soshiegirl

The website is NOT easy on they eyes but I do love their Juicy Sweet Cherry, Orange Creamsicle, and J&J Bedtime Bath.

TT's - Tonic, Provence, Egyptian Dragon, Inlet Lakegrass Community Candle/Fragrance Buddy - Avobath Candle Scent - Chocolate Cake

The best carrot cake I ever used was by Fragrance Oil Heaven. They were bought out by Elements who subsequently dropped the scent. It smelled identical to the real thing. As for cheesecake, I've not found a plain cheesecake that was awesome but I do like Just Scent's and CS's Blueberry Cheesecake.

I've had both. Candle Cocoon's Ooey Gooey Caramel is super strong so you'll need to cut back on the amount you add...for real; it can be overpowering and slightly stinky if you don't. It smells really rich and creamy...I would love to drink the bottle or bathe in it (don't judge!). Kickin Caramel is delicious as well. I find that it's sweeter smelling and lighter than Ooey Gooey Caramel. I use kickin caramel more as it's easier to blend with other scents because it doesn't drown out the other scents.

If you want a sample of Vanilla Cotton, just PM me. It's a really great scent. You haven't even touched Pure Fragrance Oils, Bulk Apothecary, Southern Scentations, TriState, Texas Candle Supply...oh my the list just goes on, doesn't it?!

Do you want me to send you a ounce sample to play with? If so, just PM me. I've got your covered!

The vanilla cotton from Lonestar is really good. I only order two oils from them and that's one of them.

I love the Snickers coffee. You might want to try Bulk Apothecary; they carry Snickers coffee too and it's throw is super powerful.

Moonstar - Candy Crush is so good. I keep a bottle just for myself.

Cajun's Oatmeal Raisin Cookie is delicious.

ICS Baked Apples is delicious. It's a former Snowtop scent. I like to add a little bit more pie crust to it to liven it up! I agree with Belinda, I think RE's Homemade Apple Pie (formerly KY Candle) is if not identical is super duper close to ICS Baked Apples.

Vanilla Snowflake type - Although this is a very good one, I think I like Aroma Haven's just a tad bit more. I'm going to go downstairs and sniff between the two just to make sure. Buttercream Crunch - A sweet delicious delight. You may also want to check out their Vanilla Buttercream Crunch too (so sweet and decadent) Peppermint Bark - The only one I use. Top seller in winter and it smells just like the candy. Nice and rich with just the right combo of peppermint and chocolate. Christmas Wish - Another love. Perfect combination of sugar cookies and pine. Cotton Candy Stronger - Be on this! My favorite. It is very strong for such a typically light scent. Cotton Candy Frosting - I ordered a sample of this but haven't put it in wax yet. Heard many folks like this better than the cotton candy stronger. Things not on your list: Birthday Cake, Caramel Cinnamon Latte (super strong), Blue Cotton Candy, Chestnuts and Brown Sugar, Super Red Hot Cinnamon, Orange Chiffon cake, Serendipity, Orange Caramel Crumble, and Pink Lemonade...just to name a few.

I would too..perhaps even 5! That Chocolate Nut Brownie is down right delicious.

Any chance you might consider sending in chocolate nut brownie?

Hey B - That's the only one I use from them. It's so good!

Try Northstar's Sugar Cookie or NG's Sugar Cookie.

Daystar's Cake Bake is delicious also.

You should try Candlewic's Sugared Vanilla Shortbread; it's the original and smells so good!

If you want a sample to play with just let me know.

Try ICS Vanilla Smoothie, it's wonderful on it's own and makes a great blender; a nice sweet smooth vanilla. Vanilla custard is delicious. There's also sugar milk (Dulce de Leche)

For a straight buttercream - Daystar Buttercream Frosting. I used to also love their pink buttercream frosting but it's been discontinued. I found Just Scent's Cotton Candy Stronger to be really good; it's super popular. JS Blue Cotton Candy is really good too.

Her Comptoir sud Pacifique dupes are on point. Belinda is correct, her vanilla bean cookies is vanilla bean noel. Other goodies include brown sugar, buttercream frosting, blackberry cookies, marshmallow, cake bake, salty sailor, cabana boy, innocent grace (pure grace), ginger lime and sweet pumpkin to name a few.

Moonstar, I think those are great names. Just jibing off Moonstar's names....Mermaid's Dream, Seaside Floral, Poisenden's Tale, Neptune's Breeze (can you tell my son just finished a lesson on Greek and Roman history?). Sorry, I suck at names too!

Any one find a replacement for TCS's chocolate nut brownie?

You may want to check out Genwax aka candlemakingsupplies.net. They are out of Southern California.