You should give CC a try- complex scents- not all are earthy types (I'm like you, I prefer the bakery, sweeter scents, and really can't stomach the musky/patch scents)- but she has others that are wonderful. I've just had to dig in the try them, if you wants some recs, just let me know! (her Sultry Angel is a wonderful sugar cookie type fo). Also, you have to try SC, MC and Elements...