I'd say if 3 people are smelling something, it's probably there. We get fo nose and it's hard for us to really detect scents when we are in it working. If I use my respirator mask while working, I smell better as things cure. You could also just smell things differently, you may like a scent that others do not. I've not smelled Black Amber Musk so I can't really help but the name indicates to me a very earthy smell.