Belinda

I like Vanilla Bean Noel from WSP and also Mrs. Claus Cookies from NG and Vanilla Bean Cookies from Daystar which is pretty much the same but maybe VBC and MCC has a slight more bakery note. They are almost an identical smell though. All are good.

@Waxing Poetic, please update when you get them in wax! I'm anxious to hear your results. I haven't looked to see what new oils they've added but I think they add quite frequently.

I have really liked what I got from Studio and Muddy both. I haven't put anything much in wax but they all smell good to me OOB. I haven't noticed any off smells from the FO from Studio but it could be that I'm not sure what I'm supposed to be smelling? So far from Muddy I got Idgie Threadgood, Lemon Pound Cake, After 5, Night Watch, Peach Bellini, Bazooka, which I can't smell any bubblegum at all but could be me, and Castaway. So far from Studio I really like Salted Caramel Apricot, and strawberry and peach gelato and their cucumber melon. Those are the only ones I can think of off the top of my head that I've put in wax.

This oil is so yummy! It smells the same as Mrs. Claus Cookies from NG which is their version of VBN. Wax used 4625/6006 in clams. CT-Great HT-8 out of 10

This is one of the best apple cinnamon fragrances I've found. I love it! Wax used: 4625:6006, KY parasoy tart wax CT-10 HT-10

Texas Candle Supply has one of the best leather scents. It's comparable to the one from Lone Star. If you're looking for a good leather this is it. They ship fast too! Wax used: 4625/6006 CT-Great HT-Great

I think you'll love their oils and they are also wonderful to deal with!

Like pcbrook said you can't fit very many in a 4 ounce jar. I use polypropylene bags and plastic containers to mix mine in. Make sure the plastic has the number 5 on it (although I'm not sure if this really matters since Fragrance oils come in bottles that don't have a 5) but just to be safe. I mix 8:2 ratio. You will need a scale to measure the weight of the beads and FO. Shake them every day and when they're dry they're ready to bake.

There are a lot of people that believe this helps but I've never found it to make a difference in my fresheners. I personally think once they're dry they're ready to bake. But like you I've read this in different groups but just never felt like it made a difference. But who knows, we all get different results using the same things at times! What doesn't work for one might be the missing thing for someone else.

That's good to know! I loved the FO's I bought from them.

Also there's a new one Called Midwest Fragrance Company. They have some great FO's.

That's a great idea! I've noticed there are others that aren't added like Pro Candle Supply and I don't think Scented Expression supplies is on the list either.

I mix 4625/6006 in equal amounts for clamshells or 4625/4630. I've never mixed all 3 together though.

I doubt I'd start out with 50/50. Maybe 75 apple and 25 crust to start with. I don't blend my apple pie scents but you're making me want to try LOL!

ICS has some good apple scents too. I think one of her apple pie scents is the same as baked apple from RE and she offers great prices for 4 ounce bottles. I happen to love apple pie from CS but like bfroberts says, it's so subjective. Oh, and ICS has pie crust too in case you want to try to blend one!

I see where there are some sellers on etsy that offer it. NG has peanut butter cookie so maybe you could add some chocolate to a peanut butter scent? Indigo also has a peanut butter scent.

Please share what you find out. I'm in Cleveland, Texas, not too far from you! I am interested in what is offered in Texas too.

The para/soy tart wax is great for both. It's a good wax to start with for sure for both.

The best prices on clams that I've found is from Virginia Candle, Maple Street and Fillmore Container. I'm thinking the ones from Virginia were the best priced including shipping. They sell them by the case of 700 for $95.00, Fillmore's are .35 each or $112 for a case of 700. I've used clams from all three of them and they're the same exact clams.

I need to check my Aztec stash and see if I have it from them. I like the one from NG but it seems lighter than the one from Cajun but I don't really need anything from them so I hated to place an order for just that. Thanks!

I have the one from NG and it's nice OOB but I also tried the one from Cajun and it seemed stronger and had a little bit of a different smell to it. Has anyone tried the one from NG and found a stronger one before I place an order with Cajun? Thanks!

Do you plan on using clamshells or pouring into molds? If clams then my favorite blend is 4625/6006 at 50/50. For shapes I like using 4625 alone or 4794 which would also mix well with 6006 for clams. I mentioned in your other post that there's a para/soy tart wax that several suppliers sell that is easy to work with and comes in a pellet form and a great wax, especially for beginners but even seasoned tart makers use it. You can get it from Flaming, Virginia, Just Scent, Rustic Escentuals, Scented Expressions and I'm sure other places. It works well for clams and shapes. Like someone else said pick the one that has the cheapest shipping to you. Where is your location? I'm in Texas and can order from Flaming, Virginia, Lone Star and Aztec with about the same cost in shipping.

I agree with Karen. These are questions that everyone has a different opinion about. Personally, I think Flaming is a great place to start too. I would recommend trying their tart wax, Problend 650. It's a para/soy blend. It holds a lot of fragrance and easy to work with. It'll work for shapes and clams. You can go from there as to whether you want to use an all paraffin or all soy wax as you learn more about the craft. You can get this same wax from several different suppliers. Virginia candle, Just Scent and Rustic Escentuals, and Scented Expressions are four that I know that carry the same exact wax for tarts and I'm sure there are more. As far as who has the best fragrances, you're going to find that every supplier has great FO's and duds and those are subjective too. For instance, I think the best birthday cake comes from Keystone (Peak) or Fragrance Buddy, and I don't care for birthday cake from Aztec, ICS or Lone Star, but a lot of people love their birthday cake fragrance. You'll find a lot of great information on here that will help you through your journey. Welcome to your new addiction! These are some of my favorite suppliers in no particular order: Aztec Flaming Texas Candle Supply Nature's Gardens Midwest Fragrance Company Candle Science Just Scent Fragrance Buddy Indiana Candle Supply Scented Expressions and Pro Candle Supply are new to me and I've loved their fragrances too. And there are many more but I can't think off the top of my head.

I'm so glad you're feeling better! I hope you have many more good days ahead, getting better every day. I think these threads can be archived but I have no idea how to do it. Maybe copy and paste the conversation into a word document? I need to send you some of my wax to test for me since you are the wax melt queen LOL!

I don't have many of their scents but I like their Pumpkin Pie and Sissie's sugar cookie. It's a lighter sugar cookie that some suppliers use as snicker doodle but it smells good. I also love their All Hallow's Eve. I see that they're getting Blueberry Sugar and I'm dying to try that one but hate that I don't order from them more. Shipping is too high for me.