i don't know which ones you are considering, but JBN's are very different from each other. brown sugar and fig has a clean smell to it, slightly green, but not sweet. i like it, but will probably rename it. chestnuts & brown sugar is really good in soy and rocks in tarts. a great fall scent. nutty, a pinch of salt and sweet...i smell almond when i smell it oob. i have some peeps that like this one year round in their cabins.