Some people's facial skin is more sensitive than others. I cannot use any type of soap on my face, not even facial "cleansers" from the store. What type of oils are you using for the oil cleansing method? Castor draws the impurities out, and too much can be irritating (it is to me). You'll have to find the right balance of oils for your own skin, so try different % of different oils. I used to use DHC's Olive Oil Cleanser, but it got too expensive for my taste after a while. I loved the way it was water dispersable, which meant it rinsed off cleanly, leaving no oiliness behind on my face, but still left it feeling moisturized. After researching, I formulated my own water dispersable oil cleanser for my own use. No more break outs, no more redness, or burning irritation, rashes, or skin peeling. And I get to use the oils that my skin loves. ETA: after reading your reply, not sure what's going on since you haven't used the soap on your face..... ??? Did you by chance maybe have raw soap on your hands, and then rubbed your face? I don't know, but that's sure kinda puzzling.