I, too, am a major fan of BNL/BCN Cucumber Melon. the old Alabaster carried Cucumber Melon also and to my nose it was exactly the same of BNL/BCN. I have not tried Community Candle's CM since their taking over Alabaster, but she did say her oils are the same. Anyway -- since Community has so many great ones, I just wanted to mention that the CM might be worth a sample. BTW - are there any strong "true" non-candy watermelons out there?