I've only tried Peak's Amish Harvest, but I'm impressed. Actually, I was on the fence about it for a while and didn't pour any candles last year. I recently pulled out a soy (cb135) candle that has to be at least 2 and maybe 3 yrs old. I haven't made container candles in that long, and I figured that all I would enjoy was the glow. This candle was on my screened porch at my beach house, and the scent was beautiful not only on the porch but in the entrance living room. I became a believer.