People make all kinds of crafts at Christmas. In fact, they sell candlemaking kits at many craft stores, so I respectfully disagree with Top's statement. I actually commend ashleylynn8888 for seeking out a candle forum, looking for advice from professionals in an attempt to make a safer, better candle for gift-giving. I was never completely happy with the burn on got on my apothecaries, so I can't give you much guidance there. You can always try the other wicks you might have, but the best bet might be to order some additional ones to try. Here's some suggestions from the Wax and Wick Suggestions in the Archives: 16 oz: J223 wax - 51zinc wick J223 wax - (two) HTP-104 wicks J223 wax - (two) HTP-83 wicks ECO 135 wax - ECO 12 wick no wax listed - (two) 51-32-18z wicks Here's another thread discussing wicking those bad boys, and you'll find some additional suggestions at the bottom of the page. Let us know how it pans out -- and welcome to CT