ashleylynn8888

Again, I was not trying to offend/call-out anyone... which is why I didn't mention any names. I was simply asking for opinions on the age of these oils... not the seller! I find it strange that before it was brought to anyone's attention who the seller was, everyone said that the oils sounded like they are probably old; and now that they know who the seller was they are all offering reasons for their aged qualities. I never said they smelled 'skunky' I said they smell 'off'. Just because I'm a newbie to this board does not mean I don't have the right to post my opinions or questions without getting browbeaten (or that I 'forgot how to use the brain God gave me'). Were you not all newbies here once too? Lets move on...

I did not "slander" anyone-- I made no mention of a name whatsoever. I simply asked those who are more 'experienced' for their opinions regarding the age of the oils. I have brand new bottles of some of these exact same oils that smell and look noticeably different.

And no answers to PM's HOW RUDE!

And for the record, the ad said: "All smell fine. Kept in cool dark cupboard."

Unfortunately, yes, I bought them off here. I was skeptical but bought them based on seller's abundance of positive feedback. Even the labels look old and the bottles are covered in dust. Lesson learned I guess. Is it typical to express disappointment to the seller in cases like this??? Thanks for helping a (naive) newbie out! :smiley2:

I spend a decent chunk of change and ordered some FO from the classifieds and when they arrived today I was disappointed. They are all dark in color and smell 'off'... some smell like vinegar, and some smell like thick old lady perfume. Not a single one in the bunch smells good. I have always ordered new FO and am a noob so I don't really know the characteristics of old/improperly stored oils. Did I get ripped off?

Just wondering what your favorite (or best selling) Spring scents are?

What a productive day you had! I bet my husband is glad we don't live close to a supply store! haha!

You all are so helpful! I'm definitely going to try the Country Gift Shop... I've never ordered from them before, so if anything, I'm learning about new places to shop! ; ) Thanks again!

Mrs. Claus' Cookies- NG Iced Cinnamon Rolls- NG Harvest- LS And I agree, NG's patchouli does smell like dirt... yuck.

To be a little more specific, she is wanting the 'smell' of the little, privately owned, home decor shops... That carry the barn stars, berry swags, specialty candles, wreaths, etc. I have NG's Home Sweet Home and Potpourri.... I will sample the others you mentioned. I appreciate the suggestions!

Awesome! Thanks Natalie!

The scent that they spray in their stores (every 30min.) is Fierce.

My mother-in-law requested a candle smelling like all of the country-home type shops she goes to. Any suggestions??? Thanks!

You guys have been very helpful and I now have many options to explore... the 1st reply got me discouraged enough to throw in the towel, but I'm glad I didn't. Thank you for taking the time to help! ashleylynn