i don't want to take away from this discussion...but... i know a lot of us are looking for dupes of TSW.. I just tested AH/RE Main Street Christmas...to my nose it smells a lot like TSW Christmas tide.. I know I love Christmas tide, and only have a few oz. left..so I was happy to find one so close. i think i may have a sample of Provence...i will look, if someone needs it to have duped..