I had to make an order for something at Miami-Erie and just picked up a sample of Caramel Apple. It is wicked strong, and smells good, however, has a very off celery note to it. Maybe it is the tart apple not sweet, but the caramel doesn't smell buttery either. I thought I had candle nose because I had been pouring all day but I decided to do a test burn and my daughter who has no real scent distinction said....Yum are you cooking celery? Great. Anyone else notice this?