From your list I've tried brown sugar pecan, caramel apple, chocolate chip cookie dough and nana's old fashioned apple butter. The cookie dough one didn't have a knock your socks throw for me- did throw, just didn't knock me down like I like or like the others I've tried from your list. The nana's old fashioned apple butter should be moved to a must have IMO- it's YUM and perfect for fall! The caramel apple is excellent- out of all the caramel apple ones I've tried, this one is my favorite.