Marleigha

Hello ladies! I am currently looking for the best Lemon Cookie FO. I know there’s Iced Lemon Cookie from Aztec & Lemon Sugar Cookie from Flaming Candle.... I have 1 oz samples of them both. I just haven’t put them in wax yet. I think the one smells best OOB and my friend thinks the other one smells best OOB. Just need to put them into wax ASAP. I also heard about Lemon Icebox Cookies from ICS..... And I know there’s many others.... 🤩 What do ya’all think? Who makes the best lemon cookie fragrance oil? Of course, everything is subjective. I would just like to get an overall opinion from the wonderful people here on CS. Thanks so much in advance! 😇

Oh wow! The Aveda Rosemary Mint sounds nice! How does this one differ from the regular rosemary mint? Her Orange Caramel Crumble is reallly nice! I tried this one because of Belinda and Jenniwix and I love it! The vanilla sugar waffle cone cone is honestly pretty light, but I do still use it as a blender. Like @soshiegirl I also use a lot of FO’s from Becky.... She is in Ohio with me. So just LMK if you so need more suggestions/opinions. I’m sure between me, Soshie & Belinda you’ll pick up some amazing FO’s from JS. They are like many suppliers some duds, some good ones, and some outta this world! Looking forward to your warm reviews as I know your candles are OUT OF THIS WORLD! Not only performance wise but looks wise!!!!! 🥰 💁🏼‍♀️

I think our brains are in the same wave length! I have been looking for Palo Santo now for about 3 weeks or so. I was never interested in it before, but one of my friends said it’s amazing so I want to get it to try it. I did just email Julie to ask her if it will be available to order soon and let her know about this thread here at CS. I hope she can get it ASAP!

Yes! I have so many darn Vanilla’s. I bet I have 15, 1# bottles of different vanilla FO’s. I do like NG Mrs. Claus Cookies, but I do also like CC Vanilla Voodoo..... However, they are very different to my nose. Mrs. Claus Cookies definitely has that bakery vibe to it, where the Vanilla Voodoo does not. I am local to WSP so I have smelled it OOB just haven’t tested in yet in my parasoy blend. Will definitely do that eventually. 👍🏼

So true! I am a happily married woman, to an amazing man for 23 years, but goodness gracious that image of that man is just scrum-dilly-icious! Come- eeethhh here cowwwwboy! 😂. It’s all in good fun though.... 👍🏼🤣

Welcome Brenda. Glad you joined Craftserver. Trust me, I understand, as do all of the other busy ladies here... Life happens! God Bless! 😇

Tested in: Wax Melts Description: This is a moonworks original fragrance. I have tried the dupe of it from another supplier but the original is far better in my wax! It’s one of my favorite fragrances from PFO. It’s so sexy & just an amazing smell. Excellent cold/hot throw! Wax used: Parasoy blend Fragrance load (%): 9% Average cure time: 2 weeks Wax additives: None Container: N/A Wick: N/A Cold throw: VERY GOOD (10 out of 10) Hot Throw: EXCELLENT (10 out of 10)

Would love to hear your thoughts on what you ordered @Lizzy 😊 And I couldn’t agree with you more about the Cactus Flower & Jade, Hibiscus Palm and Magnolia & Peony. I ordered all 6 of the new ones but these 3 were also my personal favs. All feminine yet powerful scents!

@Trappeur if you like pumpkin in general you will most likely love it! It’s one of the most unique pumpkin fragrances I’ve ever smelled. And so unexpected! Also their Cowboy FO is WOW! And the picture they have posted for it is as well. 😜

I second the LS French Market! Such a gorgeous floral! And for me, florals can give me a headache sometimes. But this one is done so well.

Hi @Sebleo I agree with many of the suggestions that everyone has said. Just to give you another opinion, I would personally suggest the following: Lonestar, Blueberry Cobbler- This fragrance oil is a shining star in my wax! Just perfect! I do however agree with @Belinda that CS Blueberry Cheesecake is good also. The difference that I notice with them is you can definitely detect more of the bakery note is the LS Blueberry Cobbler but with the CS Blueberry Cheesecake is more of a rich creamy blueberry. Key Lime Pie- Totally biting off of Belinda’s original suggestion here but woah.... YES! Key Lime Pie!!!! Both the Key Lime Pie FO’s that I have tried have been great! Which are Key Lime Pie from RE & NG. But my personal favorite is the one from NG. It’s just so stinking creamy and powerful! I know you said that you hadn’t had much luck with NG FO’s but I have tested this one in 2-3 different wax blends and it has performed quite nice in all of them. Pure Fragrance Oils, Sugar Cookie- Now I have tried maybe 9-10 different sugar cookie FO’s, including Sugar Cookie Royal from FB. Prior to trying the Sugar Cookie from PFO, SCR from FB used to be my favorite, well that one and Sugared Vanilla Shortbread from CW. Now they are both on the back burner! @katmeltswax can also confirm this. It’s is so darn rich & creamy and just overall an amazing Sugar Cookie! FB Pumpkin Pecan Waffles or CS Pumpkin Soufflé- I agree with @moonshine about having a pumpkin option. And I agree with @Trappeurthat pumpkin is definitely a year round seller! I’m definitely one that will melt pumpkin wax year round. I ❤️ pumpkin scents as you can do so much with them too. You can add it to coffee, bonfire or fireside, vanilla, sugar cookie, birthday cake, etc.... I just love pumpkin! Oh and I too really like LS Drunken Punkin! Such a nice FO! CS Cinnamon Bun- At first I was going to suggest an Apple Pie FO. But if you get Cinnamon Buns, it will allow you to either offer Cinnamon Bun by itself or you can add a small percentage of an apple FO and create your own Apple Pie blend. I also really like the suggestion from @GailCfor the Caramel Pecan Pie from Aztec. It smells really nice! Caramelized Pralines from CS is also great! I have never tried it myself but I have heard great things about Aztec Black Strap Molasses that @aptommo suggested too. Katmeltswax also loves that one and speaks highly of it all the time. Anyhoo.... If you need anymore that we’re not mentioned just LMK. I apologize for my 177 paragraph response. 😂 HTH! 😇💞

Oh I was actually just on their site trying to edit my cart right before I hopped on here and it’s definitely still there. They have 7 new ones that are 15% off, as well as the 6 quick buy fragrances that are 15% off. I was over there editing my cart for the 2nd time this evening. I’m one of those people that it takes 3-4 days to finalize my cart. LOL I really need to try to get it finalized ASAP just to make sure I get the 15% off. In any event, LMK what ones you end up getting. I know I’m excited to try the Almond Milk & Honey and to get more of my Green Cactus.

I apologize @Sebleo I thought I left my comment the other day and come back today to check the forum and just realized I never hit send. 😬. In any event, I’m actually glad that it worked out the way it did because NOW there’s actually an even better deal for us on the Green Cactus! 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 It’s on sale for 15% off on a special buy! (There’s a new section on the left side of the website that says special buys). I will definitely be stocking up! They also has 4-5 other ones in the special buy section which are all also 15% off. 😳🤗 The only one I haven’t tried in the special buys is the Almond Milk & Honey one so I’m gonna be trying that one this time! Anyhoo, just thought I’d let you know that Green Cactus is on sale. Hope you have a great day! Lmk what ones you order. 😇.

I have always used the Lilac from Candle Science and love the performance in my parasoy wax. I do also like the smell of NG Lilac OOB but have not tested it in my wax, only smelled it at the NG store.

I can’t speak to the fireside (type) or the firewood, but the campfire is CRAZY strong and legitimately smells almost exact to the burnt smell from a campfire or the smell on your clothes when your sitting next to a smokey campfire. Which is exactly what I was personally looking for. It’s excellent when mixed, especially with vanilla FO’s. But if I were to try one more out of the firewood or the fireside, I too would choose the fireside type. 😇.

Hi @Candybee! Thank you for the heads up on the Fresh Waterfall Mist. Im definitely going to have to grab some now as well as some of their LMAO as @Sarah S said it was really great! I was also told by one of my other friends that FMW is a beautiful scent and she likes it too. I inquired about the FWM and this is what I was told..... We purchased a lot of the Fresh Waterfall Mist & Lick Me All Over fragrance when we were told it was being discontinued by the manufacturer, we added it to the clearance section to sell off 35 lbs of the original fragrance. Since we had enough on hand, we've been working to get it duped & reformulated with no phthalates. Once we are satisfied with the duplication, we will bring it in if we have enough interest for it from our customers. In the meantime, we sold off the 35 lbs & we added the remainder back to our regular section, while awaiting the final testing on the new duplication. So this is great news for everyone that has used it for so long and loved it. One thing I have noticed about PFO is they do not 1/2 step. Literally everything I have bought from them I’ve been extremely satisfied with. It just seems like all of their fragrances are very potent but in a good way! Anyone have any other suggestions?

Oh I’m excited for you! Can’t wait to hear what you got and to hear your thoughts on them. I have been so happy with literally everything I’ve got thus far. Keep us posted. 😇

Ahhh.... See I think this is why I was always afraid of Witches Brew.... I don’t like anything that smells like Black Licorice. Is it a strong black licorice or is it barely noticeable that it’s black licorice? I like Patchouli but dislike black licorice smells so much! And the LMAO sounds fab! I for sure have to try that one. And yes the new ones including the Bourbon And Guinevere's Attraction are on my list! The Fresh Picked Plum & Kickin’ Kumquat are ya the tippy top! I just know they will be great!!! I will certainly keep you posted with any more that I get.

@Daisymay66 I hope your having a great weekend! I myself do not use straight soy. I use a parasoy blend. However, I can tell you with confidence that I am just loving the oils from PFO. Not only are the ones I’ve tried really strong but they are also really unique! Just to think when my friend first told me about them I said nooooo!!! 😂. I didn’t want yet another supplier! But now I can’t imagine not buying from them! ❤️❤️❤️ PFO!

Well darn darn darn..... 🙈. I didn’t want to read but I just couldn’t stop reading!!!! 😂 I’m definitely addicted to buying way more FO’s than I need. I’ve never even looked twice at Elements. My curiosity is certainly piqued! In regards to a great Rose FO, I personally strongly suggest Rose Geranium from RE. It smells exactly like a real rose and has an amazing hot throw in parasoy. 😇

I too like the peach nectar from CS, but to me it’s more of a canided peach rather than a real authentic fresh peach. But it is still great.... @PeggyK The raspberry burst from BC does this smell like the actual fruit/authentic or slightly candied? TIA! 😇

@Barbara AL Yes definitely very different. I do also like Energy from BB, but yes PFO’s Morning Sunrise is stunning! Just the slight touch of mint makes it a very relaxing spa type scent. So glad you had this one recreated! Wonderful! But yes Pure Fragrance oils is the sole owner of all the original Moonworks fragrances. Rhonda sold them to PFO as she is no longer is in the fragrance oil business. HTH! 😇

Please keep us posted ladies about the samples you all are testing. 😊. Still have a few days and if they are good I’d possibly like to grab a few.

Wow! So what were the 4 fragrances you ordered? And woah that was fast shipping that’s for sure! 😍

Tested in: Wax Melts Description: This is a wonderful fragrance. I typically use 9% in my parasoy blend but this one is so darn strong that you really only need 6-6.5%. It certainly has a phenomenal throw in my blend. Wax used: Parasoy blend Fragrance load (%): 6.5% Average cure time: 2 weeks Wax additives: None Container: N/A Wick: N/A Cold throw: VERY GOOD (10 out of 10) Hot Throw: EXCELLENT (10 out of 10)