When this thread got bumped up and I read it I thought - what the hell, try it, you're still looking for a good pumpkin. Well, I got it today. OOB I went - ehh - but then I put it in wax! WOW!! I absolutely LOVE it!! This is def what I had been looking for!! Plus, I got some of their Maple Pecan - I can't wait to make Pumpkin Maple Pecan Soap this weekend!! YAY!!!! :yay: