Thank you all for responding! This board is so wonderful when we need some help. I was worried that you guys wouldn't understand my description.....but you all knew what I was talking about. It is so great talking to people who know where you are coming from. Smells is what we do, lol, it does matter to us! So ok. I have been using NG's for years. People are CRAZY about this scent. I love it too, BUT I want the scent to stay the same when burning. I know that is difficult with many fragrances. I have tried CS and Berts to compare with NG's. I was having those candle nose days when trying to compare. They burned well and threw well, but I didn't actually have a candle by candle HT test. Now I am out of oil to do another side by side test. It is good to know many of you liked CS. I buy quite a few other oils from them. How about Berts? Anyone crazy about hers? I made a few testers with hers, but am just not thrilled. Just wondering if it's my nose or if this isn't the true Apple Jack & Peel I am searching for. I do believe I am searching for the Original AJ & P from Claire Burke. I worked in the fragrance/cosmetic dept at JCPenny when this first came out. That is what I have in my head that it is supposed to smell like. It looks like I will have to try AH/RE and again CS!