I really think that I am totally addicted to this company! MMS scents are to die for and they ship SO quickly from across the country. I have never had a single issue with them. I am anxiously awaiting an order right now from them and hopefully it will arrive today.
I have tried many of their closeout scents. I have mixed feelings. Some are good, but just as many are not. I do not like the Water Lily and Violet and Birch at all. The Pumpkin Pie is great though. Those are the only ones on your list that I have tried. The only ones on closeout that I currently use are the Lemon Pound Cake and Chocolate Brownie.
Have you considered making it scentless or with very low scent? Then you can add in a moisturizing oil in place of the scent. I have done this many times with success.
I had all of my Select Shades tested when this rumor started. I am lucky to have access to a biologist, but I still had to pay for it. Mine were fine with not a single thing wrong and I had different batches. I also have never had a single problem ordering from TW's. But I have had a few horror stories from some beloved suppliers. You have to go based on your own experiences and so I must say that all of mine have been positive with TW's.
WSP does have fantastic clear base. But you do have to watch the FO or you will have clear light yellow base. This happened when I used orange EO and orange FO.
I cannot stand patchouli and oakmoss, but I am used to them. I also detest hyacinth and anything with lime in it. Clover also is a big yuck for me, as well as cotton candy and pink sugar.