Okay...little late now but...I must have been tired last night but...I read that you got the water calulated 10 to 15 oz lye 5.49to5.32 from the sooz calc and you got the water calculated 6.8 lye at 2.24 oz at MMS That's why I punched in the numbers at MMS...didn't do sooz. Not sure about the recipe though...I'm not good at what looks right and what doesn't...when I used to make soap...I just used what I wanted to use, ran through calc and made the batch. sorry couldn't have been more help. Anyway, still doesn't seem right about the 6.8 oz of water and the 2.24 oz of lye...'cause that seems more for a one pound batch..not the 39 + oz you have.