Have you already tried Apple Jack & Peel, Blueberry Muffin, Hot Cocoa, Peppermint Kiss, Sugar Cookie, Warm Apple Pie? Amish Harvest - nice, strong Buttermint Candies - smells good OOB, but didn't think many would like... Frosted Carrot Cake - very very sweet! Yummy too! Green Clover & Aloe - haven't tried, but wouldn't think of as a "wintery" scent Home For the Holidays - holiday scent, not much of a Christmas tree smell fan though Mountain Lake - good for the men Sage & Lemongrass - nice, but wouldn't think too much of a "wintery" scent either Spruce Christmas Tree - haven't tried Sugar Plum Berries - haven't tried myself, but have smelled and I don't like it Wild Cherry - haven't tested, but really strong OOB