Well, I'm less than pleased with these. They looked wonderful and smelled awesome! BUT...they never did get very hard...hard but crumbly I guess I should say. Even more than that though...they sucked in the tub. Yes, they fizzed and did their thing, but other than the scent and the cloudy bath water, you would never know that I'd put anything in. The bath melts I make are wonderful and make my skin soft...not the bath cookies. I'm going to play with the recipe some and maybe combine the bath melt and bath cookie recipe to come up with something in between. The look of the cookies is adorable but the skin softening properties of the melts are way better. Oh, and here's a picture