I am going to make this again and try uping the liquid soap in one batch and adding SLSA in another batch. It has been almost a week and still very, very little suds when you use it. I don't know enough about butters and I might be showing my stupidity, but I cannot see where using Shealoe butter would have that affect. But like I said, I am soooooo new to this that it just shows my ignorance too!! I don't have any other butters so if it is by chance the Shealoe butter, what could I use in place of the butters in the recipe?