I use several of their oils, I'm dissapointed to hear about the pink sugar, I love that one! I recently had the same problem with the lilac. It came in a different color and didn't smell as true as the other one. Bummed me out. I think once I am done with that one, I'm going to try Berts! The other oils I get from there I love, especially the Pineapple upside down cake, YUM!