One of my biggest sellers is a squarish container without the lid. At first, I was cutting out an insert to prevent dust and stuff but found it really wasn't needed. If for some reason, someone wants a better "hit" of the scent, I let them smell the same scent in a tin. I have a retail store so people tend to get fragrance overload and sometime think they do not smell the candles without the lid. Does that make sense? Even though that container does not have a lid, people love the style of it. I carry both obviously and I am currently looking into another container...with a lid