I have had the liquid red dye for @ 1 yr. The left over candle I made last yr. smells great! Now this season I have duplicated the red dye, Warm Apple Pie, w/ J-223. Same-O-Same-O-. But the fuel smell is awful. Poured 1#,let it set. stunk,then started from scratched, poured it, stunk, tried again still stunk... Not just me now!!!Tried diff. temps. diff. scents, w/ 3 # of wax + dye + FO But it is the liquid dye I'm sure. Now what?? I have wasted soooo much money.(9 oz. jars inc.) Does the red liquid not last as long as the other colors? Any info or bitching appreciated:undecided