That quote seems exceptionally high. I ship UPS from Ohio to New England almost weekly since that's where most of my wholesale accounts are. I just sent a 26 lb box yesterday and it was 14 bucks. A couple of weeks ago, I sent a shipment that was split into 4 boxes and weighed a total of 110 lbs. and the total was $53. Any time you take your packages to a retail outlet, they hike up the price. You should get an account with UPS, pack your items yourself and you can drop them anywhere that UPS picks up daily. You can even flag down a driver and give it to him!!! It is a whole lot cheaper to do it this way. As for splitting an order, I would rather be safe than sorry. If I'm figuring correctly your candles would be over 50 lbs. I think something that heavy would risk bursting the box. (Every time I get in a case of wax, the box is split open)!! UPS will help you set up an account. It's very easy and they will just send you a bill weekly or you can pay with credit card as you go. So much cheaper than taking it someplace to send it. Nancy