Ruina, I certainly don't mind at all telling you how I got that shade of color. The supplies I bought to make that soap basically came from an international food store we have in Ottawa. I used shortening (crisco), coconut oil, palm oil, grapeseed oil and olive oil and superfatted with castor oil. Now the palm oil I bought from this store was not white like I got from the supplier I ordered from before (soap making supplier). When I saw it at this store I thought to myself "is this going to work" because it was quite orange. I looked at the label and there were no additives at all in it so I decided to try it and thought well I best make an orange colored soap, hence the reason I decided on the orange chocolate. Now when I melted all my hard oils I could see that it wasn't orange really but a heck of a bright yellow/orange so I decided I better add some red liquid coloring to it to get the orange I wanted and that is what I did and voila, it worked! I used liquid coloring also in my bath bombs but I have ordered the powdered and am awaiting that order. The liquid was fine for melt and pour but with my very first batch of CP soap, the one before this one, I wanted a blue swirl :embarasse and it ended up being PURPLE!!!! Not what I was expecting that's for sure, lol. I made a foot lotion with eucalyptus/spearmint and my co-workers who are my testers are all loving it! P.S. I haven't cleaned up the top of the soap yet, except for one that is in the pic behind the flower, so that caramel color will be gone and the dark brown will be the only thing showing . I just wanted to say how AWESOME this site is and the people here. I have been browsing here for a few months and reading all your posts and am so happy to have found such great wisdom and knowledge from all of you who share with us newbies. THANK YOU! I am having a BLAST!