I know they say it has orange in it from that one supplier, so I dont think that one is it. I dont smell any orange or citrus in it at all. And like you said the onther one is closed, and the other one is an EO . . . So not much to go on there. Maybe I could add a little pine to Peaks "Sugar Plum Berries" or better yet they could do it and sell a new scent called "Christmas Berries" Well I may give that a try what the heck.