NG suggestions for CP ??

[dee263]

I have never ordered from NG and really don't need another supplier but...I can't resist any longer. I have been reading mindyw86's thread with much interest and have a few of those FOs in my cart already. The suggestions in that thread are for good FOs for candles, and while I make candles as well, I'd like to hear from soapers, though. What have you found that works well in soap, especially CP? TIA:smiley2:

Edited November 14, 2011 by dee263
clarity

[Oceangazer1]

NG has some awesome FO's. Been ordering from them for over 10 yrs now. But Amazing Grace and Endless love didn't hold in CP for me. Nice for HP and MP though! Mermaid Kisses held perfectly! Very strong. I will have to look at my list later and post then for more.

[dee263]

Thanks for the info. Knowing which ones don't work is almost as important as knowing the one's that do. I'll look forward to seeing the rest of your list.

[Kitn]

I use the following in my regular line, they are great stickers in CP.

Satsuma

Niagara Falls

Extremely Sexy Male

China Rain

Fresh Bamboo

Cucumber Cilantro Wasabi

Black Tie

Lemon Sugar

Crackilin Birch

Christmas Cabin

Cool Citrus Basil

[TallTayl]

Butterfly Hugs

Hummingbird

Black Cherry Bomb

Lime Cilantro (good as blender too)

Tibetian Amber

Egyptian Musk (it's very light, so I renamed it Light Egyptian Musk))

Mojito (good blender)

Sweet Grass (heats in mold, so be prepared)

Mardi Gras

Nutmeg (good blender)

Indian Summer is too light to even smell OOB. Skip it.

[Shar]

I only make cp soaps with their fo's and use 1 oz./ppo

Lavender Vanilla- good and strong sticker in cp, soaps well,but discolors due to vanilla

Magnolia & Orange Blossom- Very nice and sticks, No A or D

Amazing Grace- Accelerates a bit but managable, not a strong fragrance but customers like it

Loving Spell- Very good, sticks and sells well and no problems soaping

Monkey Farts- I don't like their version,looking for a better one

Honeysuckle- don't like their version much. I've found better at CS (Honeysuckle jasmine is nice) and I like MC"S Honeysuckle Vine

Cool Water- Don't bother with NG version, fades in cp.

DKNY Be Delicious Type- Nice, soaps well sticks good in cp

Aqua Di Gio- Nice, soaps well and sticks in Cp

Very Sexy for Men type- same as above

Pink Sugar- Customer favorite, but discolors like other suppliers in cp. I'd recommend

I don't like NG's OMH not fond of the Almond either though it's a strong oil

Nantucket Brier is Very nice floral that people seem to like and soaps well, no discolor

Dragon's Blood- Nice, people like it, discolors though

Cracklin Birch- Awesome in Cp, but accelerates a bit , discolors but I love it and sells great too!

I'm looking to place another order soon also...Anyone have cp reviews for

Lemon Sugar

Warm Vanilla Sugar

Pomegranate

Blue Sugar

[TallTayl]

@Shar - Blue Sugar by The Scent Works is the best of class IMO.

[number2of7]

DOES WORK WELL:

Lilac

Dragon's Blood

Hippy Christmas

Bergamot & Tarragon

Angelica

Torrential Rains

Flower Child

Green Clover & Aloe

Egyptian Dragon

Autumn Magic

Lemon Sugar (scent does fade some, but it's still doable)

DOES NOT WORK WELL:

Buttercream Cupcake -- smells like playdough to me in cp soap

Fresh Strawberry -- scent completely morphs out

Cucumber Splash -- scent fades quickly

Edited November 15, 2011 by number2of7

[Shar]

Thanks TallTayl, I've only tried the one from OnlyFragrance.net, so didn't have anything to compare it to. I like Scent Works White Peach, best I've found..most peach fo's morph in cp so next time I order I'll have to try their blue sugar then:)