Opinions please - keystone order

[The Candle Nook]

Planning my first Keystone order and this is in my cart. All are “peaks” fragrances I’ve read about on different threads here (except cranberry chutney). Anything stand out as a boo-boo or am I missing a FO that should-NOT-be-missed?

 

birthday cake

cinnamon and balsam

salty sea air (hope it’s not cologne like)

winter wonderland

tall grass

cranberry chutney (the hunt continues)

 

[BenderSF]

Peak's Amish Harvest is one of my favorites, and seems pretty popular on this forum.  (Rustic's Celtic Moonspice is a near-dupe, and Rustic's Amish Quilt is also really similar, but I like Amish Harvest the best.)

 

The only one from your cart I've tried is the Birthday Cake, which I like a lot.

[Belinda]

On 2/27/2021 at 10:40 AM, The Candle Nook said:

Planning my first Keystone order and this is in my cart. All are “peaks” fragrances I’ve read about on different threads here (except cranberry chutney). Anything stand out as a boo-boo or am I missing a FO that should-NOT-be-missed?

 

birthday cake

cinnamon and balsam

salty sea air (hope it’s not cologne like)

winter wonderland

tall grass

cranberry chutney (the hunt continues)

 

Their birthday cake is great! I have cinnamon and balsam too which I like OOB but haven't put in wax yet. I haven't smelled any of the others you have listed. I like Old Town Bakeshop too. It's lite but a good bakery scent. Bird of Paradise is good, cherries in the snow, chocolate grahams, country berry hotcakes, cranberry apple marmalade, creamy pecan praline, iced lemon danish ( I also like iced lemon cookies from Aztec and lemon biscotti from Fillmore) sea salt and cocoa bean. I've read where they have a good cream brûlée but I've never used it. I like the one from Cajun.