Ok, I've tried every marsmallow out there & I only do b&b. Here is my opinion(other peoples opinions might differ!): Taylored: burnt smell KY: to me, I get a toasted note & even a "bubble gum" note. Lonestar: a chemical note to it JS: yep, I get a cookieish note to it. WSP: I like theirs alot, but I don't know if they still carry it. At Wix End: Light, but like it,but still not "the one" CandleChem: yuck! Flickers: didn't like it(& don't know if the new people have it) Natures Garden: I like it, but it's still not "the one" Royal Aromatics: I use this one in combination w/Soap Silly's & I love it. But here is the good news: I LOVE the following two, both at Daystar: Daystar now has the SoapSilly's Marshmallow & it is awesome!!! But, I also tried Daystar's own Marshmallow & it is awesome too!!!! I call one Jet Puffed Marshmallows & the other Marshmallow Fluff. You MUST try them both!!!you will be so happy & finally stop looking for "the one".