LeahRB

Have you checked out Aztec's ecosoya pb? It states that ecosoya tells them it's the original pb formula. https://www.candlemaking.com/ecosoya-pb-pillar-blend-soy-wax-45lb-case.html

Barbara, do you prefer one over the other?

Peak's clove performed very well in 444.

It is skin safe and if my memory serves me correctly, it was awesome in cp! Oh and AH does have a ton of pumpkins. :-)

I'm going to throw another pumpkin out there--I love AH's Butternut Pumpkin. It's a sweet pumpkin with plenty of spice and a little something extra. For Halloween I love NG's Tricks or Treats. It is quite sweet. If you remember Candle Science's Spiced Wassail, it is smells very similar. Strong throw too!

I tried the Redwood fo from Aroma Haven, and although I usually have good look with their fos, this fragrance was way too light in wax.

Thank you, Belinda! I'm going to be placing an order soon and I'll just get a couple 4 oz bottles and keep my fingers crossed. I've been on a vanilla kick lately.

Did anyone ever test the Vanilla Custard in wax? I really have my eye on this one. Also, has anyone tried the Toasted Marshmallow?

I have not come across anything that smells even close. Did anyone keep some? Fragrance Buddy seems to dupe quite a few for people.

I'm so jealous! Where is your frosting? I always get some frosting with colors. I have been using pb with 444. They look very creamy and beautiful!

I like Lavender and vanilla from The Candle Source. It's good and strong in melts and people seem to love it.

Aztec's Blueberry Cobbler is the best and strongest to me.

I have a Baked Apple that mix I with orange and I call it Country Store. I think that name would work for either of those two scents. Or how about Mercantile, Country Store, Country Kitchen, Southern Home, Mulling Spices and Apple, Apple Barrel, Harvest Apple or Farmer's Market. I don't always completely match a scent to its name, sometimes I just find a name I like and go with it. It seems to work for me.

Ugh! Candle nose! I can't stand it. Lol! Hopefully you'll get your sniffer back soon!

Yes, Candybee!!! That is what I want!!!