I bought a couple of those 4-wicks mainly for cold throw and decor before my candle making days. The cold throw on the black cherry was great, but the dye!! I gave up getting the thick sticky mess completely off the holder it was placed on. Last one (& the very last one I'll ever buy) was a cucumber melon. Cold throw was decent and looked great sitting on coffee table. Upon initial lighting, one wick just shriveled up and died, one I couldn't keep going, and two were fine. Poor thing! I usually check out W-Mart's candles to see what they're peddling. Last week, they did have a tumbler candle made in the US. Don't remember details. BTW, I don't make paraffin candles, only soy... why the reaction in the above posts to granulations? I noticed some of the 4-wick W-Mart candles have quite evident granulations which come off like the clear beads on christmas-y type candles. I could be wrong here, but YC tarts seem to be made of them. Not that I'm promoting YC, but just comparing. Quite curious, Hope