I never actually got around to putting them in lip balm, but from sniffing, my opinions: Orange juicy - Wonderful! It smells exactly like a fresh orange. Merry strawberry - sweet, but more of a candy strawberry smell. Since I don't really like a straight strawberry scent, I think it's perfect. Green apple, cotton candy, & grape - these have a bit of a medicine-y smell to them. That may go away after you put them in some base though. Buttercream - delightful! It smells exactly like a cake with frosting. Quite yummy! This was my favorite. Pear - excellent! Very crisp and clean, though it smells a little bit like the apple, but no medicine smell.