Vanilla Velvet Substitute?

[stephnms]

Can anyone recommend a good substitute for BCN Vanilla Velvet? I've used Vanilla Velvet for almost two years now but lately I keep having trouble with it so I'd like to replace it with something similar.

Thanks!

[Spellkast]

I think JS's Silky Vanilla is pretty close to vanilla velvet....BUT could just be me!

[stephnms]

I'm wondering about ICS Vanilla Smoothie. Anyone tried that one?

[AngelaVA]

JS Silky "V" Vanilla is really, really close (if not the same, lol), at least in my opinion. I would definitely give it a try. I haven't tried the one from ICS, but I like their other FOs.

[Spellkast]

I use both JS's and ICS's Vanilla Smoothie. I use the ICS for candles because it smells like a heavy bakery vanilla (not like vanilla velvet in my opinion.) and I use JS's in all of my body products. It's a more straight, nice vanilla if you know what I mean! I can send you a sample of both if you'd like to try them..i think I have a cuople of empty 1 oz bottles around here somewhere.

[stephnms]

I use both JS's and ICS's Vanilla Smoothie. I use the ICS for candles because it smells like a heavy bakery vanilla (not like vanilla velvet in my opinion.) and I use JS's in all of my body products. It's a more straight, nice vanilla if you know what I mean! I can send you a sample of both if you'd like to try them..i think I have a cuople of empty 1 oz bottles around here somewhere.

That would be awesome!! Thanks so much!! I'll PM you.