I guess it would have helped if I stated why I wanted to sub Crisco:rolleyes2. I do not want to use any soy in my recipe. Doesn't Crisco contain soybean oil? I am also trying to keep the recipes vegan. Plus, like Top pointed out Crisco ingredients keep changing and it may make it difficult to know what soap properties to expect. I'll just stick with CO, PKO and Babassu. Thanks everyone for the help.