Are the same type of wicks created equal?

[rainey]

If I tested candles with an HTP #62 from one supplier -- and then order these wicks from another supplier, will my candle burn the same way????

I forgot to include these wicks in my recent order. Now, if I order them alone, it will cost me $4 in shipping.

I need to place an order with a different company and I could include these wicks in my order but if I'm not going to get the same results, I'd rather pay the $4 and have peace of mind.

What has been your experience with mixing wick suppliers?

Thanks!

[RobinInOR]

Usually, but not always. I'd test with your most "difficult" FO to see if you get the same results...

Sometimes they have a different coating that will change the burn slightly. Even worse, sometimes you can buy a new batch of wicks from the same supplier and they won't work the same!

That's happened big time twice that I can recall. A bad bunch of zincs - 51s I think? And the manufacturer 2 years ago redid the specs on HTPs so new batches burned differently...

I suggest any time you get a new batch of wicks, do a couple of tests just to make sure you aren't surprised. You'll probably be fine, but it's nice to be sure.

[VerticallyEnhanced]

I agree. I use CD wicks and have always used the same supplier. I needed some quick, so I chose a closer supplier. Their CD 12 burned more like a CD 11. I know there is not such thing as a CD 11, but it was not quiet a 10 and sure not a 12. I learned my lesson.

[rainey]

Yikes! Thanks for the info.