I use BCN's Pineapple Cilantro too. I can't pick out the cilantro when it is in wax (100% soy), but I think that's what takes away the sweet candy-like smell that other pineapple FOs have. My customers always comment about how fresh smelling and "real" this one is. I tried it in lotion too and the cilantro was much easier to detect, very different than in the candle.