Candlebuddy

Speaking on my experience only, this doesn't surprise me. I love some of their oils, but it's because of this type of thing that I don't order anymore.

1/2 Pumpkin Souffle and 1/2 Pumpkin Pie, both from Candle Science.

I agree with the Baked Apples from ICS and and Homemade Apple Pie from KY; they smell the same to me. Also if Heartfelt is still in business they have an awesome Apple Danish. I'm also really liking Apple Harvest from CS.

Birthday Cake, Dickens Christmas, Tangerine Dreams, Kudzu.

BW's Honey Gingerbread is awesome; a little Creme Brulee will do the trick. I also mix Creme Brulee with Coffee as well as Pumpkin.

Never used HZC from TSB, but I use the one from BW and it sells great. To make it a little more creamier, I add a touch of Creme Brulee from KY (now AH/RE).

I don't like the smell of Leather; but I tried mixing it with Vanilla Lace from CS and I have some customers that like it. I named it Leather & Lace.

CS carries Cedarwood Vanilla; very strong in 6006. Their sale ends tonight. It smells like cedar to me; the vanilla sweetens it up a bit but the cedar really comes through. Not musty smelling to my nose.

It's KY's at www.aromahaven.com for me. I mix it with just about everything.

Lemon Zest from Bluegrass; you can find it at Elements.

Another combo is KY's Creme Brulee and Pumpkin Pie ... this is rich and creamy. I only use KY's Pumpkin Pie to mix, and it sure is good when mixed with their Creme Brulee.

It's KY for me ... a best seller!

When I started out, I bought a starter kit from Cajun Candles. Included was wax, wicks, dye and several of their best selling scents. This worked great for me. I also spent many many hours reading the board to gather information from more experienced candle makers.

Off the top of my head ...

Winter Wonderland

Sleigh Ride

Snow Drift

Santa's Sleigh

Snow Angels

Love the name!

SnC is a company that sold to AH/RE. You're right Prim-Beginnings, it was Soap n Candles. However, Sweet n Creamy was a scent that KY used to carry. AH/RE carries it now because KY sold to them too. AH/RE has bought many candle businesses. It's a good thing, because we can still get the oils that we depend upon.

any pine or Christmas tree scent

apple

coffee

I've read somewhere on this board that a dupe of BW's Honey Gingerbread is CS's Hansel & Gretel's House.

I agree, it's different than ICS ... I like ICS much better.

Kinda hit or miss for me, but there are some fo's that I absolutely love. Sometimes I think that Loren's mother is rude when I place an order, but because I buy my wicks from them and I order several of their scents, I just deal with it. Shipping is fast and reasonable.

Twigs and Berries

So sorry number2of7 ... hopefully it will be back in stock soon.

Off the top of my head ...

Rocky Mountain Pine

Fresh Baked Cookies

Cinnamon Buns

Blackberry Sage

Citrus and Sage

Sweet Pumpkin Pie

Just want to note that I've been reading some negative comments on this board about Heartfelt's customer service. I've never had a problem, but it seems as though some have.

I love Apple Danish from Heartfelt Candle Supply; not a lot of cinnamon; more like sweet apple pie filling than anything else I've tested.

Lemon Ginger from ICS. It's a combo of Lemon Meringue and Gingerbread ... I love it.