Tina J

Thanks for the suggestions.  I wasn't even sure if I should be looking a strawberry or cherry scents. Haha.

Thanks so much. I'll check out both of them.

Thanks I'll check it out.

Anbody seen a red licorice FO anywhere or have any ideas on what to mix?

Ooh I might have to give that a try!

I just noticed they've discontinued Raspberry Macaroon. Anybody know of a good replacement?

JS Buttery Brown Sugar might work.

Thanks a lot!  I've never tried their oils before but now I will have to.  Do they ever have any sample sales?

I think JS smells EXACTLY like Scentsy's.

I make mine blue. I have too many pink scents.

Does anyone know of a sweet & creamy lemon scent? Something that's not too tart and not bakery would be great.

Just curious but are you only going to be making stuff for yourself or are you potentially going to start a business with this? Besides ingredients there are A LOT of other things to consider if you are thinking about a business--testing, insurance, etc, etc...

Are there any fo's out there that smell like Cherry Laffy Taffy?

Yummy!!!

That mix sounds incredible! Thanks for sharing!!

So Daystar has discontinued Ile Flottante

Can anyone recommend a replacement?

I recently ordered A LOT of samples from them and boy am I glad I did!! Everything was wonderful!!!

Does anyone know of anything that's smells like JS's Romeo & Juliet? I don't see it on their site anymore

I got a request for a Watermelon that smells like Jolly Ranchers. Any ideas? It would be for B&B.

Thanks!

I received my order from Soap Silly a few days ago and just got a chance to try out a few of the scents. I made everything into lotion or body butter.

Pink Buttercream Frosting - WOW!! So yummy!

Raspberry Crumb Cake - Like BBW Black Raspberry Vanilla but with a yummy, slightly spicy cake note added to it.

Hamakua Banana - The most realistic banana I've ever smelled.

Apple Strudel - Perfect. Smells more realistic than the "Hot Baked Apple Pie" scent that everyone else has out there.

That's all I've tried so far.

I also want to add that I know some people have had bad luck with Soap Silly, but I received my order very quickly. It was accurate and well packed, and I got SEVERAL free samples! I will definitely order again!

The Tropical PFruit is awesome in B&B! It smells exactly like BBW's. You won't find a closer dupe anywhere!

I LOVE this thread

Another one IMO is JS Caramelized Pralines and DS White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookies. Anyone else?

I second JS!

I just discovered that CS Very Vanilla is the same as DS Ultimate Vanilla (and CC Vanilla Voodoo, etc.)

I know Daystar had it. I think it might be discontinued now though--not quite sure. Sorry, I know I'm not much help.

Has anyone seen a dupe yet of BBW Simply Divine Cherry Pie? This really is THE BEST cherry pie I've ever smelled. Don't get me wrong there are some good ones out there. But to me they all smell to "cobblery". Like they're too tart, or too brown sugary, or too spicy. This one is juuust right. The perfect mix of sweet and tart with just the right amout of crisp, sugary crust. Mmm! Mmm!