8-GRAN-ONES Posted August 21, 2012 Share Posted August 21, 2012 yes...it is very nice of you...that is alot of work..thanks.. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
jackbenimble Posted August 22, 2012 Share Posted August 22, 2012 Elements had a scent called Olive Blossom and I swear it smells like MoonWorks Floral Muse FO. Just thought I'd add to the pile. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dana Posted September 3, 2012 Share Posted September 3, 2012 AHRE's Butternut Pumpkin smells very, very similar to JS's Frosted Pumpkin and MC's Frosted Carrot Cake.I second that! I discoved that a few years ago....I guess I should have posted. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
bells4shells Posted September 3, 2012 Share Posted September 3, 2012 Elements had a scent called Olive Blossom and I swear it smells like MoonWorks Floral Muse FO. Just thought I'd add to the pile.I may have to make this an FO triplet. I have never smelled MoonWorks Floral Muse, but Elements Olive Blossom smells the same to me as CS Rain Water. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ChandlerWicks Posted September 3, 2012 Share Posted September 3, 2012 I think you may be correct. I'll have to test the MWs against the CS FO. Much cheaper if they are the same. Thanks!I may have to make this an FO triplet. I have never smelled MoonWorks Floral Muse, but Elements Olive Blossom smells the same to me as CS Rain Water. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
jackbenimble Posted September 3, 2012 Share Posted September 3, 2012 I may have to make this an FO triplet. I have never smelled MoonWorks Floral Muse, but Elements Olive Blossom smells the same to me as CS Rain Water.I guess my nose is different because they don't smell the same to me. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
jackbenimble Posted September 3, 2012 Share Posted September 3, 2012 (edited) I may have to make this an FO triplet. I have never smelled MoonWorks Floral Muse, but Elements Olive Blossom smells the same to me as CS Rain Water.Sorry, the site or my Internet is off today. Edited September 3, 2012 by jackbenimble Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
rctfavr3 Posted September 5, 2012 Share Posted September 5, 2012 Anyone know a fragrance twin to BCN's Apple Juice. It's really mild and not at all candy like. Everything else I've tried has cinnamon notes. Any Apple Juice types? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
nursenancy Posted November 16, 2012 Share Posted November 16, 2012 Bert's Aspen Forest and Fillmore Citrus Spruce smell identical to me - or close enough to make me happy.... Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
moonshine Posted November 16, 2012 Share Posted November 16, 2012 Moonworks Pinion pine smells exact to me as CS mistletoe At least nobody in my house can tell a difference! Maybe we all have bad noses- haha Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
so-soy Posted November 29, 2012 Share Posted November 29, 2012 AH/RE Sugar Corn Pudding smells the same as BCN Amish Friendship Bread. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
marcuset Posted January 9, 2013 Share Posted January 9, 2013 (edited) **bumping thread**Aztec's Sweet Winterberry & Rustic Escentuals Frosted Winterberry Edited January 9, 2013 by marcuset Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
megandgarr Posted May 2, 2013 Share Posted May 2, 2013 Bumping this thread since I personally find it very useful and some of the newer members may as well... Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
megandgarr Posted May 2, 2013 Share Posted May 2, 2013 bumping Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Belinda Posted May 26, 2013 Share Posted May 26, 2013 I know this is probably already listed but JS country berry hotcakes and ICS Wildberry Mousse. Also, Peaks country berry hotcakes smells just like JS cbh, in my opinion.Belinda Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
8-GRAN-ONES Posted May 26, 2013 Share Posted May 26, 2013 The Scent Works..Sweet Lodge Smoke..and DayStar's..Hunters Moon smell very very much alike..to my nose..I think that Daystars is stronger....In cp soap..Daystars is much stronger, and holds the scent better..i love it in candles, candle tart warmers, and cp soap.. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
grama Posted June 21, 2013 Share Posted June 21, 2013 Candlemaker's Store (Steve's) - Silver Bells - Tennessee Candle - This Old HouseI needed This Old House and Tennessee Candles was out of stock so I ordered Candlemakers Store Silver Bells grade A and to my nose they are nothing alike - sorry. I smell pine in it I think but it is not This Old House. Just thought I would let anyone that may be looking for TOH know. Don't know if Candlemakers Store changed since the list was posted or not. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
moonshine Posted June 21, 2013 Share Posted June 21, 2013 MW gypsy rose and Elements sensuous black rose are very much alike but I can get MW to throw stronger in a candle Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
marcuset Posted November 15, 2013 Share Posted November 15, 2013 :bump: Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
megandgarr Posted March 18, 2014 Share Posted March 18, 2014 Ok, I am bringing this one back to life again. I copied the list from post 138 and pasted all posts through 169 and then added a few more. These are opinions from various members of the board. Please feel free to copy/paste the list into a new post and add your own twinsies that you have discovered. Tri-State Clean Cotton and MC High CottonJS Mimosa Mandarin and MC Magenta NectarKY--roasted coffee and ICS coffee beanKY--Wildberry Scone and ICS Wildberry----(forgot what they call theirs)KY--Southern Vanilla and SS Country Vanilla (super close, maybe identical)Missy's(JS)-- Christmas Cookie and KH (Keystone) Christmas CookieJS's-- Victorian Vanilla Lace and SS sweet snowJS-- pomegranate and BCN Pomegranate--pretty closeKY--Creme brulee and JBN Creme bruleeKeystone(KH)--Pumpkin Fudge and SS Vanilla PumpkinNature's Garden's Twigs and Berries and Tayberry and Teak Wood.Day Star's OohLaLa and WSP's Beneath the StarsWYW Perfect Pumpkin and WSP's Perfect PumpkinC&S Jade (Pier one type) and MC DreamcatcherJust Scent's Sea Mist smells just like Oceans (Pier 1)...Daystar's Decadent Orange Fluff Cake smells just like NG's Hot orange danishTW Emerald Sea and OM CalypsoPeak Jamaican Me Crazy and JS Paradise IslandHeartfelt's Enchanted, and ICS Japanese Plum!Orange Chiffon Cake-JS, Hot Orange Danish-NGBanana Split-DS, Monkey Farts-AHSerendipity-JS, Cupid-BCN/BNLFramboise Citron Cheesecake-AH, Iced Lemon Danish-PeakUltimate Vanilla-DS, French Vanilla-AH, Vanilla Voodoo-CCCandy Corn-JS, CC, BCN Eggnog-BCN, Custard-AWESilky V Vanilla-JS, Very Vanilla-BCN, Vanilla Extract-BCS, Simply Vanilla-DS, Glazed Donut-TC, Angel Food Cake-WSPCoconut Cream Pie-BCN, JSTwinkies-JS, Nanny's Country Pound Cake-DSAroma Haven Hey Hey Cute Cabana boy and DS Coconut PearMagnolia Melba from Tony's, Summer Fling from BB and Mardi Gras from OT Bayrum: OT & SWCandy Corn: TCS, KS, CC, JSChina Rain: TCS, JSRaisinbread, blahblahblah: WNW, JS, FOHCC & Daystar: Vanilla Voodoo/Ultimate VanillaTwigs & Berries: NG, StevesWNW creme brulee & NG's butter brickle - very similar. even yellows my soy wax the same wayKitchen Spice - JS & DaystarNG's Mrs. Claus Cookies and Day Star's Vanilla Bean NoelSC Watermelon = Day Star's Watermelon MartiniButt Naked from At Wix End is a slightly stronger version of Tranquil Tropics of BubblesnLights (BCN)Clean Cotton = JS, TRI-STGreen Leaf's Starla, The Scent Work's Mayan GoldPeaks Amish Harvest and Aroma Haven's Celtic Moon Spice- Very very SimiliarSanta Spruce (Brambleberry) and Sugared Spruce (the candle source)Strudel from Candle Science and Graham Cracker from Green Leaf smell exactly alike out of the bottle.Wilberry Mousse from Candle Science and Berry Creme Brulee from MilcreekNG"s Watercress and Aloe and Peak's Green Clover in AloeAGE's Salty Mariner and Peaks OceanNG's Passionate Kisses and TCS Caribbean HolidayPeak's Casaba Mist & AH's BadedasJS Grammas Berry Griddlecakes is the same as CS wildberry mousse & These are also the same as ICS Wildberry MousseSweetcakes Fig / BNL Fig MelonGreen Leafs -Indonesean Teak is the same as Flickers - Tuscan LaceDS Tropical Fruit Slices = ICS Summer MedleyKY Apple Clove Butter=Flicker's Cider SnapCS Spiced Wassail=Flicker's Autumn SpiceKY's Homemade Apple Pie ST (now ICS) Baked ApplesAH Fudge Brownie = JS Fabulous FudgeCS Wildberry Mousse and BCN and TCS Country Berry HotcakesBrambleberry's Welcome Home and Tennessee Candle's This Old HousePeaks Spruce Xmas Tree and AH's Ozark ForestGL Himalayan Blue Willow Taylored Concepts BambooTCS Pomegranate GL PomegranateCS Very Vanilla is the same as DS Ultimate Vanilla (and CC Vanilla VoodooGL/TC Pumpkin Pie SpiceGL/TC Pumpkin FrappuchinoTCS/TC Peach Raspberry MagnoliaTC/AH Coco MangoCandle Cocoon's Vanilla Voodoo ~ Millcreeks Extreme VanillaCandlemaker's Store (Steve's) - Harvest -Tennessee Candle - Amish HarvestCandlemaker's Store (Steve's) - Silver Bells - Tennessee Candle - This Old HouseUpdate: I needed This Old House and Tennessee Candles was out of stock so I ordered Candlemakers Store Silver Bells grade A and to my nose they are nothing alike - sorry. I smell pine in it I think but it is not This Old HouseMonkey Farts...NG and WixnwaxAlabaster Caribbean Fruit and Kumquat are the same..or at least used to beMuscadine--NG, WNW, Keystone, and AlabasterBlueberry Cobbler--NG, Keystone, and ICS blueberry cheesecakeAmaretto Nog--WNW, Keystone, JSMulberry-NG, WNW, ICSKudzu--Alabaster, WNW, ICSPeaks Fresh Linen and BCN Angel WingsNG Tayberry & Teakwood - BCN Twigs n BerriesSweet Tooth (AH) = Sweet Treat (JS) Aroma Haven's Sweet SeductionJS Winter SpiceBCN's Mulled Cider....Just Scent winterberry wreath and Candlescience med fig - Millcreeks Mediterranean FigCS Hazelnut and GL HazelnutJS Caramelized Pralines and DS White Chocolate Macadamia Nut CookiesTo me CC tigerlily and cantalope smell like CW white tea.Blackberry Sage from TN, TW, & KY sameMC pears n Berries LS pearberryJinglebells from TN smells like any mulberryBCN-Pomegranate and Just Scents-CupidTwigs & Berries by the following are all interchangable for each other - AWE, BC & NGBert's Aspen Forest & Flickers Balsam & CitrusAH and Js passionate kissesKY's Fresh Glazed Donuts smells like Warm Vanilla Sugar Spiced Crans at BCN & ICSKY Grandmother's Toddy and CS Hansel and Gretels HouseBCN's Dreamweaver and NG's Satin SheetsBCS Pumpkin Cheesecake and JS Pumpkin Fudge TorteMimosa and Mandarin CS and BC's Citrus SplashMillcreek Soy Candle Cozy Home smells similar to me like CS's Cranberry MarmaladeMillcreek's Cinnamon Vanilla and CS Strudel and Spice are very very alikeLonestar Sun 'N Sea and Sea Petals are identicalBCS Sissy Sugar Cookies and Southern Scentsations Snickerdoodle BW Sandalwood Cardamom is the same as Peakes Sage & CitrusBW Gingerbread Latte is the same as JBN Pumpkin FrappBert's Lemon Biscotti Pie is the same as NG Lemon Pound CakeBW Black Irish is the same as Flickers Green Irish Tweed"beach daisies" from Nature's Garden smells exactly like "Sun & Sand"-Yankme dupe from Wholesale Supplies AH/RE-French Vanilla Oak=Southern Garden Scents-Baton RogueCierra's -grandmas kitchen, At wix end-grandmas kitchen, Makes scents-apple cinnamon~ all have a very similar cider scent. Elements Patchouli Honey and Moonwork's Native PrincessSugared Spruce from Candle Soylutions is the same as Aztec's, WSP and BB Santa's SpruceDayStar's Paridise = Oregon Trails Fruit LoopsTennessee's Spiced Apples & Peaches = Sweet Cakes Cinnamon Apple PeachBert's Aspen Forest = Moonworks Winter FestivalCandlewic's Spa = WSP's Aqua Spa (WSP's is stronger, but same scent)NG's Mermaid Kisses and ICS Cactus and Sea Salt.JS Vanilla Bean Noel and NG Vanilla Valentine Candlewic's sugared vanilla shortbread and Moonworks (Venus Candles) sugar cookie royaleCandle Science - Sage and Pomegranate is the same as Millcreek Northern Red CurrantJS Aspen Winter and The Candle Source Sleigh RidePeaks Clean Cotton and The Candle Source Clean CottonBCN Spiced Cranberry and Tenn Spiced CranberryJS Vanilla Bean Noel (type) and Tenn Vanilla Bean Noel (type)KY Zucchini Bread and The Candle Source Grammy's Zucchini BreadCS Black Rasp Vanilla and Peaks Black Rasp VanillaJS Cinnamon Buns w/vanilla & The Candle Source Cinn Buns w/vanilla are very similarBCS Harvest and JS Harvest smell the same OOB but IMO the BCS throws a bit betterPeaks Amish Harvest & Tenn Amish Harvest are very similar AHRE's Butternut Pumpkin smells very, very similar to JS's Frosted Pumpkin and MC's Frosted Carrot CakeElements had a scent called Olive Blossom and I swear it smells like MoonWorks Floral Muse FOI have never smelled MoonWorks Floral Muse, but Elements Olive Blossom smells the same to me as CS Rain WaterBert's Aspen Forest and Fillmore Citrus Spruce smell identical to me - or close enough to make me happyMoonworks Pinion pine smells exact to me as CS mistletoeAH/RE Sugar Corn Pudding smells the same as BCN Amish Friendship BreadAztec's Sweet Winterberry & Rustic Escentuals Frosted WinterberryAlso Peaks country berry hotcakes and ICS Wildberry Mousse. Also, Peaks country berry hotcakes smells just like JS cbhThe Scent Works..Sweet Lodge Smoke..and DayStar's..Hunters Moon smell very very much alikeMW gypsy rose and Elements sensuous black rose are very much alike but I can get MW to throw stronger in a candlePeaks & Candlewic Black Raspberry VanillaPeaks Blueberry Cobbler and Candlewic Blueberry PieCommunity Candle Dickens Christmas and The Candlesource Christmas SplendorNG Strawberry Passion & BCN Strawberry JamCandlescience & The Candlesource Mulberry according to my notes but I can not remember for sure: Community Candle Mulled Cider & Tennessee Apple CiderPeaks & AH/RE Orange Chiffon CakeICS & AH/RE Salty Sea Air 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
babudust Posted August 15, 2014 Share Posted August 15, 2014 BRV-Peaks & Candlewic Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Candybee Posted August 15, 2014 Share Posted August 15, 2014 Wow! Megandarr. If this thread hadn't been bumped I wouldn't have seen all the work you did condensing these FO comparisons. Nice work. Thank you!! 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
megandgarr Posted August 16, 2014 Share Posted August 16, 2014 I didn't mind at all. I know the list has certainly prevented me from ordering samples unnecessarily and hopefully it helps others. I probably should take a look at the list again and see if I have any more to add. Hopefully others will have more to add as well. Dessa 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ChandlerWicks Posted August 16, 2014 Share Posted August 16, 2014 (edited) Ok, I am bringing this one back to life again. I copied the list from post 138 and pasted all posts through 169 and then added a few more. These are opinions from various members of the board. Please feel free to copy/paste the list into a new post and add your own twinsies that you have discovered. Tri-State Clean Cotton and MC High CottonJS Mimosa Mandarin and MC Magenta NectarKY--roasted coffee and ICS coffee beanKY--Wildberry Scone and ICS Wildberry----(forgot what they call theirs)KY--Southern Vanilla and SS Country Vanilla (super close, maybe identical)Missy's(JS)-- Christmas Cookie and KH (Keystone) Christmas CookieJS's-- Victorian Vanilla Lace and SS sweet snowJS-- pomegranate and BCN Pomegranate--pretty closeKY--Creme brulee and JBN Creme bruleeKeystone(KH)--Pumpkin Fudge and SS Vanilla PumpkinNature's Garden's Twigs and Berries and Tayberry and Teak Wood.Day Star's OohLaLa and WSP's Beneath the StarsWYW Perfect Pumpkin and WSP's Perfect PumpkinC&S Jade (Pier one type) and MC DreamcatcherJust Scent's Sea Mist smells just like Oceans (Pier 1)...Daystar's Decadent Orange Fluff Cake smells just like NG's Hot orange danishTW Emerald Sea and OM CalypsoPeak Jamaican Me Crazy and JS Paradise IslandHeartfelt's Enchanted, and ICS Japanese Plum!Orange Chiffon Cake-JS, Hot Orange Danish-NGBanana Split-DS, Monkey Farts-AHSerendipity-JS, Cupid-BCN/BNLFramboise Citron Cheesecake-AH, Iced Lemon Danish-PeakUltimate Vanilla-DS, French Vanilla-AH, Vanilla Voodoo-CCCandy Corn-JS, CC, BCN Eggnog-BCN, Custard-AWESilky V Vanilla-JS, Very Vanilla-BCN, Vanilla Extract-BCS, Simply Vanilla-DS, Glazed Donut-TC, Angel Food Cake-WSPCoconut Cream Pie-BCN, JSTwinkies-JS, Nanny's Country Pound Cake-DSAroma Haven Hey Hey Cute Cabana boy and DS Coconut PearMagnolia Melba from Tony's, Summer Fling from BB and Mardi Gras from OT Bayrum: OT & SWCandy Corn: TCS, KS, CC, JSChina Rain: TCS, JSRaisinbread, blahblahblah: WNW, JS, FOHCC & Daystar: Vanilla Voodoo/Ultimate VanillaTwigs & Berries: NG, StevesWNW creme brulee & NG's butter brickle - very similar. even yellows my soy wax the same wayKitchen Spice - JS & DaystarNG's Mrs. Claus Cookies and Day Star's Vanilla Bean NoelSC Watermelon = Day Star's Watermelon MartiniButt Naked from At Wix End is a slightly stronger version of Tranquil Tropics of BubblesnLights (BCN)Clean Cotton = JS, TRI-STGreen Leaf's Starla, The Scent Work's Mayan GoldPeaks Amish Harvest and Aroma Haven's Celtic Moon Spice- Very very SimiliarSanta Spruce (Brambleberry) and Sugared Spruce (the candle source)Strudel from Candle Science and Graham Cracker from Green Leaf smell exactly alike out of the bottle.Wilberry Mousse from Candle Science and Berry Creme Brulee from MilcreekNG"s Watercress and Aloe and Peak's Green Clover in AloeAGE's Salty Mariner and Peaks OceanNG's Passionate Kisses and TCS Caribbean HolidayPeak's Casaba Mist & AH's BadedasJS Grammas Berry Griddlecakes is the same as CS wildberry mousse & These are also the same as ICS Wildberry MousseSweetcakes Fig / BNL Fig MelonGreen Leafs -Indonesean Teak is the same as Flickers - Tuscan LaceDS Tropical Fruit Slices = ICS Summer MedleyKY Apple Clove Butter=Flicker's Cider SnapCS Spiced Wassail=Flicker's Autumn SpiceKY's Homemade Apple Pie ST (now ICS) Baked ApplesAH Fudge Brownie = JS Fabulous FudgeCS Wildberry Mousse and BCN and TCS Country Berry HotcakesBrambleberry's Welcome Home and Tennessee Candle's This Old HousePeaks Spruce Xmas Tree and AH's Ozark ForestGL Himalayan Blue Willow Taylored Concepts BambooTCS Pomegranate GL PomegranateCS Very Vanilla is the same as DS Ultimate Vanilla (and CC Vanilla VoodooGL/TC Pumpkin Pie SpiceGL/TC Pumpkin FrappuchinoTCS/TC Peach Raspberry MagnoliaTC/AH Coco MangoCandle Cocoon's Vanilla Voodoo ~ Millcreeks Extreme VanillaCandlemaker's Store (Steve's) - Harvest -Tennessee Candle - Amish HarvestCandlemaker's Store (Steve's) - Silver Bells - Tennessee Candle - This Old HouseUpdate: I needed This Old House and Tennessee Candles was out of stock so I ordered Candlemakers Store Silver Bells grade A and to my nose they are nothing alike - sorry. I smell pine in it I think but it is not This Old HouseMonkey Farts...NG and WixnwaxAlabaster Caribbean Fruit and Kumquat are the same..or at least used to beMuscadine--NG, WNW, Keystone, and AlabasterBlueberry Cobbler--NG, Keystone, and ICS blueberry cheesecakeAmaretto Nog--WNW, Keystone, JSMulberry-NG, WNW, ICSKudzu--Alabaster, WNW, ICSPeaks Fresh Linen and BCN Angel WingsNG Tayberry & Teakwood - BCN Twigs n BerriesSweet Tooth (AH) = Sweet Treat (JS) Aroma Haven's Sweet SeductionJS Winter SpiceBCN's Mulled Cider....Just Scent winterberry wreath and Candlescience med fig - Millcreeks Mediterranean FigCS Hazelnut and GL HazelnutJS Caramelized Pralines and DS White Chocolate Macadamia Nut CookiesTo me CC tigerlily and cantalope smell like CW white tea.Blackberry Sage from TN, TW, & KY sameMC pears n Berries LS pearberryJinglebells from TN smells like any mulberryBCN-Pomegranate and Just Scents-CupidTwigs & Berries by the following are all interchangable for each other - AWE, BC & NGBert's Aspen Forest & Flickers Balsam & CitrusAH and Js passionate kissesKY's Fresh Glazed Donuts smells like Warm Vanilla Sugar Spiced Crans at BCN & ICSKY Grandmother's Toddy and CS Hansel and Gretels HouseBCN's Dreamweaver and NG's Satin SheetsBCS Pumpkin Cheesecake and JS Pumpkin Fudge TorteMimosa and Mandarin CS and BC's Citrus SplashMillcreek Soy Candle Cozy Home smells similar to me like CS's Cranberry MarmaladeMillcreek's Cinnamon Vanilla and CS Strudel and Spice are very very alikeLonestar Sun 'N Sea and Sea Petals are identicalBCS Sissy Sugar Cookies and Southern Scentsations Snickerdoodle BW Sandalwood Cardamom is the same as Peakes Sage & CitrusBW Gingerbread Latte is the same as JBN Pumpkin FrappBert's Lemon Biscotti Pie is the same as NG Lemon Pound CakeBW Black Irish is the same as Flickers Green Irish Tweed"beach daisies" from Nature's Garden smells exactly like "Sun & Sand"-Yankme dupe from Wholesale Supplies AH/RE-French Vanilla Oak=Southern Garden Scents-Baton RogueCierra's -grandmas kitchen, At wix end-grandmas kitchen, Makes scents-apple cinnamon~ all have a very similar cider scent. Elements Patchouli Honey and Moonwork's Native PrincessSugared Spruce from Candle Soylutions is the same as Aztec's, WSP and BB Santa's SpruceDayStar's Paridise = Oregon Trails Fruit LoopsTennessee's Spiced Apples & Peaches = Sweet Cakes Cinnamon Apple PeachBert's Aspen Forest = Moonworks Winter FestivalCandlewic's Spa = WSP's Aqua Spa (WSP's is stronger, but same scent)NG's Mermaid Kisses and ICS Cactus and Sea Salt.JS Vanilla Bean Noel and NG Vanilla Valentine Candlewic's sugared vanilla shortbread and Moonworks (Venus Candles) sugar cookie royaleCandle Science - Sage and Pomegranate is the same as Millcreek Northern Red CurrantJS Aspen Winter and The Candle Source Sleigh RidePeaks Clean Cotton and The Candle Source Clean CottonBCN Spiced Cranberry and Tenn Spiced CranberryJS Vanilla Bean Noel (type) and Tenn Vanilla Bean Noel (type)KY Zucchini Bread and The Candle Source Grammy's Zucchini BreadCS Black Rasp Vanilla and Peaks Black Rasp VanillaJS Cinnamon Buns w/vanilla & The Candle Source Cinn Buns w/vanilla are very similarBCS Harvest and JS Harvest smell the same OOB but IMO the BCS throws a bit betterPeaks Amish Harvest & Tenn Amish Harvest are very similar AHRE's Butternut Pumpkin smells very, very similar to JS's Frosted Pumpkin and MC's Frosted Carrot CakeElements had a scent called Olive Blossom and I swear it smells like MoonWorks Floral Muse FOI have never smelled MoonWorks Floral Muse, but Elements Olive Blossom smells the same to me as CS Rain WaterBert's Aspen Forest and Fillmore Citrus Spruce smell identical to me - or close enough to make me happyMoonworks Pinion pine smells exact to me as CS mistletoeAH/RE Sugar Corn Pudding smells the same as BCN Amish Friendship BreadAztec's Sweet Winterberry & Rustic Escentuals Frosted WinterberryAlso Peaks country berry hotcakes and ICS Wildberry Mousse. Also, Peaks country berry hotcakes smells just like JS cbhThe Scent Works..Sweet Lodge Smoke..and DayStar's..Hunters Moon smell very very much alikeMW gypsy rose and Elements sensuous black rose are very much alike but I can get MW to throw stronger in a candlePeaks & Candlewic Black Raspberry VanillaPeaks Blueberry Cobbler and Candlewic Blueberry PieCommunity Candle Dickens Christmas and The Candlesource Christmas SplendorNG Strawberry Passion & BCN Strawberry JamCandlescience & The Candlesource Mulberry according to my notes but I can not remember for sure: Community Candle Mulled Cider & Tennessee Apple CiderPeaks & AH/RE Orange Chiffon CakeICS & AH/RE Salty Sea AirBRV-Peaks & CandlewicWild Mountain Honey-Peak, Flaming Candle Company & Elements-Honey L'Occitane Type Edited August 16, 2014 by ChandlerWicks 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Candybee Posted August 16, 2014 Share Posted August 16, 2014 Nice job! Sure are a lot of comparisons there! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.