Jump to content

Fragrance Twins


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 204
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

I love Lone Star's Lemongrass Sage scent, but it has phathalates in it so I have been on the hunt for one that smells similar to it.  Rustic just had their sample sale, and one of the samples I got is

WSP's Indonesian Teakwood smells exactly like Candlewic's Mahogany Spice

Ok, I am bringing this one back to life again.    I copied the list from post 138 and pasted all posts through 169 and then added a few more.  These are opinions from various members of the board. Ple

Apparently I don't have much to do this AM, so I compiled a listing of dupes that have been posted on this thread into one big list!

Tri-State Clean Cotton and MC High Cotton

JS Mimosa Mandarin and MC Magenta Nectar

KY--roasted coffee and ICS coffee bean

KY--Wildberry Scone and ICS Wildberry----(forgot what they call theirs)

KY--Southern Vanilla and SS Country Vanilla (super close, maybe identical)

Missy's(JS)-- Christmas Cookie and KH (Keystone) Christmas Cookie

JS's-- Victorian Vanilla Lace and SS sweet snow

JS-- pomegranate and BCN Pomegranate--pretty close

KY--Creme brulee and JBN Creme brulee

Keystone(KH)--Pumpkin Fudge and SS Vanilla Pumpkin

Nature's Garden's Twigs and Berries and Tayberry and Teak Wood.

Day Star's OohLaLa and WSP's Beneath the Stars

WYW Perfect Pumpkin and WSP's Perfect Pumpkin

C&S Jade (Pier one type) and MC Dreamcatcher

Just Scent's Sea Mist smells just like Oceans (Pier 1)...

Daystar's Decadent Orange Fluff Cake smells just like NG's Hot orange danish

TW Emerald Sea and OM Calypso

Peak Jamaican Me Crazy and JS Paradise Island

Heartfelt's Enchanted, and ICS Japanese Plum!

Orange Chiffon Cake-JS, Hot Orange Danish-NG

Banana Split-DS, Monkey Farts-AH

Serendipity-JS, Cupid-BCN/BNL

Framboise Citron Cheesecake-AH, Iced Lemon Danish-Peak

Ultimate Vanilla-DS, French Vanilla-AH, Vanilla Voodoo-CC

Candy Corn-JS, CC, BCN

Eggnog-BCN, Custard-AWE

Silky V Vanilla-JS, Very Vanilla-BCN, Vanilla Extract-BCS,

Simply Vanilla-DS, Glazed Donut-TC, Angel Food Cake-WSP

Coconut Cream Pie-BCN, JS

Twinkies-JS, Nanny's Country Pound Cake-DS

Aroma Haven Hey Hey Cute Cabana boy and DS Coconut Pear

Magnolia Melba from Tony's, Summer Fling from BB and Mardi Gras from OT

Bayrum: OT & SW

Candy Corn: TCS, KS, CC, JS

China Rain: TCS, JS

Raisinbread, blahblahblah: WNW, JS, FOH

CC & Daystar: Vanilla Voodoo/Ultimate Vanilla

Twigs & Berries: NG, Steves

WNW creme brulee & NG's butter brickle - very similar. even yellows my soy wax the same way

Kitchen Spice - JS & Daystar

NG's Mrs. Claus Cookies and Day Star's Vanilla Bean Noel

SC Watermelon = Day Star's Watermelon Martini

Butt Naked from At Wix End is a slightly stronger version of Tranquil Tropics of BubblesnLights (BCN)

Clean Cotton = JS, TRI-ST

Green Leaf's Starla, The Scent Work's Mayan Gold

Peaks Amish Harvest and Aroma Haven's Celtic Moon Spice- Very very Similiar

Santa Spruce (Brambleberry) and Sugared Spruce (the candle source)

Strudel from Candle Science and Graham Cracker from Green Leaf smell exactly alike out of the bottle.

Wilberry Mousse from Candle Science and Berry Creme Brulee from Milcreek

NG"s Watercress and Aloe and Peak's Green Clover in Aloe

AGE's Salty Mariner and Peaks Ocean

NG's Passionate Kisses and TCS Caribbean Holiday

Peak's Casaba Mist & AH's Badedas

JS Grammas Berry Griddlecakes is the same as CS wildberry mousse & These are also the same as ICS Wildberry Mousse

Sweetcakes Fig / BNL Fig Melon

Green Leafs -Indonesean Teak is the same as Flickers - Tuscan Lace

DS Tropical Fruit Slices = ICS Summer Medley

KY Apple Clove Butter=Flicker's Cider Snap

CS Spiced Wassail=Flicker's Autumn Spice

KY's Homemade Apple Pie ST (now ICS) Baked Apples

AH Fudge Brownie = JS Fabulous Fudge

CS Wildberry Mousse and BCN and TCS Country Berry Hotcakes

Brambleberry's Welcome Home and Tennessee Candle's This Old House

Peaks Spruce Xmas Tree and AH's Ozark Forest

GL Himalayan Blue Willow Taylored Concepts Bamboo

TCS Pomegranate GL Pomegranate

CS Very Vanilla is the same as DS Ultimate Vanilla (and CC Vanilla Voodoo

GL/TC Pumpkin Pie Spice

GL/TC Pumpkin Frappuchino

TCS/TC Peach Raspberry Magnolia

TC/AH Coco Mango

Candle Cocoon's Vanilla Voodoo ~ Millcreeks Extreme Vanilla

Candlemaker's Store (Steve's) - Harvest -Tennessee Candle - Amish Harvest

Candlemaker's Store (Steve's) - Silver Bells - Tennessee Candle - This Old House

Monkey Farts...NG and Wixnwax

Alabaster Caribbean Fruit and Kumquat are the same..or at least used to be

Muscadine--NG, WNW, Keystone, and Alabaster

Blueberry Cobbler--NG, Keystone, and ICS blueberry cheesecake

Amaretto Nog--WNW, Keystone, JS

Mulberry-NG, WNW, ICS

Kudzu--Alabaster, WNW, ICS

Peaks Fresh Linen and BCN Angel Wings

NG Tayberry & Teakwood - BCN Twigs n Berries

Sweet Tooth (AH) = Sweet Treat (JS) Aroma Haven's Sweet Seduction

JS Winter Spice

BCN's Mulled Cider....

Just Scent winterberry wreath and Candlescience med fig - Millcreeks Mediterranean Fig

CS Hazelnut and GL Hazelnut

JS Caramelized Pralines and DS White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookies

To me CC tigerlily and cantalope smell like CW white tea.

Blackberry Sage from TN, TW, & KY same

MC pears n Berries LS pearberry

Jinglebells from TN smells like any mulberry

BCN-Pomegranate and Just Scents-Cupid

Twigs & Berries by the following are all interchangable for each other - AWE, BC & NG

Bert's Aspen Forest & Flickers Balsam & Citrus

AH and Js passionate kisses

KY's Fresh Glazed Donuts smells like Warm Vanilla Sugar

Spiced Crans at BCN & ICS

KY Grandmother's Toddy and CS Hansel and Gretels House

BCN's Dreamweaver and NG's Satin Sheets

BCS Pumpkin Cheesecake and JS Pumpkin Fudge Torte

Mimosa and Mandarin CS and BC's Citrus Splash

Millcreek Soy Candle Cozy Home smells similar to me like CS's Cranberry Marmalade

Millcreek's Cinnamon Vanilla and CS Strudel and Spice are very very alike

Lonestar Sun 'N Sea and Sea Petals are identical

BCS Sissy Sugar Cookies and Southern Scentsations Snickerdoodle

BW Sandalwood Cardamom is the same as Peakes Sage & Citrus

BW Gingerbread Latte is the same as JBN Pumpkin Frapp

Bert's Lemon Biscotti Pie is the same as NG Lemon Pound Cake

BW Black Irish is the same as Flickers Green Irish Tweed

"beach daisies" from Nature's Garden smells exactly like "Sun & Sand"-Yankme dupe from Wholesale Supplies

AH/RE-French Vanilla Oak=Southern Garden Scents-Baton Rogue

JS Nostalgia and Aztec's Smell of Christmas

JS Christmas Splendor, Starrville's Christmas Splendor, MC Orange Clove

Link to post
Share on other sites
Apparently I don't have much to do this AM, so I compiled a listing of dupes that have been posted on this thread into one big list!

Tri-State Clean Cotton and MC High Cotton

JS Mimosa Mandarin and MC Magenta Nectar

KY--roasted coffee and ICS coffee bean

KY--Wildberry Scone and ICS Wildberry----(forgot what they call theirs)

KY--Southern Vanilla and SS Country Vanilla (super close, maybe identical)

Missy's(JS)-- Christmas Cookie and KH (Keystone) Christmas Cookie

JS's-- Victorian Vanilla Lace and SS sweet snow

JS-- pomegranate and BCN Pomegranate--pretty close

KY--Creme brulee and JBN Creme brulee

Keystone(KH)--Pumpkin Fudge and SS Vanilla Pumpkin

Nature's Garden's Twigs and Berries and Tayberry and Teak Wood.

Day Star's OohLaLa and WSP's Beneath the Stars

WYW Perfect Pumpkin and WSP's Perfect Pumpkin

C&S Jade (Pier one type) and MC Dreamcatcher

Just Scent's Sea Mist smells just like Oceans (Pier 1)...

Daystar's Decadent Orange Fluff Cake smells just like NG's Hot orange danish

TW Emerald Sea and OM Calypso

Peak Jamaican Me Crazy and JS Paradise Island

Heartfelt's Enchanted, and ICS Japanese Plum!

Orange Chiffon Cake-JS, Hot Orange Danish-NG

Banana Split-DS, Monkey Farts-AH

Serendipity-JS, Cupid-BCN/BNL

Framboise Citron Cheesecake-AH, Iced Lemon Danish-Peak

Ultimate Vanilla-DS, French Vanilla-AH, Vanilla Voodoo-CC

Candy Corn-JS, CC, BCN

Eggnog-BCN, Custard-AWE

Silky V Vanilla-JS, Very Vanilla-BCN, Vanilla Extract-BCS,

Simply Vanilla-DS, Glazed Donut-TC, Angel Food Cake-WSP

Coconut Cream Pie-BCN, JS

Twinkies-JS, Nanny's Country Pound Cake-DS

Aroma Haven Hey Hey Cute Cabana boy and DS Coconut Pear

Magnolia Melba from Tony's, Summer Fling from BB and Mardi Gras from OT

Bayrum: OT & SW

Candy Corn: TCS, KS, CC, JS

China Rain: TCS, JS

Raisinbread, blahblahblah: WNW, JS, FOH

CC & Daystar: Vanilla Voodoo/Ultimate Vanilla

Twigs & Berries: NG, Steves

WNW creme brulee & NG's butter brickle - very similar. even yellows my soy wax the same way

Kitchen Spice - JS & Daystar

NG's Mrs. Claus Cookies and Day Star's Vanilla Bean Noel

SC Watermelon = Day Star's Watermelon Martini

Butt Naked from At Wix End is a slightly stronger version of Tranquil Tropics of BubblesnLights (BCN)

Clean Cotton = JS, TRI-ST

Green Leaf's Starla, The Scent Work's Mayan Gold

Peaks Amish Harvest and Aroma Haven's Celtic Moon Spice- Very very Similiar

Santa Spruce (Brambleberry) and Sugared Spruce (the candle source)

Strudel from Candle Science and Graham Cracker from Green Leaf smell exactly alike out of the bottle.

Wilberry Mousse from Candle Science and Berry Creme Brulee from Milcreek

NG"s Watercress and Aloe and Peak's Green Clover in Aloe

AGE's Salty Mariner and Peaks Ocean

NG's Passionate Kisses and TCS Caribbean Holiday

Peak's Casaba Mist & AH's Badedas

JS Grammas Berry Griddlecakes is the same as CS wildberry mousse & These are also the same as ICS Wildberry Mousse

Sweetcakes Fig / BNL Fig Melon

Green Leafs -Indonesean Teak is the same as Flickers - Tuscan Lace

DS Tropical Fruit Slices = ICS Summer Medley

KY Apple Clove Butter=Flicker's Cider Snap

CS Spiced Wassail=Flicker's Autumn Spice

KY's Homemade Apple Pie ST (now ICS) Baked Apples

AH Fudge Brownie = JS Fabulous Fudge

CS Wildberry Mousse and BCN and TCS Country Berry Hotcakes

Brambleberry's Welcome Home and Tennessee Candle's This Old House

Peaks Spruce Xmas Tree and AH's Ozark Forest

GL Himalayan Blue Willow Taylored Concepts Bamboo

TCS Pomegranate GL Pomegranate

CS Very Vanilla is the same as DS Ultimate Vanilla (and CC Vanilla Voodoo

GL/TC Pumpkin Pie Spice

GL/TC Pumpkin Frappuchino

TCS/TC Peach Raspberry Magnolia

TC/AH Coco Mango

Candle Cocoon's Vanilla Voodoo ~ Millcreeks Extreme Vanilla

Candlemaker's Store (Steve's) - Harvest -Tennessee Candle - Amish Harvest

Candlemaker's Store (Steve's) - Silver Bells - Tennessee Candle - This Old House

Monkey Farts...NG and Wixnwax

Alabaster Caribbean Fruit and Kumquat are the same..or at least used to be

Muscadine--NG, WNW, Keystone, and Alabaster

Blueberry Cobbler--NG, Keystone, and ICS blueberry cheesecake

Amaretto Nog--WNW, Keystone, JS

Mulberry-NG, WNW, ICS

Kudzu--Alabaster, WNW, ICS

Peaks Fresh Linen and BCN Angel Wings

NG Tayberry & Teakwood - BCN Twigs n Berries

Sweet Tooth (AH) = Sweet Treat (JS) Aroma Haven's Sweet Seduction

JS Winter Spice

BCN's Mulled Cider....

Just Scent winterberry wreath and Candlescience med fig - Millcreeks Mediterranean Fig

CS Hazelnut and GL Hazelnut

JS Caramelized Pralines and DS White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookies

To me CC tigerlily and cantalope smell like CW white tea.

Blackberry Sage from TN, TW, & KY same

MC pears n Berries LS pearberry

Jinglebells from TN smells like any mulberry

BCN-Pomegranate and Just Scents-Cupid

Twigs & Berries by the following are all interchangable for each other - AWE, BC & NG

Bert's Aspen Forest & Flickers Balsam & Citrus

AH and Js passionate kisses

KY's Fresh Glazed Donuts smells like Warm Vanilla Sugar

Spiced Crans at BCN & ICS

KY Grandmother's Toddy and CS Hansel and Gretels House

BCN's Dreamweaver and NG's Satin Sheets

BCS Pumpkin Cheesecake and JS Pumpkin Fudge Torte

Mimosa and Mandarin CS and BC's Citrus Splash

Millcreek Soy Candle Cozy Home smells similar to me like CS's Cranberry Marmalade

Millcreek's Cinnamon Vanilla and CS Strudel and Spice are very very alike

Lonestar Sun 'N Sea and Sea Petals are identical

BCS Sissy Sugar Cookies and Southern Scentsations Snickerdoodle

BW Sandalwood Cardamom is the same as Peakes Sage & Citrus

BW Gingerbread Latte is the same as JBN Pumpkin Frapp

Bert's Lemon Biscotti Pie is the same as NG Lemon Pound Cake

BW Black Irish is the same as Flickers Green Irish Tweed

"beach daisies" from Nature's Garden smells exactly like "Sun & Sand"-Yankme dupe from Wholesale Supplies

AH/RE-French Vanilla Oak=Southern Garden Scents-Baton Rogue

JS Nostalgia and Aztec's Smell of Christmas

JS Christmas Splendor, Starrville's Christmas Splendor, MC Orange Clove

Peaks Downey Fresh & KY's Summer Breeze (Idenitical IMO) OOB & in wax

Added to bottom

Link to post
Share on other sites
Apparently I don't have much to do this AM, so I compiled a listing of dupes that have been posted on this thread into one big list!

Tri-State Clean Cotton and MC High Cotton

JS Mimosa Mandarin and MC Magenta Nectar

KY--roasted coffee and ICS coffee bean

KY--Wildberry Scone and ICS Wildberry----(forgot what they call theirs)

KY--Southern Vanilla and SS Country Vanilla (super close, maybe identical)

Missy's(JS)-- Christmas Cookie and KH (Keystone) Christmas Cookie

JS's-- Victorian Vanilla Lace and SS sweet snow

JS-- pomegranate and BCN Pomegranate--pretty close

KY--Creme brulee and JBN Creme brulee

Keystone(KH)--Pumpkin Fudge and SS Vanilla Pumpkin

Nature's Garden's Twigs and Berries and Tayberry and Teak Wood.

Day Star's OohLaLa and WSP's Beneath the Stars

WYW Perfect Pumpkin and WSP's Perfect Pumpkin

C&S Jade (Pier one type) and MC Dreamcatcher

Just Scent's Sea Mist smells just like Oceans (Pier 1)...

Daystar's Decadent Orange Fluff Cake smells just like NG's Hot orange danish

TW Emerald Sea and OM Calypso

Peak Jamaican Me Crazy and JS Paradise Island

Heartfelt's Enchanted, and ICS Japanese Plum!

Orange Chiffon Cake-JS, Hot Orange Danish-NG

Banana Split-DS, Monkey Farts-AH

Serendipity-JS, Cupid-BCN/BNL

Framboise Citron Cheesecake-AH, Iced Lemon Danish-Peak

Ultimate Vanilla-DS, French Vanilla-AH, Vanilla Voodoo-CC

Candy Corn-JS, CC, BCN

Eggnog-BCN, Custard-AWE

Silky V Vanilla-JS, Very Vanilla-BCN, Vanilla Extract-BCS,

Simply Vanilla-DS, Glazed Donut-TC, Angel Food Cake-WSP

Coconut Cream Pie-BCN, JS

Twinkies-JS, Nanny's Country Pound Cake-DS

Aroma Haven Hey Hey Cute Cabana boy and DS Coconut Pear

Magnolia Melba from Tony's, Summer Fling from BB and Mardi Gras from OT

Bayrum: OT & SW

Candy Corn: TCS, KS, CC, JS

China Rain: TCS, JS

Raisinbread, blahblahblah: WNW, JS, FOH

CC & Daystar: Vanilla Voodoo/Ultimate Vanilla

Twigs & Berries: NG, Steves

WNW creme brulee & NG's butter brickle - very similar. even yellows my soy wax the same way

Kitchen Spice - JS & Daystar

NG's Mrs. Claus Cookies and Day Star's Vanilla Bean Noel

SC Watermelon = Day Star's Watermelon Martini

Butt Naked from At Wix End is a slightly stronger version of Tranquil Tropics of BubblesnLights (BCN)

Clean Cotton = JS, TRI-ST

Green Leaf's Starla, The Scent Work's Mayan Gold

Peaks Amish Harvest and Aroma Haven's Celtic Moon Spice- Very very Similiar

Santa Spruce (Brambleberry) and Sugared Spruce (the candle source)

Strudel from Candle Science and Graham Cracker from Green Leaf smell exactly alike out of the bottle.

Wilberry Mousse from Candle Science and Berry Creme Brulee from Milcreek

NG"s Watercress and Aloe and Peak's Green Clover in Aloe

AGE's Salty Mariner and Peaks Ocean

NG's Passionate Kisses and TCS Caribbean Holiday

Peak's Casaba Mist & AH's Badedas

JS Grammas Berry Griddlecakes is the same as CS wildberry mousse & These are also the same as ICS Wildberry Mousse

Sweetcakes Fig / BNL Fig Melon

Green Leafs -Indonesean Teak is the same as Flickers - Tuscan Lace

DS Tropical Fruit Slices = ICS Summer Medley

KY Apple Clove Butter=Flicker's Cider Snap

CS Spiced Wassail=Flicker's Autumn Spice

KY's Homemade Apple Pie ST (now ICS) Baked Apples

AH Fudge Brownie = JS Fabulous Fudge

CS Wildberry Mousse and BCN and TCS Country Berry Hotcakes

Brambleberry's Welcome Home and Tennessee Candle's This Old House

Peaks Spruce Xmas Tree and AH's Ozark Forest

GL Himalayan Blue Willow Taylored Concepts Bamboo

TCS Pomegranate GL Pomegranate

CS Very Vanilla is the same as DS Ultimate Vanilla (and CC Vanilla Voodoo

GL/TC Pumpkin Pie Spice

GL/TC Pumpkin Frappuchino

TCS/TC Peach Raspberry Magnolia

TC/AH Coco Mango

Candle Cocoon's Vanilla Voodoo ~ Millcreeks Extreme Vanilla

Candlemaker's Store (Steve's) - Harvest -Tennessee Candle - Amish Harvest

Candlemaker's Store (Steve's) - Silver Bells - Tennessee Candle - This Old House

Monkey Farts...NG and Wixnwax

Alabaster Caribbean Fruit and Kumquat are the same..or at least used to be

Muscadine--NG, WNW, Keystone, and Alabaster

Blueberry Cobbler--NG, Keystone, and ICS blueberry cheesecake

Amaretto Nog--WNW, Keystone, JS

Mulberry-NG, WNW, ICS

Kudzu--Alabaster, WNW, ICS

Peaks Fresh Linen and BCN Angel Wings

NG Tayberry & Teakwood - BCN Twigs n Berries

Sweet Tooth (AH) = Sweet Treat (JS) Aroma Haven's Sweet Seduction

JS Winter Spice

BCN's Mulled Cider....

Just Scent winterberry wreath and Candlescience med fig - Millcreeks Mediterranean Fig

CS Hazelnut and GL Hazelnut

JS Caramelized Pralines and DS White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookies

To me CC tigerlily and cantalope smell like CW white tea.

Blackberry Sage from TN, TW, & KY same

MC pears n Berries LS pearberry

Jinglebells from TN smells like any mulberry

BCN-Pomegranate and Just Scents-Cupid

Twigs & Berries by the following are all interchangable for each other - AWE, BC & NG

Bert's Aspen Forest & Flickers Balsam & Citrus

AH and Js passionate kisses

KY's Fresh Glazed Donuts smells like Warm Vanilla Sugar

Spiced Crans at BCN & ICS

KY Grandmother's Toddy and CS Hansel and Gretels House

BCN's Dreamweaver and NG's Satin Sheets

BCS Pumpkin Cheesecake and JS Pumpkin Fudge Torte

Mimosa and Mandarin CS and BC's Citrus Splash

Millcreek Soy Candle Cozy Home smells similar to me like CS's Cranberry Marmalade

Millcreek's Cinnamon Vanilla and CS Strudel and Spice are very very alike

Lonestar Sun 'N Sea and Sea Petals are identical

BCS Sissy Sugar Cookies and Southern Scentsations Snickerdoodle

BW Sandalwood Cardamom is the same as Peakes Sage & Citrus

BW Gingerbread Latte is the same as JBN Pumpkin Frapp

Bert's Lemon Biscotti Pie is the same as NG Lemon Pound Cake

BW Black Irish is the same as Flickers Green Irish Tweed

"beach daisies" from Nature's Garden smells exactly like "Sun & Sand"-Yankme dupe from Wholesale Supplies

AH/RE-French Vanilla Oak=Southern Garden Scents-Baton Rogue

JS Nostalgia and Aztec's Smell of Christmas

JS Christmas Splendor, Starrville's Christmas Splendor, MC Orange Clove

BB's Almond and KY's Oatmeal Milk & Honey same OOB and B&B

BB's & DS Grapefruit Lily same OOB and B&B

CS & CC Clean Cotton same OOB and wax (IGI 4360) CC has a slightly stronger hot throw not much though

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 7 months later...
Apparently I don't have much to do this AM, so I compiled a listing of dupes that have been posted on this thread into one big list!

Tri-State Clean Cotton and MC High Cotton

JS Mimosa Mandarin and MC Magenta Nectar

KY--roasted coffee and ICS coffee bean

KY--Wildberry Scone and ICS Wildberry----(forgot what they call theirs)

KY--Southern Vanilla and SS Country Vanilla (super close, maybe identical)

Missy's(JS)-- Christmas Cookie and KH (Keystone) Christmas Cookie

JS's-- Victorian Vanilla Lace and SS sweet snow

JS-- pomegranate and BCN Pomegranate--pretty close

KY--Creme brulee and JBN Creme brulee

Keystone(KH)--Pumpkin Fudge and SS Vanilla Pumpkin

Nature's Garden's Twigs and Berries and Tayberry and Teak Wood.

Day Star's OohLaLa and WSP's Beneath the Stars

WYW Perfect Pumpkin and WSP's Perfect Pumpkin

C&S Jade (Pier one type) and MC Dreamcatcher

Just Scent's Sea Mist smells just like Oceans (Pier 1)...

Daystar's Decadent Orange Fluff Cake smells just like NG's Hot orange danish

TW Emerald Sea and OM Calypso

Peak Jamaican Me Crazy and JS Paradise Island

Heartfelt's Enchanted, and ICS Japanese Plum!

Orange Chiffon Cake-JS, Hot Orange Danish-NG

Banana Split-DS, Monkey Farts-AH

Serendipity-JS, Cupid-BCN/BNL

Framboise Citron Cheesecake-AH, Iced Lemon Danish-Peak

Ultimate Vanilla-DS, French Vanilla-AH, Vanilla Voodoo-CC

Candy Corn-JS, CC, BCN

Eggnog-BCN, Custard-AWE

Silky V Vanilla-JS, Very Vanilla-BCN, Vanilla Extract-BCS,

Simply Vanilla-DS, Glazed Donut-TC, Angel Food Cake-WSP

Coconut Cream Pie-BCN, JS

Twinkies-JS, Nanny's Country Pound Cake-DS

Aroma Haven Hey Hey Cute Cabana boy and DS Coconut Pear

Magnolia Melba from Tony's, Summer Fling from BB and Mardi Gras from OT

Bayrum: OT & SW

Candy Corn: TCS, KS, CC, JS

China Rain: TCS, JS

Raisinbread, blahblahblah: WNW, JS, FOH

CC & Daystar: Vanilla Voodoo/Ultimate Vanilla

Twigs & Berries: NG, Steves

WNW creme brulee & NG's butter brickle - very similar. even yellows my soy wax the same way

Kitchen Spice - JS & Daystar

NG's Mrs. Claus Cookies and Day Star's Vanilla Bean Noel

SC Watermelon = Day Star's Watermelon Martini

Butt Naked from At Wix End is a slightly stronger version of Tranquil Tropics of BubblesnLights (BCN)

Clean Cotton = JS, TRI-ST

Green Leaf's Starla, The Scent Work's Mayan Gold

Peaks Amish Harvest and Aroma Haven's Celtic Moon Spice- Very very Similiar

Santa Spruce (Brambleberry) and Sugared Spruce (the candle source)

Strudel from Candle Science and Graham Cracker from Green Leaf smell exactly alike out of the bottle.

Wilberry Mousse from Candle Science and Berry Creme Brulee from Milcreek

NG"s Watercress and Aloe and Peak's Green Clover in Aloe

AGE's Salty Mariner and Peaks Ocean

NG's Passionate Kisses and TCS Caribbean Holiday

Peak's Casaba Mist & AH's Badedas

JS Grammas Berry Griddlecakes is the same as CS wildberry mousse & These are also the same as ICS Wildberry Mousse

Sweetcakes Fig / BNL Fig Melon

Green Leafs -Indonesean Teak is the same as Flickers - Tuscan Lace

DS Tropical Fruit Slices = ICS Summer Medley

KY Apple Clove Butter=Flicker's Cider Snap

CS Spiced Wassail=Flicker's Autumn Spice

KY's Homemade Apple Pie ST (now ICS) Baked Apples

AH Fudge Brownie = JS Fabulous Fudge

CS Wildberry Mousse and BCN and TCS Country Berry Hotcakes

Brambleberry's Welcome Home and Tennessee Candle's This Old House

Peaks Spruce Xmas Tree and AH's Ozark Forest

GL Himalayan Blue Willow Taylored Concepts Bamboo

TCS Pomegranate GL Pomegranate

CS Very Vanilla is the same as DS Ultimate Vanilla (and CC Vanilla Voodoo

GL/TC Pumpkin Pie Spice

GL/TC Pumpkin Frappuchino

TCS/TC Peach Raspberry Magnolia

TC/AH Coco Mango

Candle Cocoon's Vanilla Voodoo ~ Millcreeks Extreme Vanilla

Candlemaker's Store (Steve's) - Harvest -Tennessee Candle - Amish Harvest

Candlemaker's Store (Steve's) - Silver Bells - Tennessee Candle - This Old House

Monkey Farts...NG and Wixnwax

Alabaster Caribbean Fruit and Kumquat are the same..or at least used to be

Muscadine--NG, WNW, Keystone, and Alabaster

Blueberry Cobbler--NG, Keystone, and ICS blueberry cheesecake

Amaretto Nog--WNW, Keystone, JS

Mulberry-NG, WNW, ICS

Kudzu--Alabaster, WNW, ICS

Peaks Fresh Linen and BCN Angel Wings

NG Tayberry & Teakwood - BCN Twigs n Berries

Sweet Tooth (AH) = Sweet Treat (JS) Aroma Haven's Sweet Seduction

JS Winter Spice

BCN's Mulled Cider....

Just Scent winterberry wreath and Candlescience med fig - Millcreeks Mediterranean Fig

CS Hazelnut and GL Hazelnut

JS Caramelized Pralines and DS White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookies

To me CC tigerlily and cantalope smell like CW white tea.

Blackberry Sage from TN, TW, & KY same

MC pears n Berries LS pearberry

Jinglebells from TN smells like any mulberry

BCN-Pomegranate and Just Scents-Cupid

Twigs & Berries by the following are all interchangable for each other - AWE, BC & NG

Bert's Aspen Forest & Flickers Balsam & Citrus

AH and Js passionate kisses

KY's Fresh Glazed Donuts smells like Warm Vanilla Sugar

Spiced Crans at BCN & ICS

KY Grandmother's Toddy and CS Hansel and Gretels House

BCN's Dreamweaver and NG's Satin Sheets

BCS Pumpkin Cheesecake and JS Pumpkin Fudge Torte

Mimosa and Mandarin CS and BC's Citrus Splash

Millcreek Soy Candle Cozy Home smells similar to me like CS's Cranberry Marmalade

Millcreek's Cinnamon Vanilla and CS Strudel and Spice are very very alike

Lonestar Sun 'N Sea and Sea Petals are identical

BCS Sissy Sugar Cookies and Southern Scentsations Snickerdoodle

BW Sandalwood Cardamom is the same as Peakes Sage & Citrus

BW Gingerbread Latte is the same as JBN Pumpkin Frapp

Bert's Lemon Biscotti Pie is the same as NG Lemon Pound Cake

BW Black Irish is the same as Flickers Green Irish Tweed

"beach daisies" from Nature's Garden smells exactly like "Sun & Sand"-Yankme dupe from Wholesale Supplies

AH/RE-French Vanilla Oak=Southern Garden Scents-Baton Rogue

Cierra's -grandmas kitchen, At wix end-grandmas kitchen, Makes scents-apple cinnamon~ all have a very similar cider scent.

Link to post
Share on other sites

That was an awesome job compiling all those fragrances. Wow!

I do see some inconsistencies with a few of those comparisons. Eg. flickers Green Irish Tweed is not the same as BW Black Irish; Wildberry Mousse and Country Berry Hotcakes do not smell the same to me. There are others but I am not going to list all.

I think if you use the list to get an idea of what some of these FOs smell like you should be okay as some are spot on while others are a long shot.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Due to all the raves I just got in Bert's Aspen Forest and in addition to it being a twin to Flicker's Balsam & Citrus it is also a twin to Southern Scentsations fragrance Holiday Scentsation.

ETA - Southern Scentsations Butt Naked is a dupe to At Wix End Butt Naked and Make's Scent Butt Naked.

Edited by Brenda (OH)
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 3 months later...
  • 1 month later...
  • 2 months later...

I'm :bump:

I updated this list last year so I thought I'd bump it up for ya'll!

Add to list as you see fit.:)

Apparently I don't have much to do this AM, so I compiled a listing of dupes that have been posted on this thread into one big list!

Tri-State Clean Cotton and MC High Cotton

JS Mimosa Mandarin and MC Magenta Nectar

KY--roasted coffee and ICS coffee bean

KY--Wildberry Scone and ICS Wildberry----(forgot what they call theirs)

KY--Southern Vanilla and SS Country Vanilla (super close, maybe identical)

Missy's(JS)-- Christmas Cookie and KH (Keystone) Christmas Cookie

JS's-- Victorian Vanilla Lace and SS sweet snow

JS-- pomegranate and BCN Pomegranate--pretty close

KY--Creme brulee and JBN Creme brulee

Keystone(KH)--Pumpkin Fudge and SS Vanilla Pumpkin

Nature's Garden's Twigs and Berries and Tayberry and Teak Wood.

Day Star's OohLaLa and WSP's Beneath the Stars

WYW Perfect Pumpkin and WSP's Perfect Pumpkin

C&S Jade (Pier one type) and MC Dreamcatcher

Just Scent's Sea Mist smells just like Oceans (Pier 1)...

Daystar's Decadent Orange Fluff Cake smells just like NG's Hot orange danish

TW Emerald Sea and OM Calypso

Peak Jamaican Me Crazy and JS Paradise Island

Heartfelt's Enchanted, and ICS Japanese Plum!

Orange Chiffon Cake-JS, Hot Orange Danish-NG

Banana Split-DS, Monkey Farts-AH

Serendipity-JS, Cupid-BCN/BNL

Framboise Citron Cheesecake-AH, Iced Lemon Danish-Peak

Ultimate Vanilla-DS, French Vanilla-AH, Vanilla Voodoo-CC

Candy Corn-JS, CC, BCN

Eggnog-BCN, Custard-AWE

Silky V Vanilla-JS, Very Vanilla-BCN, Vanilla Extract-BCS,

Simply Vanilla-DS, Glazed Donut-TC, Angel Food Cake-WSP

Coconut Cream Pie-BCN, JS

Twinkies-JS, Nanny's Country Pound Cake-DS

Aroma Haven Hey Hey Cute Cabana boy and DS Coconut Pear

Magnolia Melba from Tony's, Summer Fling from BB and Mardi Gras from OT

Bayrum: OT & SW

Candy Corn: TCS, KS, CC, JS

China Rain: TCS, JS

Raisinbread, blahblahblah: WNW, JS, FOH

CC & Daystar: Vanilla Voodoo/Ultimate Vanilla

Twigs & Berries: NG, Steves

WNW creme brulee & NG's butter brickle - very similar. even yellows my soy wax the same way

Kitchen Spice - JS & Daystar

NG's Mrs. Claus Cookies and Day Star's Vanilla Bean Noel

SC Watermelon = Day Star's Watermelon Martini

Butt Naked from At Wix End is a slightly stronger version of Tranquil Tropics of BubblesnLights (BCN)

Clean Cotton = JS, TRI-ST

Green Leaf's Starla, The Scent Work's Mayan Gold

Peaks Amish Harvest and Aroma Haven's Celtic Moon Spice- Very very Similiar

Santa Spruce (Brambleberry) and Sugared Spruce (the candle source)

Strudel from Candle Science and Graham Cracker from Green Leaf smell exactly alike out of the bottle.

Wilberry Mousse from Candle Science and Berry Creme Brulee from Milcreek

NG"s Watercress and Aloe and Peak's Green Clover in Aloe

AGE's Salty Mariner and Peaks Ocean

NG's Passionate Kisses and TCS Caribbean Holiday

Peak's Casaba Mist & AH's Badedas

JS Grammas Berry Griddlecakes is the same as CS wildberry mousse & These are also the same as ICS Wildberry Mousse

Sweetcakes Fig / BNL Fig Melon

Green Leafs -Indonesean Teak is the same as Flickers - Tuscan Lace

DS Tropical Fruit Slices = ICS Summer Medley

KY Apple Clove Butter=Flicker's Cider Snap

CS Spiced Wassail=Flicker's Autumn Spice

KY's Homemade Apple Pie ST (now ICS) Baked Apples

AH Fudge Brownie = JS Fabulous Fudge

CS Wildberry Mousse and BCN and TCS Country Berry Hotcakes

Brambleberry's Welcome Home and Tennessee Candle's This Old House

Peaks Spruce Xmas Tree and AH's Ozark Forest

GL Himalayan Blue Willow Taylored Concepts Bamboo

TCS Pomegranate GL Pomegranate

CS Very Vanilla is the same as DS Ultimate Vanilla (and CC Vanilla Voodoo

GL/TC Pumpkin Pie Spice

GL/TC Pumpkin Frappuchino

TCS/TC Peach Raspberry Magnolia

TC/AH Coco Mango

Candle Cocoon's Vanilla Voodoo ~ Millcreeks Extreme Vanilla

Candlemaker's Store (Steve's) - Harvest -Tennessee Candle - Amish Harvest

Candlemaker's Store (Steve's) - Silver Bells - Tennessee Candle - This Old House

Monkey Farts...NG and Wixnwax

Alabaster Caribbean Fruit and Kumquat are the same..or at least used to be

Muscadine--NG, WNW, Keystone, and Alabaster

Blueberry Cobbler--NG, Keystone, and ICS blueberry cheesecake

Amaretto Nog--WNW, Keystone, JS

Mulberry-NG, WNW, ICS

Kudzu--Alabaster, WNW, ICS

Peaks Fresh Linen and BCN Angel Wings

NG Tayberry & Teakwood - BCN Twigs n Berries

Sweet Tooth (AH) = Sweet Treat (JS) Aroma Haven's Sweet Seduction

JS Winter Spice

BCN's Mulled Cider....

Just Scent winterberry wreath and Candlescience med fig - Millcreeks Mediterranean Fig

CS Hazelnut and GL Hazelnut

JS Caramelized Pralines and DS White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookies

To me CC tigerlily and cantalope smell like CW white tea.

Blackberry Sage from TN, TW, & KY same

MC pears n Berries LS pearberry

Jinglebells from TN smells like any mulberry

BCN-Pomegranate and Just Scents-Cupid

Twigs & Berries by the following are all interchangable for each other - AWE, BC & NG

Bert's Aspen Forest & Flickers Balsam & Citrus

AH and Js passionate kisses

KY's Fresh Glazed Donuts smells like Warm Vanilla Sugar

Spiced Crans at BCN & ICS

KY Grandmother's Toddy and CS Hansel and Gretels House

BCN's Dreamweaver and NG's Satin Sheets

BCS Pumpkin Cheesecake and JS Pumpkin Fudge Torte

Mimosa and Mandarin CS and BC's Citrus Splash

Millcreek Soy Candle Cozy Home smells similar to me like CS's Cranberry Marmalade

Millcreek's Cinnamon Vanilla and CS Strudel and Spice are very very alike

Lonestar Sun 'N Sea and Sea Petals are identical

BCS Sissy Sugar Cookies and Southern Scentsations Snickerdoodle

BW Sandalwood Cardamom is the same as Peakes Sage & Citrus

BW Gingerbread Latte is the same as JBN Pumpkin Frapp

Bert's Lemon Biscotti Pie is the same as NG Lemon Pound Cake

BW Black Irish is the same as Flickers Green Irish Tweed

"beach daisies" from Nature's Garden smells exactly like "Sun & Sand"-Yankme dupe from Wholesale Supplies

AH/RE-French Vanilla Oak=Southern Garden Scents-Baton Rogue

Cierra's -grandmas kitchen, At wix end-grandmas kitchen, Makes scents-apple cinnamon~ all have a very similar cider scent.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 9 months later...
  • 1 month later...
  • 5 months later...

I copied the list from post #138, added the posts after 138 to the bottom of the list and then added several more (

starting from JS Aspen Winter)

Tri-State Clean Cotton and MC High Cotton

JS Mimosa Mandarin and MC Magenta Nectar

KY--roasted coffee and ICS coffee bean

KY--Wildberry Scone and ICS Wildberry----(forgot what they call theirs)

KY--Southern Vanilla and SS Country Vanilla (super close, maybe identical)

Missy's(JS)-- Christmas Cookie and KH (Keystone) Christmas Cookie

JS's-- Victorian Vanilla Lace and SS sweet snow

JS-- pomegranate and BCN Pomegranate--pretty close

KY--Creme brulee and JBN Creme brulee

Keystone(KH)--Pumpkin Fudge and SS Vanilla Pumpkin

Nature's Garden's Twigs and Berries and Tayberry and Teak Wood.

Day Star's OohLaLa and WSP's Beneath the Stars

WYW Perfect Pumpkin and WSP's Perfect Pumpkin

C&S Jade (Pier one type) and MC Dreamcatcher

Just Scent's Sea Mist smells just like Oceans (Pier 1)...

Daystar's Decadent Orange Fluff Cake smells just like NG's Hot orange danish

TW Emerald Sea and OM Calypso

Peak Jamaican Me Crazy and JS Paradise Island

Heartfelt's Enchanted, and ICS Japanese Plum!

Orange Chiffon Cake-JS, Hot Orange Danish-NG

Banana Split-DS, Monkey Farts-AH

Serendipity-JS, Cupid-BCN/BNL

Framboise Citron Cheesecake-AH, Iced Lemon Danish-Peak

Ultimate Vanilla-DS, French Vanilla-AH, Vanilla Voodoo-CC

Candy Corn-JS, CC, BCN

Eggnog-BCN, Custard-AWE

Silky V Vanilla-JS, Very Vanilla-BCN, Vanilla Extract-BCS,

Simply Vanilla-DS, Glazed Donut-TC, Angel Food Cake-WSP

Coconut Cream Pie-BCN, JS

Twinkies-JS, Nanny's Country Pound Cake-DS

Aroma Haven Hey Hey Cute Cabana boy and DS Coconut Pear

Magnolia Melba from Tony's, Summer Fling from BB and Mardi Gras from OT

Bayrum: OT & SW

Candy Corn: TCS, KS, CC, JS

China Rain: TCS, JS

Raisinbread, blahblahblah: WNW, JS, FOH

CC & Daystar: Vanilla Voodoo/Ultimate Vanilla

Twigs & Berries: NG, Steves

WNW creme brulee & NG's butter brickle - very similar. even yellows my soy wax the same way

Kitchen Spice - JS & Daystar

NG's Mrs. Claus Cookies and Day Star's Vanilla Bean Noel

SC Watermelon = Day Star's Watermelon Martini

Butt Naked from At Wix End is a slightly stronger version of Tranquil Tropics of BubblesnLights (BCN)

Clean Cotton = JS, TRI-ST

Green Leaf's Starla, The Scent Work's Mayan Gold

Peaks Amish Harvest and Aroma Haven's Celtic Moon Spice- Very very Similiar

Santa Spruce (Brambleberry) and Sugared Spruce (the candle source)

Strudel from Candle Science and Graham Cracker from Green Leaf smell exactly alike out of the bottle.

Wilberry Mousse from Candle Science and Berry Creme Brulee from Milcreek

NG"s Watercress and Aloe and Peak's Green Clover in Aloe

AGE's Salty Mariner and Peaks Ocean

NG's Passionate Kisses and TCS Caribbean Holiday

Peak's Casaba Mist & AH's Badedas

JS Grammas Berry Griddlecakes is the same as CS wildberry mousse & These are also the same as ICS Wildberry Mousse

Sweetcakes Fig / BNL Fig Melon

Green Leafs -Indonesean Teak is the same as Flickers - Tuscan Lace

DS Tropical Fruit Slices = ICS Summer Medley

KY Apple Clove Butter=Flicker's Cider Snap

CS Spiced Wassail=Flicker's Autumn Spice

KY's Homemade Apple Pie ST (now ICS) Baked Apples

AH Fudge Brownie = JS Fabulous Fudge

CS Wildberry Mousse and BCN and TCS Country Berry Hotcakes

Brambleberry's Welcome Home and Tennessee Candle's This Old House

Peaks Spruce Xmas Tree and AH's Ozark Forest

GL Himalayan Blue Willow Taylored Concepts Bamboo

TCS Pomegranate GL Pomegranate

CS Very Vanilla is the same as DS Ultimate Vanilla (and CC Vanilla Voodoo

GL/TC Pumpkin Pie Spice

GL/TC Pumpkin Frappuchino

TCS/TC Peach Raspberry Magnolia

TC/AH Coco Mango

Candle Cocoon's Vanilla Voodoo ~ Millcreeks Extreme Vanilla

Candlemaker's Store (Steve's) - Harvest -Tennessee Candle - Amish Harvest

Candlemaker's Store (Steve's) - Silver Bells - Tennessee Candle - This Old House

Monkey Farts...NG and Wixnwax

Alabaster Caribbean Fruit and Kumquat are the same..or at least used to be

Muscadine--NG, WNW, Keystone, and Alabaster

Blueberry Cobbler--NG, Keystone, and ICS blueberry cheesecake

Amaretto Nog--WNW, Keystone, JS

Mulberry-NG, WNW, ICS

Kudzu--Alabaster, WNW, ICS

Peaks Fresh Linen and BCN Angel Wings

NG Tayberry & Teakwood - BCN Twigs n Berries

Sweet Tooth (AH) = Sweet Treat (JS) Aroma Haven's Sweet Seduction

JS Winter Spice

BCN's Mulled Cider....

Just Scent winterberry wreath and Candlescience med fig - Millcreeks Mediterranean Fig

CS Hazelnut and GL Hazelnut

JS Caramelized Pralines and DS White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookies

To me CC tigerlily and cantalope smell like CW white tea.

Blackberry Sage from TN, TW, & KY same

MC pears n Berries LS pearberry

Jinglebells from TN smells like any mulberry

BCN-Pomegranate and Just Scents-Cupid

Twigs & Berries by the following are all interchangable for each other - AWE, BC & NG

Bert's Aspen Forest & Flickers Balsam & Citrus

AH and Js passionate kisses

KY's Fresh Glazed Donuts smells like Warm Vanilla Sugar

Spiced Crans at BCN & ICS

KY Grandmother's Toddy and CS Hansel and Gretels House

BCN's Dreamweaver and NG's Satin Sheets

BCS Pumpkin Cheesecake and JS Pumpkin Fudge Torte

Mimosa and Mandarin CS and BC's Citrus Splash

Millcreek Soy Candle Cozy Home smells similar to me like CS's Cranberry Marmalade

Millcreek's Cinnamon Vanilla and CS Strudel and Spice are very very alike

Lonestar Sun 'N Sea and Sea Petals are identical

BCS Sissy Sugar Cookies and Southern Scentsations Snickerdoodle

BW Sandalwood Cardamom is the same as Peakes Sage & Citrus

BW Gingerbread Latte is the same as JBN Pumpkin Frapp

Bert's Lemon Biscotti Pie is the same as NG Lemon Pound Cake

BW Black Irish is the same as Flickers Green Irish Tweed

"beach daisies" from Nature's Garden smells exactly like "Sun & Sand"-Yankme dupe from Wholesale Supplies

AH/RE-French Vanilla Oak=Southern Garden Scents-Baton Rogue

Cierra's -grandmas kitchen, At wix end-grandmas kitchen, Makes scents-apple cinnamon~ all have a very similar cider scent.

Elements Patchouli Honey and Moonwork's Native Princess

Sugared Spruce from Candle Soylutions is the same as Aztec's, WSP and BB Santa's Spruce

DayStar's Paridise = Oregon Trails Fruit Loops

Tennessee's Spiced Apples & Peaches = Sweet Cakes Cinnamon Apple Peach

Bert's Aspen Forest = Moonworks Winter Festival

Candlewic's Spa = WSP's Aqua Spa (WSP's is stronger, but same scent)

NG's Mermaid Kisses and ICS Cactus and Sea Salt.

JS Vanilla Bean Noel and NG Vanilla Valentine

Candlewic's sugared vanilla shortbread and Moonworks (Venus Candles) sugar cookie royale

Candle Science - Sage and Pomegranate is the same as Millcreek Northern Red Currant

JS Aspen Winter and The Candle Source Sleigh Ride

Peaks Clean Cotton and The Candle Source Clean Cotton

BCN Spiced Cranberry and Tenn Spiced Cranberry

JS Vanilla Bean Noel (type) and Tenn Vanilla Bean Noel (type)

KY Zucchini Bread and The Candle Source Grammy's Zucchini Bread

CS Black Rasp Vanilla and Peaks Black Rasp Vanilla

JS Cinnamon Buns w/vanilla & The Candle Source Cinn Buns w/vanilla are very similar

BCS Harvest and JS Harvest smell the same OOB but IMO the BCS throws a bit better

Peaks Amish Harvest & Tenn Amish Harvest are very similar

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 4 months later...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


×
×
  • Create New...