Candlebuddy Posted October 1, 2008 Share Posted October 1, 2008 Yes, I agree ... KY's Fresh Glazed Donuts smells like Warm Vanilla Sugar to me too. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TraciS Posted October 1, 2008 Share Posted October 1, 2008 Spiced Crans at BCN & ICS are twins. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Brenda (OH) Posted October 2, 2008 Share Posted October 2, 2008 To my nose KY Grandmother's Toddy and CS Hansel and Gretels House smell the same . . .anyone else notice this ? or is my nose fried already . . Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
cwuer Posted November 6, 2008 Share Posted November 6, 2008 I can't remember the one I got last time. Maybe it was NG, but it was really good. Any help with spiced cranberry? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
so-soy Posted January 26, 2009 Share Posted January 26, 2009 BCN's Dreamweaver and NG's Satin Sheets is soooo close to being the exact scent its really hard to tell the two apart when sniffing the scent on each hand. OOB, there might be a slight difference, but on the skin it is so close, IMO they could be used as the same scent. Same color oil too! Sure do smell good! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Jaime Posted January 26, 2009 Share Posted January 26, 2009 BCS Pumpkin Cheesecake and JS Pumpkin Fudge Torte smell the same OOB. At least to my nose anyways! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
katcandlemaker Posted January 27, 2009 Share Posted January 27, 2009 Mimosa and Mandarin CS and BC's Citrus SplashMillcreek Soy Candle Cozy Home smells similar to me like CS's Cranberry Marmalade. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Mountain_Annie Posted February 13, 2009 Share Posted February 13, 2009 Hi all, Is Peak's Cranberry Apple Marmalade the same as the CS Cranberry Marmalade? They smell identical to my nose today. It may just be me...but if any of you have both...could you check and LMK what you think? Thanks a bunch.Mt Annie Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
katcandlemaker Posted February 13, 2009 Share Posted February 13, 2009 Found another while ordering something new, ugh. Millcreek's Cinnamon Vanilla and CS Strudel and Spice are very very alike. OOB MC is a little stronger, but after putting it in wax, can't tell the difference between the two scented candles. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
countyline Posted February 13, 2009 Share Posted February 13, 2009 Lonestar Sun 'N Sea and Sea Petals are identical. I think that Sun N Sea is gel safe and Sea Petals is not. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Marisa Posted March 25, 2009 Share Posted March 25, 2009 Im not sure if this was listed, but BCS Sissy Sugar Cookies and Southern Scentsations Snickerdoodle smell amazingly close if not the same to me. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
chuck_35550 Posted July 25, 2009 Share Posted July 25, 2009 BW Sandalwood Cardamom is the same as Peakes Sage & CitrusBW Gingerbread Latte is the same as JBN Pumpkin FrappBert's Lemon Biscotti Pie is the same as NG Lemon Pound CakeBW Black Irish is the same as Flickers Green Irish Tweed Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
melissaroth6868 Posted July 25, 2009 Share Posted July 25, 2009 The new "beach daisies" from Nature's Garden smells exactly like "Sun & Sand"-Yankme dupe from Wholesale Supplies (so buy from NG and save $) Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Donna-Do Posted July 25, 2009 Share Posted July 25, 2009 The last fragrance twins I came across were:AH/RE-French Vanilla Oak=Southern Garden Scents-Baton Rogue Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
candlelady Posted July 25, 2009 Share Posted July 25, 2009 Apparently I don't have much to do this AM, so I compiled a listing of dupes that have been posted on this thread into one big list!Tri-State Clean Cotton and MC High CottonJS Mimosa Mandarin and MC Magenta NectarKY--roasted coffee and ICS coffee beanKY--Wildberry Scone and ICS Wildberry----(forgot what they call theirs)KY--Southern Vanilla and SS Country Vanilla (super close, maybe identical)Missy's(JS)-- Christmas Cookie and KH (Keystone) Christmas CookieJS's-- Victorian Vanilla Lace and SS sweet snowJS-- pomegranate and BCN Pomegranate--pretty closeKY--Creme brulee and JBN Creme bruleeKeystone(KH)--Pumpkin Fudge and SS Vanilla PumpkinNature's Garden's Twigs and Berries and Tayberry and Teak Wood.Day Star's OohLaLa and WSP's Beneath the StarsWYW Perfect Pumpkin and WSP's Perfect PumpkinC&S Jade (Pier one type) and MC DreamcatcherJust Scent's Sea Mist smells just like Oceans (Pier 1)...Daystar's Decadent Orange Fluff Cake smells just like NG's Hot orange danishTW Emerald Sea and OM CalypsoPeak Jamaican Me Crazy and JS Paradise IslandHeartfelt's Enchanted, and ICS Japanese Plum!Orange Chiffon Cake-JS, Hot Orange Danish-NGBanana Split-DS, Monkey Farts-AHSerendipity-JS, Cupid-BCN/BNLFramboise Citron Cheesecake-AH, Iced Lemon Danish-PeakUltimate Vanilla-DS, French Vanilla-AH, Vanilla Voodoo-CCCandy Corn-JS, CC, BCN Eggnog-BCN, Custard-AWESilky V Vanilla-JS, Very Vanilla-BCN, Vanilla Extract-BCS, Simply Vanilla-DS, Glazed Donut-TC, Angel Food Cake-WSPCoconut Cream Pie-BCN, JSTwinkies-JS, Nanny's Country Pound Cake-DSAroma Haven Hey Hey Cute Cabana boy and DS Coconut PearMagnolia Melba from Tony's, Summer Fling from BB and Mardi Gras from OT Bayrum: OT & SWCandy Corn: TCS, KS, CC, JSChina Rain: TCS, JSRaisinbread, blahblahblah: WNW, JS, FOHCC & Daystar: Vanilla Voodoo/Ultimate VanillaTwigs & Berries: NG, StevesWNW creme brulee & NG's butter brickle - very similar. even yellows my soy wax the same wayKitchen Spice - JS & DaystarNG's Mrs. Claus Cookies and Day Star's Vanilla Bean NoelSC Watermelon = Day Star's Watermelon MartiniButt Naked from At Wix End is a slightly stronger version of Tranquil Tropics of BubblesnLights (BCN)Clean Cotton = JS, TRI-STGreen Leaf's Starla, The Scent Work's Mayan GoldPeaks Amish Harvest and Aroma Haven's Celtic Moon Spice- Very very SimiliarSanta Spruce (Brambleberry) and Sugared Spruce (the candle source)Strudel from Candle Science and Graham Cracker from Green Leaf smell exactly alike out of the bottle.Wilberry Mousse from Candle Science and Berry Creme Brulee from MilcreekNG"s Watercress and Aloe and Peak's Green Clover in AloeAGE's Salty Mariner and Peaks OceanNG's Passionate Kisses and TCS Caribbean HolidayPeak's Casaba Mist & AH's BadedasJS Grammas Berry Griddlecakes is the same as CS wildberry mousse & These are also the same as ICS Wildberry MousseSweetcakes Fig / BNL Fig MelonGreen Leafs -Indonesean Teak is the same as Flickers - Tuscan LaceDS Tropical Fruit Slices = ICS Summer MedleyKY Apple Clove Butter=Flicker's Cider SnapCS Spiced Wassail=Flicker's Autumn SpiceKY's Homemade Apple Pie ST (now ICS) Baked ApplesAH Fudge Brownie = JS Fabulous FudgeCS Wildberry Mousse and BCN and TCS Country Berry HotcakesBrambleberry's Welcome Home and Tennessee Candle's This Old HousePeaks Spruce Xmas Tree and AH's Ozark ForestGL Himalayan Blue Willow Taylored Concepts BambooTCS Pomegranate GL PomegranateCS Very Vanilla is the same as DS Ultimate Vanilla (and CC Vanilla VoodooGL/TC Pumpkin Pie SpiceGL/TC Pumpkin FrappuchinoTCS/TC Peach Raspberry MagnoliaTC/AH Coco MangoCandle Cocoon's Vanilla Voodoo ~ Millcreeks Extreme VanillaCandlemaker's Store (Steve's) - Harvest -Tennessee Candle - Amish HarvestCandlemaker's Store (Steve's) - Silver Bells - Tennessee Candle - This Old HouseMonkey Farts...NG and WixnwaxAlabaster Caribbean Fruit and Kumquat are the same..or at least used to beMuscadine--NG, WNW, Keystone, and AlabasterBlueberry Cobbler--NG, Keystone, and ICS blueberry cheesecakeAmaretto Nog--WNW, Keystone, JSMulberry-NG, WNW, ICSKudzu--Alabaster, WNW, ICSPeaks Fresh Linen and BCN Angel WingsNG Tayberry & Teakwood - BCN Twigs n BerriesSweet Tooth (AH) = Sweet Treat (JS) Aroma Haven's Sweet SeductionJS Winter SpiceBCN's Mulled Cider....Just Scent winterberry wreath and Candlescience med fig - Millcreeks Mediterranean FigCS Hazelnut and GL HazelnutJS Caramelized Pralines and DS White Chocolate Macadamia Nut CookiesTo me CC tigerlily and cantalope smell like CW white tea.Blackberry Sage from TN, TW, & KY sameMC pears n Berries LS pearberryJinglebells from TN smells like any mulberryBCN-Pomegranate and Just Scents-CupidTwigs & Berries by the following are all interchangable for each other - AWE, BC & NGBert's Aspen Forest & Flickers Balsam & CitrusAH and Js passionate kissesKY's Fresh Glazed Donuts smells like Warm Vanilla Sugar Spiced Crans at BCN & ICSKY Grandmother's Toddy and CS Hansel and Gretels HouseBCN's Dreamweaver and NG's Satin SheetsBCS Pumpkin Cheesecake and JS Pumpkin Fudge TorteMimosa and Mandarin CS and BC's Citrus SplashMillcreek Soy Candle Cozy Home smells similar to me like CS's Cranberry MarmaladeMillcreek's Cinnamon Vanilla and CS Strudel and Spice are very very alikeLonestar Sun 'N Sea and Sea Petals are identicalBCS Sissy Sugar Cookies and Southern Scentsations Snickerdoodle BW Sandalwood Cardamom is the same as Peakes Sage & CitrusBW Gingerbread Latte is the same as JBN Pumpkin FrappBert's Lemon Biscotti Pie is the same as NG Lemon Pound CakeBW Black Irish is the same as Flickers Green Irish Tweed"beach daisies" from Nature's Garden smells exactly like "Sun & Sand"-Yankme dupe from Wholesale Supplies AH/RE-French Vanilla Oak=Southern Garden Scents-Baton Rogue 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
earthfriendly Posted July 25, 2009 Share Posted July 25, 2009 WOW!!! Thanks Carrie, that sure saves us time from having to back track looking for the info. This is great. Thank you for taking the time to do this. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Sharon in KY Posted July 25, 2009 Share Posted July 25, 2009 Thank you, I couldn't have typed all that in a week. Typing is not one of my skills... I emailed it to myself so I could print and keep with scent list. Thanks again. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Daves'sHomemade Posted July 25, 2009 Share Posted July 25, 2009 Thanks All...And Carrie Very helpful Dave Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
candlelady Posted July 26, 2009 Share Posted July 26, 2009 You are all very welcome! Copy and paste into Notebook then copied all into this post...It was only 11 pages of posts....whew!Glad to help.Carrie Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
kimmeroo Posted July 26, 2009 Share Posted July 26, 2009 The new "beach daisies" from Nature's Garden smells exactly like "Sun & Sand"-Yankme dupe from Wholesale Supplies (so buy from NG and save $)Thanks! I just ordered BD from JS and was going to get the dupe for SS Yankme! You saved me some $$$$.... Thanks again!While i am here posting...does anyone know of a dupe for BCN's Autumn Spice..that was my very favorite they don't have it anymore..I bought a few samples from JS and kinda thought Holiday Wassail smelled similar but I haven't put it into wax yet..????Any help would be appreciated!Kimmeroo Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
candlelady Posted July 26, 2009 Share Posted July 26, 2009 I received my samples from JS and one was BD....it's close to WSP Sun & Sand, but not totally identical IMO. There's another note in JS version but I can't figure that out.Carrie Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Lizzy Posted July 26, 2009 Share Posted July 26, 2009 BCS Pumpkin Cheesecake and JS' Pumpkin Fudge Torte are 99.9% indentical Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
earthfriendly Posted July 26, 2009 Share Posted July 26, 2009 Ok I have 3 scents that are almost identical to me, they are Santal from SS, Sultry Angel from CC, and Indonesion Teak from JBN. The two closest to me are Santal & Indo. Teak. By the way these are in wax not oob. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
candlelady Posted July 28, 2009 Share Posted July 28, 2009 Have an idea! When someone wants to "add" to the list, the next person that reads this and wants to add, go to my post and click on quote at the bottom, remove the text in the [ ] at the beginning of the post and end, and add yours to the bottom of the list and repost. That way, the list keeps growing....Just a thought.:rolleyes2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
RWV Posted August 30, 2009 Share Posted August 30, 2009 Apparently I don't have much to do this AM, so I compiled a listing of dupes that have been posted on this thread into one big list!Tri-State Clean Cotton and MC High CottonJS Mimosa Mandarin and MC Magenta NectarKY--roasted coffee and ICS coffee beanKY--Wildberry Scone and ICS Wildberry----(forgot what they call theirs)KY--Southern Vanilla and SS Country Vanilla (super close, maybe identical)Missy's(JS)-- Christmas Cookie and KH (Keystone) Christmas CookieJS's-- Victorian Vanilla Lace and SS sweet snowJS-- pomegranate and BCN Pomegranate--pretty closeKY--Creme brulee and JBN Creme bruleeKeystone(KH)--Pumpkin Fudge and SS Vanilla PumpkinNature's Garden's Twigs and Berries and Tayberry and Teak Wood.Day Star's OohLaLa and WSP's Beneath the StarsWYW Perfect Pumpkin and WSP's Perfect PumpkinC&S Jade (Pier one type) and MC DreamcatcherJust Scent's Sea Mist smells just like Oceans (Pier 1)...Daystar's Decadent Orange Fluff Cake smells just like NG's Hot orange danishTW Emerald Sea and OM CalypsoPeak Jamaican Me Crazy and JS Paradise IslandHeartfelt's Enchanted, and ICS Japanese Plum!Orange Chiffon Cake-JS, Hot Orange Danish-NGBanana Split-DS, Monkey Farts-AHSerendipity-JS, Cupid-BCN/BNLFramboise Citron Cheesecake-AH, Iced Lemon Danish-PeakUltimate Vanilla-DS, French Vanilla-AH, Vanilla Voodoo-CCCandy Corn-JS, CC, BCN Eggnog-BCN, Custard-AWESilky V Vanilla-JS, Very Vanilla-BCN, Vanilla Extract-BCS, Simply Vanilla-DS, Glazed Donut-TC, Angel Food Cake-WSPCoconut Cream Pie-BCN, JSTwinkies-JS, Nanny's Country Pound Cake-DSAroma Haven Hey Hey Cute Cabana boy and DS Coconut PearMagnolia Melba from Tony's, Summer Fling from BB and Mardi Gras from OT Bayrum: OT & SWCandy Corn: TCS, KS, CC, JSChina Rain: TCS, JSRaisinbread, blahblahblah: WNW, JS, FOHCC & Daystar: Vanilla Voodoo/Ultimate VanillaTwigs & Berries: NG, StevesWNW creme brulee & NG's butter brickle - very similar. even yellows my soy wax the same wayKitchen Spice - JS & DaystarNG's Mrs. Claus Cookies and Day Star's Vanilla Bean NoelSC Watermelon = Day Star's Watermelon MartiniButt Naked from At Wix End is a slightly stronger version of Tranquil Tropics of BubblesnLights (BCN)Clean Cotton = JS, TRI-STGreen Leaf's Starla, The Scent Work's Mayan GoldPeaks Amish Harvest and Aroma Haven's Celtic Moon Spice- Very very SimiliarSanta Spruce (Brambleberry) and Sugared Spruce (the candle source)Strudel from Candle Science and Graham Cracker from Green Leaf smell exactly alike out of the bottle.Wilberry Mousse from Candle Science and Berry Creme Brulee from MilcreekNG"s Watercress and Aloe and Peak's Green Clover in AloeAGE's Salty Mariner and Peaks OceanNG's Passionate Kisses and TCS Caribbean HolidayPeak's Casaba Mist & AH's BadedasJS Grammas Berry Griddlecakes is the same as CS wildberry mousse & These are also the same as ICS Wildberry MousseSweetcakes Fig / BNL Fig MelonGreen Leafs -Indonesean Teak is the same as Flickers - Tuscan LaceDS Tropical Fruit Slices = ICS Summer MedleyKY Apple Clove Butter=Flicker's Cider SnapCS Spiced Wassail=Flicker's Autumn SpiceKY's Homemade Apple Pie ST (now ICS) Baked ApplesAH Fudge Brownie = JS Fabulous FudgeCS Wildberry Mousse and BCN and TCS Country Berry HotcakesBrambleberry's Welcome Home and Tennessee Candle's This Old HousePeaks Spruce Xmas Tree and AH's Ozark ForestGL Himalayan Blue Willow Taylored Concepts BambooTCS Pomegranate GL PomegranateCS Very Vanilla is the same as DS Ultimate Vanilla (and CC Vanilla VoodooGL/TC Pumpkin Pie SpiceGL/TC Pumpkin FrappuchinoTCS/TC Peach Raspberry MagnoliaTC/AH Coco MangoCandle Cocoon's Vanilla Voodoo ~ Millcreeks Extreme VanillaCandlemaker's Store (Steve's) - Harvest -Tennessee Candle - Amish HarvestCandlemaker's Store (Steve's) - Silver Bells - Tennessee Candle - This Old HouseMonkey Farts...NG and WixnwaxAlabaster Caribbean Fruit and Kumquat are the same..or at least used to beMuscadine--NG, WNW, Keystone, and AlabasterBlueberry Cobbler--NG, Keystone, and ICS blueberry cheesecakeAmaretto Nog--WNW, Keystone, JSMulberry-NG, WNW, ICSKudzu--Alabaster, WNW, ICSPeaks Fresh Linen and BCN Angel WingsNG Tayberry & Teakwood - BCN Twigs n BerriesSweet Tooth (AH) = Sweet Treat (JS) Aroma Haven's Sweet SeductionJS Winter SpiceBCN's Mulled Cider....Just Scent winterberry wreath and Candlescience med fig - Millcreeks Mediterranean FigCS Hazelnut and GL HazelnutJS Caramelized Pralines and DS White Chocolate Macadamia Nut CookiesTo me CC tigerlily and cantalope smell like CW white tea.Blackberry Sage from TN, TW, & KY sameMC pears n Berries LS pearberryJinglebells from TN smells like any mulberryBCN-Pomegranate and Just Scents-CupidTwigs & Berries by the following are all interchangable for each other - AWE, BC & NGBert's Aspen Forest & Flickers Balsam & CitrusAH and Js passionate kissesKY's Fresh Glazed Donuts smells like Warm Vanilla Sugar Spiced Crans at BCN & ICSKY Grandmother's Toddy and CS Hansel and Gretels HouseBCN's Dreamweaver and NG's Satin SheetsBCS Pumpkin Cheesecake and JS Pumpkin Fudge TorteMimosa and Mandarin CS and BC's Citrus SplashMillcreek Soy Candle Cozy Home smells similar to me like CS's Cranberry MarmaladeMillcreek's Cinnamon Vanilla and CS Strudel and Spice are very very alikeLonestar Sun 'N Sea and Sea Petals are identicalBCS Sissy Sugar Cookies and Southern Scentsations Snickerdoodle BW Sandalwood Cardamom is the same as Peakes Sage & CitrusBW Gingerbread Latte is the same as JBN Pumpkin FrappBert's Lemon Biscotti Pie is the same as NG Lemon Pound CakeBW Black Irish is the same as Flickers Green Irish Tweed"beach daisies" from Nature's Garden smells exactly like "Sun & Sand"-Yankme dupe from Wholesale Supplies AH/RE-French Vanilla Oak=Southern Garden Scents-Baton RogueJS Nostalgia and Aztec's Smell of Christmas Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.