Fragrance Twins

[ChandlerWicks]

Uh Oh I just added 2 at the end. The initial post was Megandgarrs work!

[megandgarr]

Lets call if a group effort by many members. I certainly didnt do the bulk of the work either. I took a huge list that someone else had worked on and simply updated it with additional posts so I can not take the credit either. 

 

Is this the type of post that should be a sticky? It tends to get buried in the fragrance section and forgotten. It sure is nice to be able to look up a much needed FO to see if it can be found elsewhere, and it also helps to prevent us from buying a sample of something that we may already have by another supplier. 

[Lorelei]

I'd love this as a sticky!

[jackbenimble]

Wanted to add another twin to the list. Its the bottom one listed in BOLD type. 

Tri-State Clean Cotton and MC High Cotton

JS Mimosa Mandarin and MC Magenta Nectar
KY--roasted coffee and ICS coffee bean
KY--Wildberry Scone and ICS Wildberry----(forgot what they call theirs)
KY--Southern Vanilla and SS Country Vanilla (super close, maybe identical)
Missy's(JS)-- Christmas Cookie and KH (Keystone) Christmas Cookie
JS's-- Victorian Vanilla Lace and SS sweet snow
JS-- pomegranate and BCN Pomegranate--pretty close
KY--Creme brulee and JBN Creme brulee
Keystone(KH)--Pumpkin Fudge and SS Vanilla Pumpkin
Nature's Garden's Twigs and Berries and Tayberry and Teak Wood.
Day Star's OohLaLa and WSP's Beneath the Stars
WYW Perfect Pumpkin and WSP's Perfect Pumpkin
C&S Jade (Pier one type) and MC Dreamcatcher
Just Scent's Sea Mist smells just like Oceans (Pier 1)...
Daystar's Decadent Orange Fluff Cake smells just like NG's Hot orange danish
TW Emerald Sea and OM Calypso
Peak Jamaican Me Crazy and JS Paradise Island
Heartfelt's Enchanted, and ICS Japanese Plum!
Orange Chiffon Cake-JS, Hot Orange Danish-NG
Banana Split-DS, Monkey Farts-AH
Serendipity-JS, Cupid-BCN/BNL
Framboise Citron Cheesecake-AH, Iced Lemon Danish-Peak
Ultimate Vanilla-DS, French Vanilla-AH, Vanilla Voodoo-CC
Candy Corn-JS, CC, BCN 
Eggnog-BCN, Custard-AWE
Silky V Vanilla-JS, Very Vanilla-BCN, Vanilla Extract-BCS, 
Simply Vanilla-DS, Glazed Donut-TC, Angel Food Cake-WSP
Coconut Cream Pie-BCN, JS
Twinkies-JS, Nanny's Country Pound Cake-DS
Aroma Haven Hey Hey Cute Cabana boy and DS Coconut Pear
Magnolia Melba from Tony's, Summer Fling from BB and Mardi Gras from OT 
Bayrum: OT & SW
Candy Corn: TCS, KS, CC, JS
China Rain: TCS, JS
Raisinbread, blahblahblah: WNW, JS, FOH
CC & Daystar: Vanilla Voodoo/Ultimate Vanilla
Twigs & Berries: NG, Steves
WNW creme brulee & NG's butter brickle - very similar. even yellows my soy wax the same way
Kitchen Spice - JS & Daystar
NG's Mrs. Claus Cookies and Day Star's Vanilla Bean Noel
SC Watermelon = Day Star's Watermelon Martini
Butt Naked from At Wix End is a slightly stronger version of Tranquil Tropics of BubblesnLights (BCN)
Clean Cotton = JS, TRI-ST
Green Leaf's Starla, The Scent Work's Mayan Gold
Peaks Amish Harvest and Aroma Haven's Celtic Moon Spice- Very very Similiar
Santa Spruce (Brambleberry) and Sugared Spruce (the candle source)
Strudel from Candle Science and Graham Cracker from Green Leaf smell exactly alike out of the bottle.
Wilberry Mousse from Candle Science and Berry Creme Brulee from Milcreek
NG"s Watercress and Aloe and Peak's Green Clover in Aloe
AGE's Salty Mariner and Peaks Ocean
NG's Passionate Kisses and TCS Caribbean Holiday
Peak's Casaba Mist & AH's Badedas
JS Grammas Berry Griddlecakes is the same as CS wildberry mousse & These are also the same as ICS Wildberry Mousse
Sweetcakes Fig / BNL Fig Melon
Green Leafs -Indonesean Teak is the same as Flickers - Tuscan Lace
DS Tropical Fruit Slices = ICS Summer Medley
KY Apple Clove Butter=Flicker's Cider Snap
CS Spiced Wassail=Flicker's Autumn Spice
KY's Homemade Apple Pie ST (now ICS) Baked Apples
AH Fudge Brownie = JS Fabulous Fudge
CS Wildberry Mousse and BCN and TCS Country Berry Hotcakes
Brambleberry's Welcome Home and Tennessee Candle's This Old House
Peaks Spruce Xmas Tree and AH's Ozark Forest
GL Himalayan Blue Willow Taylored Concepts Bamboo
TCS Pomegranate GL Pomegranate
CS Very Vanilla is the same as DS Ultimate Vanilla (and CC Vanilla Voodoo
GL/TC Pumpkin Pie Spice
GL/TC Pumpkin Frappuchino
TCS/TC Peach Raspberry Magnolia
TC/AH Coco Mango
Candle Cocoon's Vanilla Voodoo ~ Millcreeks Extreme Vanilla
Candlemaker's Store (Steve's) - Harvest -Tennessee Candle - Amish Harvest

Candlemaker's Store (Steve's) - Silver Bells - Tennessee Candle - This Old House

Update: I needed This Old House and Tennessee Candles was out of stock so I ordered Candlemakers Store Silver Bells grade A and to my nose they are nothing alike - sorry. I smell pine in it I think but it is not This Old House

Monkey Farts...NG and Wixnwax

Alabaster Caribbean Fruit and Kumquat are the same..or at least used to be
Muscadine--NG, WNW, Keystone, and Alabaster
Blueberry Cobbler--NG, Keystone, and ICS blueberry cheesecake
Amaretto Nog--WNW, Keystone, JS
Mulberry-NG, WNW, ICS
Kudzu--Alabaster, WNW, ICS
Peaks Fresh Linen and BCN Angel Wings
NG Tayberry & Teakwood - BCN Twigs n Berries
Sweet Tooth (AH) = Sweet Treat (JS) Aroma Haven's Sweet Seduction
JS Winter Spice
BCN's Mulled Cider....
Just Scent winterberry wreath and Candlescience med fig - Millcreeks Mediterranean Fig
CS Hazelnut and GL Hazelnut
JS Caramelized Pralines and DS White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookies
To me CC tigerlily and cantalope smell like CW white tea.
Blackberry Sage from TN, TW, & KY same
MC pears n Berries LS pearberry
Jinglebells from TN smells like any mulberry
BCN-Pomegranate and Just Scents-Cupid
Twigs & Berries by the following are all interchangable for each other - AWE, BC & NG
Bert's Aspen Forest & Flickers Balsam & Citrus
AH and Js passionate kisses
KY's Fresh Glazed Donuts smells like Warm Vanilla Sugar 
Spiced Crans at BCN & ICS
KY Grandmother's Toddy and CS Hansel and Gretels House
BCN's Dreamweaver and NG's Satin Sheets
BCS Pumpkin Cheesecake and JS Pumpkin Fudge Torte
Mimosa and Mandarin CS and BC's Citrus Splash
Millcreek Soy Candle Cozy Home smells similar to me like CS's Cranberry Marmalade
Millcreek's Cinnamon Vanilla and CS Strudel and Spice are very very alike
Lonestar Sun 'N Sea and Sea Petals are identical
BCS Sissy Sugar Cookies and Southern Scentsations Snickerdoodle 
BW Sandalwood Cardamom is the same as Peakes Sage & Citrus
BW Gingerbread Latte is the same as JBN Pumpkin Frapp
Bert's Lemon Biscotti Pie is the same as NG Lemon Pound Cake
BW Black Irish is the same as Flickers Green Irish Tweed
"beach daisies" from Nature's Garden smells exactly like "Sun & Sand"-Yankme dupe from Wholesale Supplies 
AH/RE-French Vanilla Oak=Southern Garden Scents-Baton Rogue
Cierra's -grandmas kitchen, At wix end-grandmas kitchen, Makes scents-apple cinnamon~ all have a very similar cider scent. 
Elements Patchouli Honey and Moonwork's Native Princess
Sugared Spruce from Candle Soylutions is the same as Aztec's, WSP and BB Santa's Spruce
DayStar's Paridise = Oregon Trails Fruit Loops
Tennessee's Spiced Apples & Peaches = Sweet Cakes Cinnamon Apple Peach
Bert's Aspen Forest = Moonworks Winter Festival
Candlewic's Spa = WSP's Aqua Spa (WSP's is stronger, but same scent)
NG's Mermaid Kisses and ICS Cactus and Sea Salt.
JS Vanilla Bean Noel and NG Vanilla Valentine 
Candlewic's sugared vanilla shortbread and Moonworks (Venus Candles) sugar cookie royale
Candle Science - Sage and Pomegranate is the same as Millcreek Northern Red Currant
JS Aspen Winter and The Candle Source Sleigh Ride
Peaks Clean Cotton and The Candle Source Clean Cotton
BCN Spiced Cranberry and Tenn Spiced Cranberry
JS Vanilla Bean Noel (type) and Tenn Vanilla Bean Noel (type)
KY Zucchini Bread and The Candle Source Grammy's Zucchini Bread
CS Black Rasp Vanilla and Peaks Black Rasp Vanilla
JS Cinnamon Buns w/vanilla & The Candle Source Cinn Buns w/vanilla are very similar
BCS Harvest and JS Harvest smell the same OOB but IMO the BCS throws a bit better
Peaks Amish Harvest & Tenn Amish Harvest are very similar 

AHRE's Butternut Pumpkin smells very, very similar to JS's Frosted Pumpkin and MC's Frosted Carrot Cake

Elements had a scent called Olive Blossom and I swear it smells like MoonWorks Floral Muse FO

I have never smelled MoonWorks Floral Muse, but Elements Olive Blossom smells the same to me as CS Rain Water

Bert's Aspen Forest and Fillmore Citrus Spruce smell identical to me - or close enough to make me happy

Moonworks Pinion pine smells exact to me as CS mistletoe

AH/RE Sugar Corn Pudding smells the same as BCN Amish Friendship Bread

Aztec's Sweet Winterberry & Rustic Escentuals Frosted Winterberry

Also Peaks country berry hotcakes and ICS Wildberry Mousse. Also, Peaks country berry hotcakes smells just like JS cbh

The Scent Works..Sweet Lodge Smoke..and DayStar's..Hunters Moon smell very very much alike

MW gypsy rose and Elements sensuous black rose are very much alike but I can get MW to throw stronger in a candle

Peaks & Candlewic Black Raspberry Vanilla

Peaks Blueberry Cobbler and Candlewic Blueberry Pie

Community Candle Dickens Christmas and The Candlesource Christmas Splendor

NG Strawberry Passion & BCN Strawberry Jam

Candlescience & The Candlesource Mulberry 

according to my notes but I can not remember for sure: Community Candle Mulled Cider & Tennessee Apple Cider

Peaks & AH/RE Orange Chiffon Cake

ICS & AH/RE Salty Sea Air

BRV-Peaks & Candlewic

Wild Mountain Honey-Peak, Flaming Candle Company & Elements-Honey  L'Occitane Type

Peaks (Winter Orange Spice) & Lonestar (Autumn Harvest)- same

Edited April 6, 2015 by jackbenimble

[Ray]

Bumping this great thread back up. Hopefully folks can add to it.

[Belinda]

Tri-State Clean Cotton and MC High Cotton

JS Mimosa Mandarin and MC Magenta Nectar
KY--roasted coffee and ICS coffee bean
KY--Wildberry Scone and ICS Wildberry----(forgot what they call theirs)
KY--Southern Vanilla and SS Country Vanilla (super close, maybe identical)
Missy's(JS)-- Christmas Cookie and KH (Keystone) Christmas Cookie
JS's-- Victorian Vanilla Lace and SS sweet snow
JS-- pomegranate and BCN Pomegranate--pretty close
KY--Creme brulee and JBN Creme brulee
Keystone(KH)--Pumpkin Fudge and SS Vanilla Pumpkin
Nature's Garden's Twigs and Berries and Tayberry and Teak Wood.
Day Star's OohLaLa and WSP's Beneath the Stars
WYW Perfect Pumpkin and WSP's Perfect Pumpkin
C&S Jade (Pier one type) and MC Dreamcatcher
Just Scent's Sea Mist smells just like Oceans (Pier 1)...
Daystar's Decadent Orange Fluff Cake smells just like NG's Hot orange danish
TW Emerald Sea and OM Calypso
Peak Jamaican Me Crazy and JS Paradise Island
Heartfelt's Enchanted, and ICS Japanese Plum!
Orange Chiffon Cake-JS, Hot Orange Danish-NG
Banana Split-DS, Monkey Farts-AH
Serendipity-JS, Cupid-BCN/BNL
Framboise Citron Cheesecake-AH, Iced Lemon Danish-Peak
Ultimate Vanilla-DS, French Vanilla-AH, Vanilla Voodoo-CC
Candy Corn-JS, CC, BCN 
Eggnog-BCN, Custard-AWE
Silky V Vanilla-JS, Very Vanilla-BCN, Vanilla Extract-BCS, 
Simply Vanilla-DS, Glazed Donut-TC, Angel Food Cake-WSP
Coconut Cream Pie-BCN, JS
Twinkies-JS, Nanny's Country Pound Cake-DS
Aroma Haven Hey Hey Cute Cabana boy and DS Coconut Pear
Magnolia Melba from Tony's, Summer Fling from BB and Mardi Gras from OT 
Bayrum: OT & SW
Candy Corn: TCS, KS, CC, JS
China Rain: TCS, JS
Raisinbread, blahblahblah: WNW, JS, FOH
CC & Daystar: Vanilla Voodoo/Ultimate Vanilla
Twigs & Berries: NG, Steves
WNW creme brulee & NG's butter brickle - very similar. even yellows my soy wax the same way
Kitchen Spice - JS & Daystar
NG's Mrs. Claus Cookies and Day Star's Vanilla Bean Noel
SC Watermelon = Day Star's Watermelon Martini
Butt Naked from At Wix End is a slightly stronger version of Tranquil Tropics of BubblesnLights (BCN)
Clean Cotton = JS, TRI-ST
Green Leaf's Starla, The Scent Work's Mayan Gold
Peaks Amish Harvest and Aroma Haven's Celtic Moon Spice- Very very Similiar
Santa Spruce (Brambleberry) and Sugared Spruce (the candle source)
Strudel from Candle Science and Graham Cracker from Green Leaf smell exactly alike out of the bottle.
Wilberry Mousse from Candle Science and Berry Creme Brulee from Milcreek
NG"s Watercress and Aloe and Peak's Green Clover in Aloe
AGE's Salty Mariner and Peaks Ocean
NG's Passionate Kisses and TCS Caribbean Holiday
Peak's Casaba Mist & AH's Badedas
JS Grammas Berry Griddlecakes is the same as CS wildberry mousse & These are also the same as ICS Wildberry Mousse
Sweetcakes Fig / BNL Fig Melon
Green Leafs -Indonesean Teak is the same as Flickers - Tuscan Lace
DS Tropical Fruit Slices = ICS Summer Medley
KY Apple Clove Butter=Flicker's Cider Snap
CS Spiced Wassail=Flicker's Autumn Spice
KY's Homemade Apple Pie ST (now ICS) Baked Apples
AH Fudge Brownie = JS Fabulous Fudge
CS Wildberry Mousse and BCN and TCS Country Berry Hotcakes
Brambleberry's Welcome Home and Tennessee Candle's This Old House
Peaks Spruce Xmas Tree and AH's Ozark Forest
GL Himalayan Blue Willow Taylored Concepts Bamboo
TCS Pomegranate GL Pomegranate
CS Very Vanilla is the same as DS Ultimate Vanilla (and CC Vanilla Voodoo
GL/TC Pumpkin Pie Spice
GL/TC Pumpkin Frappuchino
TCS/TC Peach Raspberry Magnolia
TC/AH Coco Mango
Candle Cocoon's Vanilla Voodoo ~ Millcreeks Extreme Vanilla
Candlemaker's Store (Steve's) - Harvest -Tennessee Candle - Amish Harvest

Candlemaker's Store (Steve's) - Silver Bells - Tennessee Candle - This Old House

Update: I needed This Old House and Tennessee Candles was out of stock so I ordered Candlemakers Store Silver Bells grade A and to my nose they are nothing alike - sorry. I smell pine in it I think but it is not This Old House

Monkey Farts...NG and Wixnwax

Alabaster Caribbean Fruit and Kumquat are the same..or at least used to be
Muscadine--NG, WNW, Keystone, and Alabaster
Blueberry Cobbler--NG, Keystone, and ICS blueberry cheesecake
Amaretto Nog--WNW, Keystone, JS
Mulberry-NG, WNW, ICS
Kudzu--Alabaster, WNW, ICS
Peaks Fresh Linen and BCN Angel Wings
NG Tayberry & Teakwood - BCN Twigs n Berries
Sweet Tooth (AH) = Sweet Treat (JS) Aroma Haven's Sweet Seduction
JS Winter Spice
BCN's Mulled Cider....
Just Scent winterberry wreath and Candlescience med fig - Millcreeks Mediterranean Fig
CS Hazelnut and GL Hazelnut
JS Caramelized Pralines and DS White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookies
To me CC tigerlily and cantalope smell like CW white tea.
Blackberry Sage from TN, TW, & KY same
MC pears n Berries LS pearberry
Jinglebells from TN smells like any mulberry
BCN-Pomegranate and Just Scents-Cupid
Twigs & Berries by the following are all interchangable for each other - AWE, BC & NG
Bert's Aspen Forest & Flickers Balsam & Citrus
AH and Js passionate kisses
KY's Fresh Glazed Donuts smells like Warm Vanilla Sugar 
Spiced Crans at BCN & ICS
KY Grandmother's Toddy and CS Hansel and Gretels House
BCN's Dreamweaver and NG's Satin Sheets
BCS Pumpkin Cheesecake and JS Pumpkin Fudge Torte
Mimosa and Mandarin CS and BC's Citrus Splash
Millcreek Soy Candle Cozy Home smells similar to me like CS's Cranberry Marmalade
Millcreek's Cinnamon Vanilla and CS Strudel and Spice are very very alike
Lonestar Sun 'N Sea and Sea Petals are identical
BCS Sissy Sugar Cookies and Southern Scentsations Snickerdoodle 
BW Sandalwood Cardamom is the same as Peakes Sage & Citrus
BW Gingerbread Latte is the same as JBN Pumpkin Frapp
Bert's Lemon Biscotti Pie is the same as NG Lemon Pound Cake
BW Black Irish is the same as Flickers Green Irish Tweed
"beach daisies" from Nature's Garden smells exactly like "Sun & Sand"-Yankme dupe from Wholesale Supplies 
AH/RE-French Vanilla Oak=Southern Garden Scents-Baton Rogue
Cierra's -grandmas kitchen, At wix end-grandmas kitchen, Makes scents-apple cinnamon~ all have a very similar cider scent. 
Elements Patchouli Honey and Moonwork's Native Princess
Sugared Spruce from Candle Soylutions is the same as Aztec's, WSP and BB Santa's Spruce
DayStar's Paridise = Oregon Trails Fruit Loops
Tennessee's Spiced Apples & Peaches = Sweet Cakes Cinnamon Apple Peach
Bert's Aspen Forest = Moonworks Winter Festival
Candlewic's Spa = WSP's Aqua Spa (WSP's is stronger, but same scent)
NG's Mermaid Kisses and ICS Cactus and Sea Salt.
JS Vanilla Bean Noel and NG Vanilla Valentine 
Candlewic's sugared vanilla shortbread and Moonworks (Venus Candles) sugar cookie royale
Candle Science - Sage and Pomegranate is the same as Millcreek Northern Red Currant
JS Aspen Winter and The Candle Source Sleigh Ride
Peaks Clean Cotton and The Candle Source Clean Cotton
BCN Spiced Cranberry and Tenn Spiced Cranberry
JS Vanilla Bean Noel (type) and Tenn Vanilla Bean Noel (type)
KY Zucchini Bread and The Candle Source Grammy's Zucchini Bread
CS Black Rasp Vanilla and Peaks Black Rasp Vanilla
JS Cinnamon Buns w/vanilla & The Candle Source Cinn Buns w/vanilla are very similar
BCS Harvest and JS Harvest smell the same OOB but IMO the BCS throws a bit better
Peaks Amish Harvest & Tenn Amish Harvest are very similar 

AHRE's Butternut Pumpkin smells very, very similar to JS's Frosted Pumpkin and MC's Frosted Carrot Cake

Elements had a scent called Olive Blossom and I swear it smells like MoonWorks Floral Muse FO

I have never smelled MoonWorks Floral Muse, but Elements Olive Blossom smells the same to me as CS Rain Water

 

I have never smelled MoonWorks Floral Muse, but Elements Olive Blossom smells the same to me as CS Rain Water

Bert's Aspen Forest and Fillmore Citrus Spruce smell identical to me - or close enough to make me happy

Moonworks Pinion pine smells exact to me as CS mistletoe

AH/RE Sugar Corn Pudding smells the same as BCN Amish Friendship Bread

Aztec's Sweet Winterberry & Rustic Escentuals Frosted Winterberry

Also Peaks country berry hotcakes and ICS Wildberry Mousse. Also, Peaks country berry hotcakes smells just like JS cbh

The Scent Works..Sweet Lodge Smoke..and DayStar's..Hunters Moon smell very very much alike

MW gypsy rose and Elements sensuous black rose are very much alike but I can get MW to throw stronger in a candle

Peaks & Candlewic Black Raspberry Vanilla

Peaks Blueberry Cobbler and Candlewic Blueberry Pie

Community Candle Dickens Christmas and The Candlesource Christmas Splendor

NG Strawberry Passion & BCN Strawberry Jam

Candlescience & The Candlesource Mulberry 

according to my notes but I can not remember for sure: Community Candle Mulled Cider & Tennessee Apple Cider

Peaks & AH/RE Orange Chiffon Cake

ICS & AH/RE Salty Sea Air

BRV-Peaks & Candlewic

Wild Mountain Honey-Peak, Flaming Candle Company & Elements-Honey  L'Occitane Type

Peaks (Winter Orange Spice) & Lonestar (Autumn Harvest)- same

FB's Fizzy Pop Soda and DS Paradise smell very similar to my nose.

[Jesusismygrace]

JS Coconut Milk and Lavender and RE Shangri-la

[Beaches]

Adding another match:

Tri-State Clean Cotton and MC High Cotton

JS Mimosa Mandarin and MC Magenta Nectar
KY--roasted coffee and ICS coffee bean
KY--Wildberry Scone and ICS Wildberry----(forgot what they call theirs)
KY--Southern Vanilla and SS Country Vanilla (super close, maybe identical)
Missy's(JS)-- Christmas Cookie and KH (Keystone) Christmas Cookie
JS's-- Victorian Vanilla Lace and SS sweet snow
JS-- pomegranate and BCN Pomegranate--pretty close
KY--Creme brulee and JBN Creme brulee
Keystone(KH)--Pumpkin Fudge and SS Vanilla Pumpkin
Nature's Garden's Twigs and Berries and Tayberry and Teak Wood.
Day Star's OohLaLa and WSP's Beneath the Stars
WYW Perfect Pumpkin and WSP's Perfect Pumpkin
C&S Jade (Pier one type) and MC Dreamcatcher
Just Scent's Sea Mist smells just like Oceans (Pier 1)...
Daystar's Decadent Orange Fluff Cake smells just like NG's Hot orange danish
TW Emerald Sea and OM Calypso
Peak Jamaican Me Crazy and JS Paradise Island
Heartfelt's Enchanted, and ICS Japanese Plum!
Orange Chiffon Cake-JS, Hot Orange Danish-NG
Banana Split-DS, Monkey Farts-AH
Serendipity-JS, Cupid-BCN/BNL
Framboise Citron Cheesecake-AH, Iced Lemon Danish-Peak
Ultimate Vanilla-DS, French Vanilla-AH, Vanilla Voodoo-CC
Candy Corn-JS, CC, BCN 
Eggnog-BCN, Custard-AWE
Silky V Vanilla-JS, Very Vanilla-BCN, Vanilla Extract-BCS, 
Simply Vanilla-DS, Glazed Donut-TC, Angel Food Cake-WSP
Coconut Cream Pie-BCN, JS
Twinkies-JS, Nanny's Country Pound Cake-DS
Aroma Haven Hey Hey Cute Cabana boy and DS Coconut Pear
Magnolia Melba from Tony's, Summer Fling from BB and Mardi Gras from OT 
Bayrum: OT & SW
Candy Corn: TCS, KS, CC, JS
China Rain: TCS, JS
Raisinbread, blahblahblah: WNW, JS, FOH
CC & Daystar: Vanilla Voodoo/Ultimate Vanilla
Twigs & Berries: NG, Steves
WNW creme brulee & NG's butter brickle - very similar. even yellows my soy wax the same way
Kitchen Spice - JS & Daystar
NG's Mrs. Claus Cookies and Day Star's Vanilla Bean Noel
SC Watermelon = Day Star's Watermelon Martini
Butt Naked from At Wix End is a slightly stronger version of Tranquil Tropics of BubblesnLights (BCN)
Clean Cotton = JS, TRI-ST
Green Leaf's Starla, The Scent Work's Mayan Gold
Peaks Amish Harvest and Aroma Haven's Celtic Moon Spice- Very very Similiar
Santa Spruce (Brambleberry) and Sugared Spruce (the candle source)
Strudel from Candle Science and Graham Cracker from Green Leaf smell exactly alike out of the bottle.
Wilberry Mousse from Candle Science and Berry Creme Brulee from Milcreek
NG"s Watercress and Aloe and Peak's Green Clover in Aloe
AGE's Salty Mariner and Peaks Ocean
NG's Passionate Kisses and TCS Caribbean Holiday
Peak's Casaba Mist & AH's Badedas
JS Grammas Berry Griddlecakes is the same as CS wildberry mousse & These are also the same as ICS Wildberry Mousse
Sweetcakes Fig / BNL Fig Melon
Green Leafs -Indonesean Teak is the same as Flickers - Tuscan Lace
DS Tropical Fruit Slices = ICS Summer Medley
KY Apple Clove Butter=Flicker's Cider Snap
CS Spiced Wassail=Flicker's Autumn Spice
KY's Homemade Apple Pie ST (now ICS) Baked Apples
AH Fudge Brownie = JS Fabulous Fudge
CS Wildberry Mousse and BCN and TCS Country Berry Hotcakes
Brambleberry's Welcome Home and Tennessee Candle's This Old House
Peaks Spruce Xmas Tree and AH's Ozark Forest
GL Himalayan Blue Willow Taylored Concepts Bamboo
TCS Pomegranate GL Pomegranate
CS Very Vanilla is the same as DS Ultimate Vanilla (and CC Vanilla Voodoo
GL/TC Pumpkin Pie Spice
GL/TC Pumpkin Frappuchino
TCS/TC Peach Raspberry Magnolia
TC/AH Coco Mango
Candle Cocoon's Vanilla Voodoo ~ Millcreeks Extreme Vanilla
Candlemaker's Store (Steve's) - Harvest -Tennessee Candle - Amish Harvest

Candlemaker's Store (Steve's) - Silver Bells - Tennessee Candle - This Old House

Update: I needed This Old House and Tennessee Candles was out of stock so I ordered Candlemakers Store Silver Bells grade A and to my nose they are nothing alike - sorry. I smell pine in it I think but it is not This Old House

Monkey Farts...NG and Wixnwax

Alabaster Caribbean Fruit and Kumquat are the same..or at least used to be
Muscadine--NG, WNW, Keystone, and Alabaster
Blueberry Cobbler--NG, Keystone, and ICS blueberry cheesecake
Amaretto Nog--WNW, Keystone, JS
Mulberry-NG, WNW, ICS
Kudzu--Alabaster, WNW, ICS
Peaks Fresh Linen and BCN Angel Wings
NG Tayberry & Teakwood - BCN Twigs n Berries
Sweet Tooth (AH) = Sweet Treat (JS) Aroma Haven's Sweet Seduction
JS Winter Spice
BCN's Mulled Cider....
Just Scent winterberry wreath and Candlescience med fig - Millcreeks Mediterranean Fig
CS Hazelnut and GL Hazelnut
JS Caramelized Pralines and DS White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookies
To me CC tigerlily and cantalope smell like CW white tea.
Blackberry Sage from TN, TW, & KY same
MC pears n Berries LS pearberry
Jinglebells from TN smells like any mulberry
BCN-Pomegranate and Just Scents-Cupid
Twigs & Berries by the following are all interchangable for each other - AWE, BC & NG
Bert's Aspen Forest & Flickers Balsam & Citrus
AH and Js passionate kisses
KY's Fresh Glazed Donuts smells like Warm Vanilla Sugar 
Spiced Crans at BCN & ICS
KY Grandmother's Toddy and CS Hansel and Gretels House
BCN's Dreamweaver and NG's Satin Sheets
BCS Pumpkin Cheesecake and JS Pumpkin Fudge Torte
Mimosa and Mandarin CS and BC's Citrus Splash
Millcreek Soy Candle Cozy Home smells similar to me like CS's Cranberry Marmalade
Millcreek's Cinnamon Vanilla and CS Strudel and Spice are very very alike
Lonestar Sun 'N Sea and Sea Petals are identical
BCS Sissy Sugar Cookies and Southern Scentsations Snickerdoodle 
BW Sandalwood Cardamom is the same as Peakes Sage & Citrus
BW Gingerbread Latte is the same as JBN Pumpkin Frapp
Bert's Lemon Biscotti Pie is the same as NG Lemon Pound Cake
BW Black Irish is the same as Flickers Green Irish Tweed
"beach daisies" from Nature's Garden smells exactly like "Sun & Sand"-Yankme dupe from Wholesale Supplies 
AH/RE-French Vanilla Oak=Southern Garden Scents-Baton Rogue
Cierra's -grandmas kitchen, At wix end-grandmas kitchen, Makes scents-apple cinnamon~ all have a very similar cider scent. 
Elements Patchouli Honey and Moonwork's Native Princess
Sugared Spruce from Candle Soylutions is the same as Aztec's, WSP and BB Santa's Spruce
DayStar's Paridise = Oregon Trails Fruit Loops
Tennessee's Spiced Apples & Peaches = Sweet Cakes Cinnamon Apple Peach
Bert's Aspen Forest = Moonworks Winter Festival
Candlewic's Spa = WSP's Aqua Spa (WSP's is stronger, but same scent)
NG's Mermaid Kisses and ICS Cactus and Sea Salt.
JS Vanilla Bean Noel and NG Vanilla Valentine 
Candlewic's sugared vanilla shortbread and Moonworks (Venus Candles) sugar cookie royale
Candle Science - Sage and Pomegranate is the same as Millcreek Northern Red Currant
JS Aspen Winter and The Candle Source Sleigh Ride
Peaks Clean Cotton and The Candle Source Clean Cotton
BCN Spiced Cranberry and Tenn Spiced Cranberry
JS Vanilla Bean Noel (type) and Tenn Vanilla Bean Noel (type)
KY Zucchini Bread and The Candle Source Grammy's Zucchini Bread
CS Black Rasp Vanilla and Peaks Black Rasp Vanilla
JS Cinnamon Buns w/vanilla & The Candle Source Cinn Buns w/vanilla are very similar
BCS Harvest and JS Harvest smell the same OOB but IMO the BCS throws a bit better
Peaks Amish Harvest & Tenn Amish Harvest are very similar 

AHRE's Butternut Pumpkin smells very, very similar to JS's Frosted Pumpkin and MC's Frosted Carrot Cake

Elements had a scent called Olive Blossom and I swear it smells like MoonWorks Floral Muse FO

I have never smelled MoonWorks Floral Muse, but Elements Olive Blossom smells the same to me as CS Rain Water

 

I have never smelled MoonWorks Floral Muse, but Elements Olive Blossom smells the same to me as CS Rain Water

Bert's Aspen Forest and Fillmore Citrus Spruce smell identical to me - or close enough to make me happy

Moonworks Pinion pine smells exact to me as CS mistletoe

AH/RE Sugar Corn Pudding smells the same as BCN Amish Friendship Bread

Aztec's Sweet Winterberry & Rustic Escentuals Frosted Winterberry

Also Peaks country berry hotcakes and ICS Wildberry Mousse. Also, Peaks country berry hotcakes smells just like JS cbh

The Scent Works..Sweet Lodge Smoke..and DayStar's..Hunters Moon smell very very much alike

MW gypsy rose and Elements sensuous black rose are very much alike but I can get MW to throw stronger in a candle

Peaks & Candlewic Black Raspberry Vanilla

Peaks Blueberry Cobbler and Candlewic Blueberry Pie

Community Candle Dickens Christmas and The Candlesource Christmas Splendor

NG Strawberry Passion & BCN Strawberry Jam

Candlescience & The Candlesource Mulberry 

according to my notes but I can not remember for sure: Community Candle Mulled Cider & Tennessee Apple Cider

Peaks & AH/RE Orange Chiffon Cake

ICS & AH/RE Salty Sea Air

BRV-Peaks & Candlewic

Wild Mountain Honey-Peak, Flaming Candle Company & Elements-Honey  L'Occitane Type

Peaks (Winter Orange Spice) & Lonestar (Autumn Harvest)- same

FB's Fizzy Pop Soda and DS Paradise smell very similar to my nose.

Lone Star's Mango Beachwood Type smells the same to me as Bulk Apocothary's Mango Beachwood

 Like this

[Beaches]

I love Lone Star's Lemongrass Sage scent, but it has phathalates in it so I have been on the hunt for one that smells similar to it.  Rustic just had their sample sale, and one of the samples I got is it!  The name is completely different.  Violet Leaf and Sweet Grass.   I also tried Lumberjack.  It smells like Tennessee Candles This Old House to me.

 

Tri-State Clean Cotton and MC High Cotton

JS Mimosa Mandarin and MC Magenta Nectar
KY--roasted coffee and ICS coffee bean
KY--Wildberry Scone and ICS Wildberry----(forgot what they call theirs)
KY--Southern Vanilla and SS Country Vanilla (super close, maybe identical)
Missy's(JS)-- Christmas Cookie and KH (Keystone) Christmas Cookie
JS's-- Victorian Vanilla Lace and SS sweet snow
JS-- pomegranate and BCN Pomegranate--pretty close
KY--Creme brulee and JBN Creme brulee
Keystone(KH)--Pumpkin Fudge and SS Vanilla Pumpkin
Nature's Garden's Twigs and Berries and Tayberry and Teak Wood.
Day Star's OohLaLa and WSP's Beneath the Stars
WYW Perfect Pumpkin and WSP's Perfect Pumpkin
C&S Jade (Pier one type) and MC Dreamcatcher
Just Scent's Sea Mist smells just like Oceans (Pier 1)...
Daystar's Decadent Orange Fluff Cake smells just like NG's Hot orange danish
TW Emerald Sea and OM Calypso
Peak Jamaican Me Crazy and JS Paradise Island
Heartfelt's Enchanted, and ICS Japanese Plum!
Orange Chiffon Cake-JS, Hot Orange Danish-NG
Banana Split-DS, Monkey Farts-AH
Serendipity-JS, Cupid-BCN/BNL
Framboise Citron Cheesecake-AH, Iced Lemon Danish-Peak
Ultimate Vanilla-DS, French Vanilla-AH, Vanilla Voodoo-CC
Candy Corn-JS, CC, BCN 
Eggnog-BCN, Custard-AWE
Silky V Vanilla-JS, Very Vanilla-BCN, Vanilla Extract-BCS, 
Simply Vanilla-DS, Glazed Donut-TC, Angel Food Cake-WSP
Coconut Cream Pie-BCN, JS
Twinkies-JS, Nanny's Country Pound Cake-DS
Aroma Haven Hey Hey Cute Cabana boy and DS Coconut Pear
Magnolia Melba from Tony's, Summer Fling from BB and Mardi Gras from OT 
Bayrum: OT & SW
Candy Corn: TCS, KS, CC, JS
China Rain: TCS, JS
Raisinbread, blahblahblah: WNW, JS, FOH
CC & Daystar: Vanilla Voodoo/Ultimate Vanilla
Twigs & Berries: NG, Steves
WNW creme brulee & NG's butter brickle - very similar. even yellows my soy wax the same way
Kitchen Spice - JS & Daystar
NG's Mrs. Claus Cookies and Day Star's Vanilla Bean Noel
SC Watermelon = Day Star's Watermelon Martini
Butt Naked from At Wix End is a slightly stronger version of Tranquil Tropics of BubblesnLights (BCN)
Clean Cotton = JS, TRI-ST
Green Leaf's Starla, The Scent Work's Mayan Gold
Peaks Amish Harvest and Aroma Haven's Celtic Moon Spice- Very very Similiar
Santa Spruce (Brambleberry) and Sugared Spruce (the candle source)
Strudel from Candle Science and Graham Cracker from Green Leaf smell exactly alike out of the bottle.
Wilberry Mousse from Candle Science and Berry Creme Brulee from Milcreek
NG"s Watercress and Aloe and Peak's Green Clover in Aloe
AGE's Salty Mariner and Peaks Ocean
NG's Passionate Kisses and TCS Caribbean Holiday
Peak's Casaba Mist & AH's Badedas
JS Grammas Berry Griddlecakes is the same as CS wildberry mousse & These are also the same as ICS Wildberry Mousse
Sweetcakes Fig / BNL Fig Melon
Green Leafs -Indonesean Teak is the same as Flickers - Tuscan Lace
DS Tropical Fruit Slices = ICS Summer Medley
KY Apple Clove Butter=Flicker's Cider Snap
CS Spiced Wassail=Flicker's Autumn Spice
KY's Homemade Apple Pie ST (now ICS) Baked Apples
AH Fudge Brownie = JS Fabulous Fudge
CS Wildberry Mousse and BCN and TCS Country Berry Hotcakes
Brambleberry's Welcome Home and Tennessee Candle's This Old House
Peaks Spruce Xmas Tree and AH's Ozark Forest
GL Himalayan Blue Willow Taylored Concepts Bamboo
TCS Pomegranate GL Pomegranate
CS Very Vanilla is the same as DS Ultimate Vanilla (and CC Vanilla Voodoo
GL/TC Pumpkin Pie Spice
GL/TC Pumpkin Frappuchino
TCS/TC Peach Raspberry Magnolia
TC/AH Coco Mango
Candle Cocoon's Vanilla Voodoo ~ Millcreeks Extreme Vanilla
Candlemaker's Store (Steve's) - Harvest -Tennessee Candle - Amish Harvest

Candlemaker's Store (Steve's) - Silver Bells - Tennessee Candle - This Old House

Update: I needed This Old House and Tennessee Candles was out of stock so I ordered Candlemakers Store Silver Bells grade A and to my nose they are nothing alike - sorry. I smell pine in it I think but it is not This Old House

Monkey Farts...NG and Wixnwax

Alabaster Caribbean Fruit and Kumquat are the same..or at least used to be
Muscadine--NG, WNW, Keystone, and Alabaster
Blueberry Cobbler--NG, Keystone, and ICS blueberry cheesecake
Amaretto Nog--WNW, Keystone, JS
Mulberry-NG, WNW, ICS
Kudzu--Alabaster, WNW, ICS
Peaks Fresh Linen and BCN Angel Wings
NG Tayberry & Teakwood - BCN Twigs n Berries
Sweet Tooth (AH) = Sweet Treat (JS) Aroma Haven's Sweet Seduction
JS Winter Spice
BCN's Mulled Cider....
Just Scent winterberry wreath and Candlescience med fig - Millcreeks Mediterranean Fig
CS Hazelnut and GL Hazelnut
JS Caramelized Pralines and DS White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookies
To me CC tigerlily and cantalope smell like CW white tea.
Blackberry Sage from TN, TW, & KY same
MC pears n Berries LS pearberry
Jinglebells from TN smells like any mulberry
BCN-Pomegranate and Just Scents-Cupid
Twigs & Berries by the following are all interchangable for each other - AWE, BC & NG
Bert's Aspen Forest & Flickers Balsam & Citrus
AH and Js passionate kisses
KY's Fresh Glazed Donuts smells like Warm Vanilla Sugar 
Spiced Crans at BCN & ICS
KY Grandmother's Toddy and CS Hansel and Gretels House
BCN's Dreamweaver and NG's Satin Sheets
BCS Pumpkin Cheesecake and JS Pumpkin Fudge Torte
Mimosa and Mandarin CS and BC's Citrus Splash
Millcreek Soy Candle Cozy Home smells similar to me like CS's Cranberry Marmalade
Millcreek's Cinnamon Vanilla and CS Strudel and Spice are very very alike
Lonestar Sun 'N Sea and Sea Petals are identical
BCS Sissy Sugar Cookies and Southern Scentsations Snickerdoodle 
BW Sandalwood Cardamom is the same as Peakes Sage & Citrus
BW Gingerbread Latte is the same as JBN Pumpkin Frapp
Bert's Lemon Biscotti Pie is the same as NG Lemon Pound Cake
BW Black Irish is the same as Flickers Green Irish Tweed
"beach daisies" from Nature's Garden smells exactly like "Sun & Sand"-Yankme dupe from Wholesale Supplies 
AH/RE-French Vanilla Oak=Southern Garden Scents-Baton Rogue
Cierra's -grandmas kitchen, At wix end-grandmas kitchen, Makes scents-apple cinnamon~ all have a very similar cider scent. 
Elements Patchouli Honey and Moonwork's Native Princess
Sugared Spruce from Candle Soylutions is the same as Aztec's, WSP and BB Santa's Spruce
DayStar's Paridise = Oregon Trails Fruit Loops
Tennessee's Spiced Apples & Peaches = Sweet Cakes Cinnamon Apple Peach
Bert's Aspen Forest = Moonworks Winter Festival
Candlewic's Spa = WSP's Aqua Spa (WSP's is stronger, but same scent)
NG's Mermaid Kisses and ICS Cactus and Sea Salt.
JS Vanilla Bean Noel and NG Vanilla Valentine 
Candlewic's sugared vanilla shortbread and Moonworks (Venus Candles) sugar cookie royale
Candle Science - Sage and Pomegranate is the same as Millcreek Northern Red Currant
JS Aspen Winter and The Candle Source Sleigh Ride
Peaks Clean Cotton and The Candle Source Clean Cotton
BCN Spiced Cranberry and Tenn Spiced Cranberry
JS Vanilla Bean Noel (type) and Tenn Vanilla Bean Noel (type)
KY Zucchini Bread and The Candle Source Grammy's Zucchini Bread
CS Black Rasp Vanilla and Peaks Black Rasp Vanilla
JS Cinnamon Buns w/vanilla & The Candle Source Cinn Buns w/vanilla are very similar
BCS Harvest and JS Harvest smell the same OOB but IMO the BCS throws a bit better
Peaks Amish Harvest & Tenn Amish Harvest are very similar 

AHRE's Butternut Pumpkin smells very, very similar to JS's Frosted Pumpkin and MC's Frosted Carrot Cake

Elements had a scent called Olive Blossom and I swear it smells like MoonWorks Floral Muse FO

I have never smelled MoonWorks Floral Muse, but Elements Olive Blossom smells the same to me as CS Rain Water

 

I have never smelled MoonWorks Floral Muse, but Elements Olive Blossom smells the same to me as CS Rain Water

Bert's Aspen Forest and Fillmore Citrus Spruce smell identical to me - or close enough to make me happy

Moonworks Pinion pine smells exact to me as CS mistletoe

AH/RE Sugar Corn Pudding smells the same as BCN Amish Friendship Bread

Aztec's Sweet Winterberry & Rustic Escentuals Frosted Winterberry

Also Peaks country berry hotcakes and ICS Wildberry Mousse. Also, Peaks country berry hotcakes smells just like JS cbh

The Scent Works..Sweet Lodge Smoke..and DayStar's..Hunters Moon smell very very much alike

MW gypsy rose and Elements sensuous black rose are very much alike but I can get MW to throw stronger in a candle

Peaks & Candlewic Black Raspberry Vanilla

Peaks Blueberry Cobbler and Candlewic Blueberry Pie

Community Candle Dickens Christmas and The Candlesource Christmas Splendor

NG Strawberry Passion & BCN Strawberry Jam

Candlescience & The Candlesource Mulberry 

according to my notes but I can not remember for sure: Community Candle Mulled Cider & Tennessee Apple Cider

Peaks & AH/RE Orange Chiffon Cake

ICS & AH/RE Salty Sea Air

BRV-Peaks & Candlewic

Wild Mountain Honey-Peak, Flaming Candle Company & Elements-Honey  L'Occitane Type

Peaks (Winter Orange Spice) & Lonestar (Autumn Harvest)- same

FB's Fizzy Pop Soda and DS Paradise smell very similar to my nose.

Lone Star's Mango Beachwood Type smells the same to me as Bulk Apocothary's Mango Beachwood

Lone Star's Lemongrass Sage and Rustic Escentuals Violet Leaf and Sweet Grass

Tennessee Candle's This Old House and Rustic Escentual's Lumberjack.  Not exact, but so close

[Karla]

On ‎6‎/‎21‎/‎2006 at 8:10 AM, Candlewitch said:

Cant think of any right now but it should be made into a list and used as a sticky post or whatever to save all of us the time and money on testing. I have tried 4 diff lilacs and all were different.

I love Candle Science Lilac. It lasted 3 days in my bathroom wall plug warmer. A good lilac smell too.. authentic.

[Belinda]

Also, KY's warm vanilla nutmeg and Fillmore's Warm Vanilla Caramel smell the same to me.

[onehorsegirl]

Hi...I am not sure if this is where I would ask bit I am looking for the fragrance oil that Gold Canyon calls Days of Christmas.  Does anyone one know of it in another name?  I have looked for years!  Frustrating.  I cannot find their "Relaxing" and "Citrus & Spruce" either.  I bet I have 10 different Spruce scents and none of them are it...ugh.  Thank you for any help 

[Belinda]

18 minutes ago, onehorsegirl said:

Hi...I am not sure if this is where I would ask bit I am looking for the fragrance oil that Gold Canyon calls Days of Christmas.  Does anyone one know of it in another name?  I have looked for years!  Frustrating.  I cannot find their "Relaxing" and "Citrus & Spruce" either.  I bet I have 10 different Spruce scents and none of them are it...ugh.  Thank you for any help 

I've never smelled that one so I'm no help to you there. Maybe you could post this in a new thread in the fragrance section and get more responses.

[onehorsegirl]

LOL...New at this and thought I did.  I will look and see how to place my question in the right place...thanks for your help

[lovelyscents]

This definitely helps people like me who would like to stick with a handful of suppliers due to shipping and/or with finding dupes.  Not to say I won't still test majority of these for myself since it is subjective and I am just me .

[quelz]

Has anyone found a Birthday Cake exactly like Peak's? Scent description is: Indulge in the aroma of freshly baked cake straight from the oven. Blended with rich vanilla, pure cane sugar and topped with a smooth and creamy white frosting.

[Moonstar]

2 hours ago, quelz said:

Has anyone found a Birthday Cake exactly like Peak's? Scent description is: Indulge in the aroma of freshly baked cake straight from the oven. Blended with rich vanilla, pure cane sugar and topped with a smooth and creamy white frosting.

Try the birthday cake from RE I use the KY version. Its quite strong 

[quelz]

22 hours ago, Moonstar said:

Try the birthday cake from RE I use the KY version. Its quite strong 

I've tried both from RE. It's good but doesn't smell like Peak's. Thanks anyway! 

[morethanrubies]

RE Apples & Oats & RE Rustic Lodge

[Trappeur]

1 hour ago, morethanrubies said:

RE Apples & Oats & RE Rustic Lodge

Are you saying both of these RE scents are duplicates of one another?

 

Trappeur

[morethanrubies]

Yes, to me, they smell exactly the same - even though the descriptions are very different.  I was disappointed because I liked the description of Rustic Lodge but - to me - OOB and in wax it smelled just like Apples & Oats with maybe a titch of something different but not enough to carry both.

Edited October 22, 2017 by morethanrubies

[lovelyscents]

On 7/28/2017 at 2:29 PM, quelz said:

Has anyone found a Birthday Cake exactly like Peak's? Scent description is: Indulge in the aroma of freshly baked cake straight from the oven. Blended with rich vanilla, pure cane sugar and topped with a smooth and creamy white frosting.

Not sure exactly what Peak smells like, had a list of oils I wanted to try, but then they closed awhile and now I have no intent to using them.  Have you tried Fragrance Buddy?  Some say it is similar.

[Sarah S]

WSP's Indonesian Teakwood smells exactly like Candlewic's Mahogany Spice

[Beaches]

Wholesale Supplies Plus Festival of Lights is the same as Rustic Escentuals Country Gift Store.

[Belinda]

AAA sugar cookie smells the same as Aztec's Grandma's Kitchen to my nose.