Looking for a marshmallow fluff fragrance oil to use in roll on perfume

[Jcake90]

Looking for a long lasting, gooey sweet vanilla, that smells like melting marshmallows and vanilla to make rice crispy treats minus the butter and cereal. I haven't had the best of luck. I tried a few of rustics marshmallows with no luck. Thought that the toasted marshmallow entailed a more gooey scent but not the case.

[Lizzy]

I use Maple Street's Marshmallow Fluff and love it. It's great on it's own or as a blender.

https://maplestreetcandle.com/Marshmallow-Fluff_p_1859.html

[Jcake90]

On 6/11/2022 at 4:33 AM, Lizzy said:

I use Maple Street's Marshmallow Fluff and love it. It's great on it's own or as a blender.

https://maplestreetcandle.com/Marshmallow-Fluff_p_1859.html

Can you tell me what it smells like? I have had a heck of a time finding an actual true marshmallow.

[Lizzy]

5 hours ago, Jcake90 said:

Can you tell me what it smells like? I have had a heck of a time finding an actual true marshmallow.

like sticking your nose into a bag of marshmallows....lol....if that helps. Sweet, creamy and vanilla-ly 

[Jcake90]

On 8/24/2022 at 3:41 AM, Lizzy said:

like sticking your nose into a bag of marshmallows....lol....if that helps. Sweet, creamy and vanilla-ly 

That helps! I'm hoping it will hold up well in a roll on! thanks so much for your rec, do you recommend any of that companies other gourmandy oils?

[Belinda]

8 minutes ago, Jcake90 said:

That helps! I'm hoping it will hold up well in a roll on! thanks so much for your rec, do you recommend any of that companies other gourmandy oils?

I haven't tried the one from MS but the marshmallow fluff from FB is really good. Lone Star's marshmallow is the most unique one I've ever smelled though. I'm not saying it's the best but it's different. But I would choose the one from FB. I"ll have to sniff the one from LS again and compare it to a bag of marshmallows.

[Jcake90]

3 minutes ago, Belinda said:

I haven't tried the one from MS but the marshmallow fluff from FB is really good. Lone Star's marshmallow is the most unique one I've ever smelled though. I'm not saying it's the best but it's different. But I would choose the one from FB. I"ll have to sniff the one from LS again and compare it to a bag of marshmallows.

Does the one from fragrance buddy have that ooey gooey melted marshmallow rich vanilla scent?

[Belinda]

19 hours ago, Jcake90 said:

Does the one from fragrance buddy have that ooey gooey melted marshmallow rich vanilla scent?

It does to me. I love it. I've not smelled their toasted marshmallow though. I'll see if I have a sample to sniff. 

[Jcake90]

51 minutes ago, Belinda said:

It does to me. I love it. I've not smelled their toasted marshmallow though. I'll see if I have a sample to sniff. 

Out of bottle is there any chemical smell or you know that base smell some oils have, not all though.

[Lizzy]

On 8/26/2022 at 10:56 PM, Jcake90 said:

That helps! I'm hoping it will hold up well in a roll on! thanks so much for your rec, do you recommend any of that companies other gourmandy oils?

right off the top of my head....Cinnamon Bread Pudding, Iced Lemon Danish, Maple Walnut Fudge, Pumpkin Milkshake, Old Town Bake Shop, Cuppy Cake and I love their straight Pumpkin as it's not overloaded with spice. There's some spice but not "in your face" like most Pumpkin scents tend to have. HTH
I am still somewhat new to MS myself but haven't been disappointed....by their oils.

[Belinda]

On 8/27/2022 at 6:12 PM, Jcake90 said:

Out of bottle is there any chemical smell or you know that base smell some oils have, not all though.

I don't detect a chemical smell at all.

[Jcake90]

1 hour ago, Belinda said:

I don't detect a chemical smell at all.

Yay I'll have to give it a try then!

[Moonstar]

On 8/28/2022 at 9:01 PM, Belinda said:

I don't detect a chemical smell at all.

Hi Belinda 😊 have you tried Indiana candle supply Marshmallow fluff ? 

[Moonstar]

On 8/28/2022 at 9:01 PM, Belinda said:

I don't detect a chemical smell at all.

Hi Belinda 😊 have you tried Indiana candle supply Marshmallow fluff ? 

[BenderSF]

On 10/31/2024 at 8:46 PM, Moonstar said:

Hi Belinda 😊 have you tried Indiana candle supply Marshmallow fluff ? 

 

I'm not @Belinda  , but I've tried it.  I only made one small test candle.  My notes say it's very nice but I thought it smelled like another Vanilla Bean Noel.  VBN is always nice, but it's not quite marshmallow.

 

(I do love their oils in general, though.)

[birdcharm]

On 10/31/2024 at 8:46 PM, Moonstar said:

Hi Belinda 😊 have you tried Indiana candle supply Marshmallow fluff ? 

 

Also not Belinda, but I ordered a sample of it ... didn't come across to me as marshmallowy, it seemed more like a light caramel.  I ended up blending it with their frosted graham cracker and some vanilla, now I have a nice vanilla-caramel, lol.  

[Belinda]

On 10/31/2024 at 8:46 PM, Moonstar said:

Hi Belinda 😊 have you tried Indiana candle supply Marshmallow fluff ? 

Sorry, just now seeing this. I do have a small bottle of that one but I've never put it in wax. It smells ok OOB but my favorite one is the one from FB. The only thing is the one from FB smells a whole lot like VBN, which isn't a bad thing since that's one of my favorite scents too but they're really close the more I smell it. The one from Lone Star is really unique to me and also I found one from Southern Scentsations is really good and marshmallowy. I don't order from them much because their shipping is so high to me but I found some of their marshmallow and it's really good as well as their caramel corn is one of the best I've smelled too.