Forgive me for not replying, I just came up for air from the holiday rush! Well, I made up a sample using NG's Tobacco and another using NG's Tobacco Caramel and it didn't pass the test with the handful of people that are requesting the scent. (One is our local Co-op, who would love to carry tarts and candles in the scent...and they know their tobacco barn smell! lol) I'm in the South, so it's huge here. I just can't nail the exact scent, which is sweet and smoky all at the same time. In my research, I did find this "The resultant tobacco possesses a powerful smoky note reminiscent of smoked meats and provides a rich “smoky & sweet note” in tobacco products." I had someone suggest that if I could find a barbecue scent, firewood scent, or beef jerky scent that I should try that. I'll let everyone know what I come up with and thank you so much for all of your input!