I had not purchased from them in awhile, because for me it seems it is hit and miss too. But I wanted to try a few and wanted to take advantage of sale. All OOB the - Leather, is a it says smells like a new leather chair, and not a leather saddle if that is what you are looking for. Did not really realize there would be a difference. Not a big leather fan, but I have requests. Japanese CHerry Blossom smells really weak to me, I HOPE:tiptoe: it does better in wax. I was told in the BBW store that this is their #1 seller right now! Autumn Leaves I and very disapointed in, reminds me of Plumeria that I had, not earthy at all. To me I don't know where they get the name Autumn Leaves, I don't smell anything of fall! I have a sample here from the old Kings Supply and it smells nothing like that. Once it hits wax hoping it will change! But I doubt it!