I use BCN's (BNL)Cucumber Melon in cp soap and it soaps beautifully! No acceleration even with a water discount, and no discoloration. I use a lot of their fragrances: (BNL)Apple Jack & Peel Type, Cedar & Saffron, (BNL) Eucalyptus Spearmint, Love Spell type, MacIntosh Apple, (BNL) Peppercorn, (BNL) Sandalwood Vanilla, Spiced Cranberry, Stonehenge type, Vanilla Bean Supreme, and (Wick Your Wax) Vanilla Grapefruit are some of my favorites!If you do order the cucumber melon, be sure you order the BNL one, as they have 4 different cucumber melons to choose from.