Jordan

I agree, it is weird

These are all good!

These are all great scents, I sold Nostalgia year round. the only one I have not poured yet is Santa's Kitchen. The others are all very good in my 50/50 wax

I like Wildfire or JS, they are identical IMO

Thanks for pulling this old post out of the dust bin. I am sorry others have lost money with the clams they purchased, yet perplexed that others are not experiencing this. I just unearthed an old box of our discontinued Clams and even other bakery and floral scents have now turned skunky. It is not my imagination, it is a big loss of money. Furthermore, when I contacted MC about the issue they said they had never heard another complaint and didn't offer me any options to the issue. All I can say, is I would have liked to have received my money back for the clams at least. This is a sore spot for me.

There are so many that throw well in soy: Brown Sugar Pecan Hot Buttery Cinnamon My Mamma's blueberry cobbler Candied Blueberry Blueberry Cheesecake Chestnuts and Brown sugar Vanilla Buttercream Crunch My secret Recipe Eggnog Totally Scrumptious Creme de la Creme Holiday Crunch Christmas Memories Carribbean Holiday Mojito Cocktail Berrilicious Caramel Cinnamon Latte Snickers Latte Holiday Coffee Mocha Mudslide Lilac Hot Buttered Rum Pumpkin Pie Spice Apple Cinnamon Nana's Apple Butter Cinnamon Cider These are what came to mind, I have tested others that also do very well too, she has great oils.

The Strawberry Rhubarb is excellent. I am switching from WW, it is superior in my opinion.

LOL, it goes away in application and is very good.

She told me it is the old Missy version, but as it was just released I don't have it yet, lol. I'd order a sample and try it out. Personally I like KY's, it is excellent in wax, oob I get bubblegum in the background and it disappears in wax.

I like WYW, TN Candle Supply's Warm Orange Gingerbread, and FOH's. All are different and very good.

cinnamon nutmeg and clove from JS is good

I think it is a nice creamy vanilla bean type scent. Definitely one of the best vanillas I have burned. She has a few great ones that I have had good success with, I don't carry all in my line, but I like these: Victorian Vanilla Lace Vanilla of Pearl Whipped Vanilla Creme Creme Vanille---this one is more buttery to me, like KY southern vanilla Becky's Ultimate Vanilla is great, too. I have to say, I order from several companies including WYW (BCN) Scent Works, KY, Millcreek, DS, Snowtop (ICS), Backwoods, JBN, GL, etc and I find JS oils to be right up there with them. I use her waxes and have had great experiences with her oils. It is hard to beat JS's CS, same day shipping, no backorders, and sales. All this is why I keep coming back, they are good people to do business with. If you place another order, maybe ask for the vanillas as your freebies and she will throw them in for you.

I went through my stash of samples and poured both.....I also prefer Peaks, it was more layered, and stronger in my soy

JS or Peaks, both are excellent.

I haven't tried the super strong strawberry----my search ended with Strawberry Jam, it is perfect. I did have to wick up, too:wink2:

Taylored Concepts Vanilla Sugar Cookie is EXCELLENT!

I like this one too, it is a great mixer as well.

Great reviews, thanks everyone!

I have had great luck with KY 125

what size is your votive? If you are making the 3 oz size, you will need a bigger wick for sure.

Just poured this one in tarts and it is a house filler, WOW! Did well in candles, but even better as a tart, great scent, very realistic. A definite must try for sure.

I really like this one, it is sweet and quite strong in soy, imo

You may need to cut back on the pear scent, although I don't use that one. I use JS perfect pear, and it is wonderful. The JS Cherry cobbler is really good too----maybe try that one. I also use cherry cobbler from King House

I love the new Cupid from JS, it is excellent. Very strong in soy.

Sounds that way, will be interesting to see what others think