Hi Marleigha
My all-time favorite from Candlescience is their Banana Nut Bread. I know it's been around forever but I never get tired of it LOL
Some of my other favorite oldies but goodies...
Hansel & Gretel's House
Carmelized Prailines
Lemon Pound Cake
Mistletoe
Lavender
Strawberry Shortcake
Hazelnut Coffee
Pumpkin Souffle
Sea Salt and Orchid
Very Vanilla
Sandlewood
These all throw really well and smell great!
Some of the newer ones I have been tried...
Fallen Leaves - I didn't care for this one. I pick up a cologne smell but that may just be me
Pumpkin Chai - I really like this one a lot! I haven't got it wicked right yet but it's got a good throw so far despite that
Cypress & Bayberry - This is an amazing scent! If you like Bayberry you will love it!
Black Current Absynthe - I can't decide if I like this one or not LOL. It is definitely different and interesting and STRONG!
Hot Apple Pie - I'm not impressed with this one. I can't smell it real well. It is in wax I decided not to use though because I was having trouble with cold throw so I may give it another shot. Also, I have always had trouble picking up apple scents so I'm probably not the best person to review it LOL
Cardamom and Star Anise - It's an interesting scent and strong but, if you do not like black licorice, you will not like this one
Some I didn't like...
Caramel Popcorn - All I smell is the butter, no caramel. If you need a movie popcorn scent, this would probably work. I haven't tested it for hot throw
Cinnamon Chai - Just do not care for the scent at all. It does have a good hot throw though
Apple Maple Bourbon - Again this could be because my nose has trouble with Apple scents, but i didn't care for this one either. It has a ton of good reviews though so I suspect it's probably just me
Pomegranate Cider - Another one I didn't care for. It's too tart for me
I haven't gotten these in wax yet but OOB scents I like...
Black Sea - It is a cologne type scent but I like it
Cinnamon Stick - I smell cinnamon sticks other people smell red hots
Snickerdoodle - Yummy
Toasted Pumpkin Spice - This is such an awesome scent OOB. I have high hopes it will hold up in wax