My all-time favorite from Candlescience is their Banana Nut Bread. I know it's been around forever but I never get tired of it LOL
Some of my other favorite oldies but goodies...
Hansel & Gretel's House
Lemon Pound Cake
Sea Salt and Orchid
These all throw really well and smell great!
Some of the newer ones I have been tried...
Fallen Leaves - I didn't care for this one. I pick up a cologne smell but that may just be me
Pumpkin Chai - I really like this one a lot! I haven't got it wicked right yet but it's got a good throw so far despite that
Cypress & Bayberry - This is an amazing scent! If you like Bayberry you will love it!
Black Current Absynthe - I can't decide if I like this one or not LOL. It is definitely different and interesting and STRONG!
Hot Apple Pie - I'm not impressed with this one. I can't smell it real well. It is in wax I decided not to use though because I was having trouble with cold throw so I may give it another shot. Also, I have always had trouble picking up apple scents so I'm probably not the best person to review it LOL
Cardamom and Star Anise - It's an interesting scent and strong but, if you do not like black licorice, you will not like this one
Some I didn't like...
Caramel Popcorn - All I smell is the butter, no caramel. If you need a movie popcorn scent, this would probably work. I haven't tested it for hot throw
Cinnamon Chai - Just do not care for the scent at all. It does have a good hot throw though
Apple Maple Bourbon - Again this could be because my nose has trouble with Apple scents, but i didn't care for this one either. It has a ton of good reviews though so I suspect it's probably just me
Pomegranate Cider - Another one I didn't care for. It's too tart for me
I haven't gotten these in wax yet but OOB scents I like...
Black Sea - It is a cologne type scent but I like it
Cinnamon Stick - I smell cinnamon sticks other people smell red hots
Snickerdoodle - Yummy
Toasted Pumpkin Spice - This is such an awesome scent OOB. I have high hopes it will hold up in wax