Don't give up! It sounds like you do this once a year for fun! Always remember that you can always remelt. And to be honest, you can make any wax work. It is generally the scents that may need to looked at. I had tested every "natural" wax on the market up to 2020 and while the the scent throws did differ I could always get something out of them with good scents. And this isn't to say that waxes don't have differences. Some waxes "squash" the scent. Some waxes drown out certain notes (bakery). Some waxes have a smell of their own. But overall, with good scents you can make your wax give you something. And if you do decide to go with a different wax just remember that you can use your old wax up at about 5-10% without changing the characteristics of the new wax. HTH. Now back to the fun with your daughter!